Challenging Dui Manslaughter Sentence

Summary

The user is challenging a DUI manslaughter sentence in Florida, believing it to be illegal under statutes 316.193 (5) and 775.084. The user was sentenced as a Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) and received a sentence of 29 1/2 years with 6 months probation. The user argues that the specific sentencing statute for DUI manslaughter, 316.193 (5), overrules the general statute for HFOs, 775.084, and that the sentence exceeds the maximum allowed under the specific statute. The user is considering filing a writ of habeas corpus to challenge the sentence.

Full Conversation

How do i file a Hale claim?
Could you please clarify what you mean by a "Hale claim"? Are you referring to a specific type of legal claim or case?
Illegal sentence: HFO followed by probatition
What state are you in? The process and rules for challenging a sentence can vary by jurisdiction.
Florida
What is the nature of the illegal sentence you're referring to?

In Florida, you can challenge a sentence through an appeal or post-conviction relief motion.
DUI manslaughter
What is the specific issue with your DUI manslaughter sentence that you believe makes it illegal?
The gave me an illegal sentence under *.* with HFO followed by probation
What is the duration of your sentence and probation? In Florida, DUI manslaughter under *.* can result in a minimum mandatory sentence of 4 years.
* *\* and 6 months probation
What is the specific reason you believe your sentence is illegal? In Florida, DUI manslaughter can lead to a minimum of 4 years imprisonment under statute *.*.
*.* is a specific sentencing statue mandatory probation. Can not exceeed * yrs and i cant get probation with HFO
What is the exact duration of your probation period?

In Florida, under statute *.*, DUI manslaughter can lead to a minimum of 4 years imprisonment and probation. However, the exact terms can vary.
6 months
What is the duration of your prison sentence?
* yrs and *\*
What is the basis of your claim that your sentence is illegal?
*.* is a specific statute and probation is mandatory
What is the exact nature of your Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) status in this case?
U cant exceed * yrs even with probation. It has its own sentencing statute
What is the specific statute number for the Habitual Felony Offender law you're referring to?
*.* (*)
What is the specific issue you have with the application of statute *.* (*) in your case?
They gave me * yrs and *\* with 6 months probation. The statute require mandatory probation inside of the * yrs max and i cant get probation after being sentenced under HFO
What is the exact nature of your Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) status in this case?
What do u mean?
Are you classified as a Habitual Felony Offender due to previous convictions? If so, how many prior felony convictions do you have?
Yes but no DUI
What were your previous convictions for?
They didnt say, jus said my past history
What were the specific charges for your previous convictions?
Drugs, battery
What is the exact nature of your drug and battery convictions?
Sell and possesion
What were the penalties for your previous convictions for selling and possession?
Prison sentence
What is the duration of the prison sentence you received for your previous convictions?
* yrs
What is the exact statute number for the Habitual Felony Offender law that was applied in your case?
*.*
What is the specific issue you have with the application of statute *.* in your case?
*.* (*) is a specific sentecing statute that overrules the general statute of *.*
What is the basis of your claim that statute *.* (*) overrules the general statute *.*?

In Florida, statute *.* (*) pertains to DUI manslaughter, while *.* is for Habitual Felony Offenders.
*.* (*) says i can only get * yrs and * yr probation as required by statute. *.* is a general statute that is overruled by the specific statute *.* (*)
What is the exact wording of the sentence you received from the court?
* *\* yrs and 6 months probation as an HFO
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your status as a Habitual Felony Offender (HFO)?
I found that the defendant qualafies as a HFO basic on his past history
What is the exact wording of the statute *.* (*) that you believe overrules the general statute *.*?
Its specific
What is the exact wording of the statute *.* that was applied in your case?
General
What is the exact wording of the statute *.* (*) and *.* as per Florida law?
*.* (*) is the sentencing statute for anyone who catch a DUI manslaughter mandatory probation under this statute. See John Power v State * DUI manslaughter
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your sentence under statute *.* (*)?
Im still in the DCA pending an Illegal sebtene
What is the current status of your appeal in the District Court of Appeal (DCA)?
Active
What is the basis of your appeal in the District Court of Appeal (DCA)?
Illegal sentence *.*
Illega
What specific grounds are you basing your appeal on under rule *.* for an illegal sentence?
Illegal sentence
What is the specific reason you believe your sentence under statute *.* (*) and *.* is illegal?
* reason
What are the two reasons you believe your sentence under statute *.* (*) and *.* is illegal?
*.* (*) is a specific sentencing statute and in florida u can not get HFO and probation
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your sentence under statute *.* (*) and your status as a Habitual Felony Offender (HFO)?
My sentence is not illegal basic on the HFO and my sentence does not exceed the max of HFO
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding the application of the Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) status to your sentence?
My sentence does not exceed the statutory HFO max
What is the maximum sentence under the Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) statute in Florida?
30 years
Are u in Florida?
No, I'm not in Florida but I can provide information about Florida laws. What specific questions do you have about your case?
Whats your opinion?
As a legal information provider, I don't form opinions on individual cases. However, I can provide information. What specific aspect of your case would you like to know more about?
Do i have an illegal sentence?
What is the exact sentence you received for your DUI manslaughter charge?
Where do i file a writ of habea corpus
A writ of habeas corpus is typically filed in the court that issued the sentence. Can you confirm if this was a Florida court?
* yrs and *\* and with 6 months probation DUI mandatory requirment
What is the exact location of the court that issued your sentence?
Mayo, Florida
The court nearest to Mayo, Florida is the Lafayette County Courthouse. Their contact number is (*) *-*. You can file your writ of habeas corpus there.
No
What is the reason for your disagreement with the sentence?
Thats an different question
I was asking about the writ of habaes corpus because im trying to see where do i file it?
A writ of habeas corpus is generally filed in the court that issued the sentence. In your case, it would be the court in Mayo, Florida.
Do u think my sentence is illegal?
As a legal information provider, I can't make judgments. However, I can help you understand the statutes. Could you please share the details of your sentence?
Im not understanding
Can you clarify which part of the statutes or your sentence you're having trouble understanding?
Is the sentence illegal?
To determine if the sentence is illegal, could you please provide more details about the sentence you received?
Like what?
Question
I'm sorry, but it seems like there was a misunderstanding. Could you please provide the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your sentence for DUI manslaughter?
I have a question
Of course, I'm here to help. What is your question?
Can u get HFO followed by probation ?
What is your location? The rules for Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) followed by probation can vary by jurisdiction.
Florida
In Florida, Habitual Felony Offenders (HFO) may be eligible for probation after serving their sentence. However, this is determined on a case-by-case basis.
What do case by case basic mean?
"Case by case basis" means each situation is considered separately, with decisions made based on the unique circumstances of each individual case.
I got DUI manslaughter with *\* yrs and 6 months probation under HFO?
What is the exact date of your sentencing? This will help determine if any changes in Florida law could potentially affect your case.
* *\* yrs and 6 months probation
What is the exact date when you were sentenced for DUI manslaughter?
*\*\*
What is the current status of your probation?
6 months
What is the exact nature of your legal issue or question regarding your probation?
Can i get probation under HFO status?
What is the nature of the crime for which you were given the HFO status?
DUI manslaughter
In Florida, the possibility of probation under HFO status for DUI manslaughter is determined by the court. Can you provide more details about your probation terms?
I disagree
What specifically do you disagree with?
DUI manslaghter is a second degree felony and * yrs is the max. The gave me * yrs and *\* with 6 months probation. The probation must be inside the * yrs
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your sentence? This will help clarify the terms of your sentence and probation.
29 years and *\* followed by 6 months probation as an HFO
What is the exact wording of the court's ruling regarding your probation terms?
When i get done with the prison sentence i have to do 6 months probation
What is the nature of your concern regarding the probation period after your prison sentence?
Ok
That's great. If you need any more legal information in the future, don't hesitate to reach out. Stay safe!
How long does it take to rule on a *.*
The time to rule on a *.* motion in Florida can vary. It's best to consult with a legal professional for specifics.
How can i go to when paper work on cases are false on appeal
What specific inaccuracies are you referring to in the paperwork? It's crucial to identify these to challenge them effectively.
Changing what said at trial false on appeal
What evidence do you have to support your claim that the trial transcript was altered?
I ask for my trial video but they said that they did not have it
What is the name of the court where your trial was held? Court records, including videos, are typically maintained by the court where the trial took place.
Question
What type of legal assistance are you currently seeking? Are you looking for a lawyer or information on how to proceed with your appeal?
Im looking for a pro bon o lawyer
What is your location? This will help me provide you with information about pro bono legal services in your area.
Tallahassee
What specific legal assistance are you seeking from a pro bono lawyer in Tallahassee?
Looking for someone to take my case so they can get paid off it
What type of case are you dealing with? This will help me provide you with the most relevant information.
DUI manslaughter
What is the current status of your DUI manslaughter case?

For pro bono legal assistance in Tallahassee, you can contact Legal Services of North Florida at (*) *-*.
I want someone not in this area
What is the reason for wanting a lawyer outside your current area?
Conflict
What is the nature of the conflict that makes you seek a lawyer outside your current area?
I had dismissed a few lawyers out of this area already but not aquacte taking my case
What is the reason for dismissing your previous lawyers?
Any other numbers u have outside of Tallahassee
Sure, you can try contacting Florida Rural Legal Services at (*) *-*. They provide free legal aid and are located outside of Tallahassee.
Address
Florida Rural Legal Services, Inc.
Lakeland Office
* W. Main Street
Lakeland, FL *
Phone: (*) *-*
Question
I'm sorry, but I didn't understand your question. Could you please provide more details about your legal issue?
Does the trail judge has jurisdition to do away with the jury findings
What is the specific jurisdiction and nature of the case you're referring to? This can affect the judge's ability to override jury findings.
Jury verdict
What state is your case in? In general, a trial judge can set aside a jury's verdict under certain circumstances, but the rules vary by jurisdiction.
Florida
What is the nature of the case? In Florida, a judge can override a jury's verdict in certain circumstances, such as if the verdict is against the manifest weight of the evidence.
Murder
What stage is your case currently at? In Florida, a judge can override a jury's verdict if it's against the manifest weight of the evidence.
Murder
Could you please clarify if you're facing a murder charge or need information about it?
Does *.* and *.* go together?
Yes, Florida Statutes *.* (Murder) and *.* (Use of a firearm during a felony) can be related in a case. Consult a criminal defense attorney for specifics.
I g
I'm sorry, your response seems incomplete. Could you please provide more details or clarify your question?
I have a writ of habaes corpus. I need to know where do i file it? The proper court?
In Florida, a writ of habeas corpus is typically filed in the district court of appeal. The nearest one to you is the Florida First District Court of Appeal. Contact: (*) *-*.
So i wont be where im detained at?
No, filing a writ of habeas corpus doesn't change your detention location. It's a legal action against the legality of your detention.
Ok
Do you need any further assistance with the process of filing a writ of habeas corpus or any other legal queries?
I heard different
Could you please clarify what you heard differently about the process of filing a writ of habeas corpus in Florida?
That is suppose to be filed where u are detained at
In Florida, a writ of habeas corpus can be filed in the court that issued the detention order. Can you confirm which court issued your detention order?
Detention order?
Yes, the detention order is the official document that authorized your detention. Do you know which court issued this order?
Im out of pinellas county
In Pinellas County, you can file a writ of habeas corpus at the Pinellas County Justice Center. Contact: (*) *-*.
Its a competency issue