Summary
In New York, interactions with minors are subject to strict legal scrutiny. Scenario (a) might not be a crime if non-sexual, as the age of consent is 17. However, scenario (b) could be problematic due to sexually implicit content, even if not saved. The DA would consider factors like intent, age difference, and communication nature. Complimenting a 16-year-old non-sexually by a 21-year-old is generally not illegal, but context matters. Consulting a legal professional is crucial for understanding specific legal implications.Full Conversation
Would a) be judged harshly or b) or both
In New York, both scenarios (a) and (b) could be subject to legal scrutiny, given the strict laws regarding interactions with minors. The DA would consider factors like intent, age difference, and nature of communication. It's crucial to consult a legal professional for detailed advice. Is there anything more specific you want to explore about these situations?
Is a) a crime
In New York, any interaction with minors, especially involving potential sexual or suggestive content, can be legally complex and subject to scrutiny. Scenario (a), where a *-year-old interacts with a *-year-old, might not be a crime if it's purely platonic and non-sexual, since the age of consent is *. However, any suggestive or inappropriate communication might still raise concerns. It's best to consult with a legal professional to understand the specific legal implications. Would you like more information on a particular aspect?
Is b) a crime
Case Rating: *
In New York, scenario (b) could indeed be problematic. Here are some key considerations:
- Age of Consent: The age of consent is *. Interactions with someone under *, especially if sexual or suggestive, can lead to legal issues.
- Sexual Content: Any sexually implicit content involving minors can be scrutinized under child pornography laws, even if not saved.
- Intent and Communication: The DA would evaluate the nature and intent of communications, looking for potential grooming or inappropriate behavior.
Consulting a legal professional is crucial to understand the specific legal implications. If you have more specific questions, feel free to ask.
If someone is * and they compliment a 16 year old girl non sexually is it illegal
Case Rating: *
In New York, complimenting a *-year-old in a non-sexual manner by someone who is * is generally not illegal. However, context matters. If the communication becomes suggestive or inappropriate, it might raise concerns. Always ensure interactions are appropriate and respectful. Let me know if you have more questions!