Contractor Dispute Resolution

Summary

The user is in a dispute with a contractor over payment terms and project completion. The contractor has removed materials from the users property after the user refused to pay more money before the project was completed. The user has a written contract stating that the remaining balance is due at the end of the job. The user has been advised to report the situation to the local police department and to contact the local civil court for further assistance.

Full Conversation

Have construction done at my house and the guy keeps asking for money gave him money for the materials now he wants more I told him that I wouldn't give him anymore until the project is done he still has a door and window and railings to do and rest of the siding to do . should I give in or wait till project is finished to give him anything
Do you have a written contract with the contractor outlining payment terms and project completion details?
Only thing I have is a list of what he is to do within seventeen days to be completed and the amount it would cost and need $*,*.* for materials then $*,*.* on completion got cashier's check for the materials and wrote what it was for
Does your list include any penalties or consequences if the contractor fails to complete the work within the specified time?
No
What state are you located in? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information regarding contractor laws in your area.
Indiana
What is the current status of the project? Is it beyond the agreed 17 days?
Almost done with it but still need screen door and two windows and finish up the siding said his ninety dollars over
What is the exact date when the *-day period ends?

In Indiana, if a contractor doesn't complete the work within the agreed time, you may withhold payment until completion.
Started on the eighteenth last Monday
What is the total amount you have paid the contractor so far?
$*,* out of the $*,*
What is the current date? This will help determine if the contractor has exceeded the agreed *-day period.
Today is the * of July
Based on the dates you've provided, it seems the contractor has exceeded the agreed *-day period. In Indiana, you have the right to withhold the remaining payment until the work is completed.
What do I do last week he told me said I was like some one else when I refuse to give him any money he wanted $*,*.* to pay his rent. Then when I told him know he stated he didn't trust me.so I still have told him know until it's done.today show up at my son's apartment asking for money
Did you inform the contractor about your decision to withhold the remaining payment until the work is completed?
Yes each time
What was the contractor's response when you informed him about withholding the remaining payment until the work is completed?
Not happy told him I would get back to him
What actions has the contractor taken since you informed him about withholding the remaining payment?
I'm going back to see what he did after I in left last time he left didn't do anything
What is the current status of the work after your last visit?
Going to check now as I said he doesn't have that much on left so he can get it done by the weekend
What is the contractor's full name and business name? This information can be useful if you decide to file a complaint or take legal action.
Kyle Montgomery's - Montgomery's contracting & construction
What is the exact location of your house where the construction is taking place?
* So * St Terre Haute Indiana *
What is the exact amount the contractor is asking for now, beyond the agreed $*,*?
Wants $*,*.* now out of the remaining $*.* I owe him
What is the reason the contractor is giving for asking for an additional $*,*.* now? In Indiana, you have the right to withhold payment until the work is completed as per the agreement.
Didn't say
What is the current status of the project? Has the contractor completed the remaining work?
As I said he could get it done by the weekend or early then that if he would get help doing it but himself
What is the current status of the work? Has the contractor completed the remaining tasks?
Hasn't completed remaining tasks his work is good
What is the nature of the remaining tasks and how critical are they to the overall project?

In Indiana, if a contractor doesn't complete the work within the agreed time, you may withhold payment until completion.
Window door and rails finish siding
What is the estimated cost of the remaining tasks (window, door, rails, and siding)?
Around $*.
What is the contractor's response when you tell him that you will only pay the remaining amount after the completion of the remaining tasks?
Didn't say anything told him had to talk with someone will get back to him
What is the contractor's response when you tell him that you will only pay the remaining amount after the completion of the remaining tasks?
Nothing in I walk away
What actions has the contractor taken since your last conversation?
Haven't been back since I talk with him headed back in now to see what he has done
What is the current status of the work after your recent visit?
Just went over he took the window out
What is the condition of the window that the contractor took out?
The old ones were broken and he took the new window
Did the contractor take the new window without your permission?
Took all the window out left
Could you please clarify if you're facing any legal issues related to the removal of these windows?
Not yet
What is the reason for removing the windows? Are there any local regulations or homeowner association rules you're concerned about violating?
He wanted more money I paid him for material since I wouldn't give him any more money till it was done he took the window
What was the agreement between you and the contractor regarding payment and completion of work?
Now I don't have anything in the window all open .
What was the form of your agreement with the contractor? Was it verbal or written?
Yes give him the rest at completions
What state are you located in? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information regarding contractor laws in your area.
Indiana
What evidence do you have of this agreement with the contractor? In Indiana, verbal contracts can be legally binding but are more difficult to prove.
Copy of his contract
What does the contract state about payment terms and completion of work? In Indiana, breach of contract can lead to legal consequences.
Yes contract state I Kyle Montgomery's on reciving $*,*.*$for Materials for siding windows three hand rail screen door,back door . remaining balance $*,*.* cash at the end of the job
What is the issue you're facing with this contract?
He wants money now not at the endof completion
What does your contract specifically state about the payment schedule? It's important to follow the agreed terms in the contract.
He stated remaining balance $*,00cash at the end of job
What state are you in? The rules regarding contract disputes can vary by location.
This is on his contractor invoice
What state is the construction project located in? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information regarding contract law in your area.
Indiana
What is the exact wording in the contract regarding the payment schedule?

In Indiana, if a contractor violates the terms of a contract, you may have legal recourse.
Remaining balance *,* cash at the end of the job
What actions have you taken so far regarding this issue?

In Indiana, if a contractor breaches a contract, you can potentially sue for damages.
Nothing just went back seen the window are out and he took the remaining siding
Did you communicate with the contractor about this issue? In Indiana, it's important to have a written record of any disputes related to contract terms.
Going to call now
What did you discuss with the contractor during the call?
So what should I do now no windows anyone can get in now
Have you reported this to the local authorities? In Indiana, theft or property damage can be considered a criminal act.
Not yet talking about it with you
Have you documented the condition of the property and the missing materials? It's crucial to have evidence in such cases.
Yes
What is the name of your local police department? In Indiana, you should report theft or property damage to your local authorities.
Terre. Haute police department
The Terre Haute Police Department can be reached at (*) *-*. It's located at * Wabash Ave, Terre Haute, IN *. You should report the situation to them.
Ok thanks
You're welcome! If you have any more questions or need further assistance, feel free to ask.
Ok calling police department
That's a good step. Remember to provide them with all the details and any evidence you have.
I need a number or who do I talk to for civil materials
Could you please specify your location so I can provide you with the contact details of the nearest civil court or legal aid service?
Indiana
You can contact the Indiana Civil Court at (*) *-*. They can guide you on how to proceed with your case.
Terre Haute Indiana
For Terre Haute, Indiana, you can contact the Vigo County Courthouse at (*) *-*. They can provide further assistance with your civil matter.