Gift Or Loan Dispute

Summary

In England, if money was given as a gift without a written agreement indicating it was a loan, repayment is generally not required. However, if your friend can provide evidence suggesting it was a loan, it may complicate matters. Gather any evidence supporting your claim that the money was a gift, such as written communications or witness testimonies. If legal action is pursued, consider consulting a lawyer to defend your position.

Full Conversation

No, she sent all the money through her bank account and she got all the bank statements that she sent the money to my account. It wasn’t a loan. It was just a help you helping me and suddenly she just asked me all the money to pay back.
It sounds like you are in a tough spot. Since there is no written agreement, it may come down to proving the intent behind the money transfer.
Here are some points to consider:
- Written Evidence: Emails, messages, or any form of written communication discussing the money as a gift.
- Bank Statements: These alone may not prove the intent, but they are a part of the evidence.
- Witnesses: Any mutual friends or third parties who can support your claim.
Would you like to get connected with a local lawyer who can help you navigate this situation?
She sent me a few money as a gift. Do I have to repay it back?
In England, if the money was given as a gift and there is no written agreement or contract indicating it was a loan, you generally do not have to repay it. However, if your friend can provide evidence that suggests otherwise, it may complicate matters.
Would you like to get connected with a local lawyer for a more detailed consultation?
No
Case Rating: *
It seems like your case revolves around proving the intent behind the money transfer. Since there is no written agreement, it may be challenging for your friend to prove the money was meant to be a loan. However, it would be beneficial to gather any evidence you have that supports your claim that the money was a gift. If your friend pursues legal action, you may need to defend your position with the help of a lawyer.