Truthful Speech And Defamation

Summary

In New York, truthful statements are protected under the First Amendment, but context and intent are important. Opinions, such as calling someone evil, are generally protected. If a statement harms someones reputation, they may consider a defamation claim. Legal advice may be necessary to navigate these issues.

Full Conversation

As long as my statements are truthful and don't harm your reputation I should be able to say whatever I want about you.
Hi Patrick! Generally, in New York, you are protected under the First Amendment to make truthful statements as long as they don't harm someone's reputation (defamation). However, even truthful statements can sometimes lead to legal issues, depending on the context and intent.
Are you currently involved in any legal disputes related to this matter?
Dale said my friend Shannon was an evil person
Hi Patrick! In New York, calling someone an "evil person" can be considered an opinion rather than a factual statement, and opinions are generally protected under the First Amendment. However, if Shannon feels that this statement has harmed her reputation, she might consider a defamation claim. Is Shannon looking to take any legal action against Dale?