Aggravated Robbery Defense

Summary

The user, located in Ohio, is facing charges for aggravated robbery. He claims innocence and has an alibi, which is confirmed by his girlfriend. The victim has identified another person as the robber. The user has a court-appointed lawyer and has already fired a previous attorney due to lack of representation. The user has concerns about the current lawyers strategy and feels that the case should have been dismissed due to the identification of another suspect and the withholding of evidence. The user has signed a time waiver in exchange for a reduced bail amount and is currently out on bail.

Full Conversation

Im being charged with aggravated robbery and I didn’t do anything and the victim has identified someone else
What state are you located in, ****? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information regarding your legal situation.
ohio
What evidence do you have to support your claim of innocence? In Ohio, aggravated robbery is a serious felony with severe penalties, including prison time.
i wasn’t identified as the robber someone said that it should like something I would do
What is the nature of the evidence against you? In Ohio, hearsay evidence is generally not admissible in court.
i was in the area and someone said it sounds like something I would do. The victim has identified another person who said it was me
What is the status of your legal representation? In Ohio, it's crucial to have a defense attorney for serious charges like aggravated robbery.
Court appointed lawyer
What is the name of your court-appointed lawyer? In Ohio, you have the right to a defense attorney. If you can't afford one, the court will appoint one for you.
david Washington
What is the next court date scheduled for your case? In Ohio, it's important to attend all court dates to avoid additional legal complications.
*/*/*
What is the name of the court where your case is being heard? This will help me provide you with the contact details.
butler county common pleas
The Butler County Common Pleas Court is located at * High St, Hamilton, OH *. You can contact them at (*) *-*.
ok
What is the name of the person the victim identified as the robber? In Ohio, mistaken identity can be a valid defense in criminal cases.
im not sure
Do you have any alibi or evidence that can prove you were not involved in the robbery at the time it occurred?
yes
What is your alibi or the evidence that can prove your innocence?
i was watching movies at my girlfriends house
Can your girlfriend confirm your alibi? In Ohio, an alibi can be a strong defense if it can be corroborated by a reliable witness.
yes
Has your girlfriend provided a statement to your lawyer, **** Washington, confirming your alibi?
no
It's crucial that your girlfriend provides a statement to your lawyer confirming your alibi. This could significantly help your case.
ok
Have you or your lawyer considered filing a motion to dismiss based on the victim identifying someone else as the robber?
Explanation: In Ohio, a motion to dismiss can be filed if there's insufficient evidence to support the charges.
no
It might be beneficial to discuss the possibility of filing a motion to dismiss with your lawyer, **** Washington.
ok
Has your lawyer, **** Washington, discussed the strategy for your defense with you?
Explanation: In Ohio, it's important to have a clear defense strategy for serious charges like aggravated robbery.
no he has not
What is the reason your lawyer hasn't discussed the defense strategy with you yet? It's important to have a clear understanding of your defense plan in Ohio.
I don’t know why he hasn’t. I have tried to discuss it with him and we are supposed to meet before court
When is your meeting scheduled with your lawyer, **** Washington? It's important to discuss your defense strategy and the possibility of filing a motion to dismiss.
*/*/* the day of court
It's crucial to meet your lawyer before the court date. Can you reschedule to an earlier date to discuss your defense strategy and other options?
I tried and he refused
What was the reason given by your lawyer, **** Washington, for refusing to reschedule the meeting to an earlier date?
he said we can do it the day of
What time is your court hearing and what time is your meeting with your lawyer scheduled? It's important to have enough time to discuss your defense strategy before the hearing.
1pm and I’m scheduled to meet him at noon
That seems a bit tight. Have you considered seeking a second opinion from another lawyer to ensure you're getting the best defense possible?
he is my second lawyer I already fired the first attorney
Why did you decide to fire your first attorney?
lack of representation
What specific issues did you face with your first attorney that led to you feeling inadequately represented?
he wouldn’t admit the fact that someone else was identified and I was innocent
Have you considered filing a complaint against your first attorney for inadequate representation?
I don’t know how to do that
You can file a complaint with the Ohio State Bar Association. Their contact number is (*) *-* or (*) *-*.
what do I do once I call them
When you call the Ohio State Bar Association, explain your situation and ask how to file a complaint against your previous attorney for inadequate representation.
will that help me with my current situation
Filing a complaint won't directly affect your current case, but it can help prevent others from experiencing similar issues. Have you discussed the identification of another suspect with your current lawyer?
Yes I have and he said that proving identity will be difficult but haven’t discussed the motion to dismiss
Have you considered discussing the motion to dismiss with your lawyer based on the victim identifying another person? It might be beneficial for your case.
No but I will
That's a good step. Also, have you discussed with your lawyer about your girlfriend's statement as an alibi? It could be crucial for your defense.
I have but it seems as if he’s cooperating with the prosecution and not being *% honest
What makes you feel that your lawyer is not being *% honest with you?
I feel that my case should have already been dismissed
Why do you believe your case should have already been dismissed?
Because I’m innocent and the fact that they were holding back evidence from my case
What evidence do you believe is being held back in your case?
The photo used to identity the original suspect and not accepting my alibi
Have you discussed this withheld evidence with your lawyer and requested him to demand its disclosure from the prosecution?
I did and it took forever to get it
What was the outcome when your lawyer finally received the withheld evidence?
Nothing changed
What steps has your lawyer taken after receiving the withheld evidence?
He said that we will take it to court
What is the specific evidence that was withheld and how do you believe it could help your case?
the photo and the identification process
What was the issue with the photo and the identification process that you believe could help your case?
I already stated that the picture isn’t me don’t look like me and I wasn’t allowed to be put in a line up
Did your lawyer raise the issue of the photo not resembling you and your exclusion from the line-up with the court?
Yes I have and I still haven’t gotten any different results
What steps has your lawyer taken to challenge the photo identification and your exclusion from the line-up in court?
I don’t know
What was the response of the court when your lawyer raised the issue of the photo not resembling you and your exclusion from the line-up?
it was set for trial but the court keeps continuing the proceedings
What is the reason given by the court for continuing the proceedings? In Ohio, continuances can be granted for various reasons including the need for additional time to prepare for trial.
additional time for trial
What is the reason given for needing additional time for trial?
I don’t know
What steps has your lawyer taken to expedite the trial process?
I had already signed a time wavier
i signed a time wavier that granted them more time
Why did you sign a time waiver granting them more time?
I was incarcerated and they lowered my bail because I signed it
The court reduced my bail bond in exchange for me signing a time wavier
By waving my fast and speedy trial the court lowered my bond
What is the new amount of your bond after it was lowered?
*
What is the status of your bond payment? Have you been able to post the reduced bond amount?
I paid a bail bondsman and I am out on bail
What is the name of the bail bondsman you paid? In Ohio, bail bondsmen are regulated by the Department of Insurance and must adhere to certain rules and regulations.
kevin allen
What is the contact information of your bail bondsman, Kevin Allen?
i don’t have it on hand
That's okay. It's important to keep your bail bondsman's contact information handy in case you need it. Do you have any other questions or concerns about your case?
no