Homeschooling Laws Florida Misinterpretation

Summary

The user is facing a legal issue regarding homeschooling laws in Florida. The school district claimed that their homeschooling portfolio was insufficient as it did not include evidence of four core subjects: math, language arts, history, and science. The user argues that according to Florida Statute 1002.41, specific subjects are not required in the homeschooling portfolio. The user is seeking legal aid to appeal the judgement. The user also mentioned a truancy case that is still pending.

Full Conversation

Homeschool review in Florida, judgement against us was made based off the school district stating * specific courses had to be in the portfolio
What were the * specific courses the school district stated had to be in the portfolio?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require a portfolio of records and materials. This includes a log of educational activities, reading list, and samples of any writings, worksheets, etc.
Math, language arts, history and science
What evidence did you provide for these courses in your portfolio?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require:
- A log of educational activities
- Reading list
- Samples of writings, worksheets, etc.
Websites containing the worksheets and instructions, along with samples of work including handwritten work, and the names of two reading materials
Did you keep a log of educational activities for these courses? In Florida, homeschooling laws require this along with samples of work and a reading list.
Yes, in the form of what subjects in what month
Did the school district provide a specific reason why your portfolio was deemed insufficient? In Florida, homeschooling portfolios should include a log of educational activities, samples of work, and a reading list.
Because it did not have the four courses mentioned earlier
What was the specific requirement for each course that the school district claimed was missing from your portfolio?
They stated the portfolio had to contain work in the four core subjects
What was the nature of the work you provided for each of the four core subjects in your portfolio?
I only had a few in those subjects, but did not include math. They included the website and work completed, and short stories from one students language arts
Did you provide any evidence of math instruction or activities in your homeschooling portfolio?
No, I did not pick them as a sample
Did you have any math instruction or activities that you could have included in your portfolio?
Yes, but it is not required by law
What is the specific law or regulation you're referring to that states math instruction isn't required in a homeschooling portfolio in Florida?
Statute *.*
What part of Statute *.* do you believe supports your claim that math instruction isn't required in a homeschooling portfolio in Florida?
Section * d * and section * d * and 1d2 e&f
What does Section * d *, Section * d *, and 1d2 e&f of Statute *.* specifically state?
The parent shall maintain a portfolio of records and materials. The portfolio must consist of the following: *. A log of educational activities that is made contemporaneously with the instruction and that designates by title any reading materials used. *. Samples of any writings, worksheets, workbooks, or creative materials used or developed by the student. (e) The parent shall determine the content of the portfolio, preserve it for 2 years, and make it available for inspection, if requested, by the district school superintendent, or the district school superintendent’s agent, upon 15 days’ written notice. Nothing in this section shall require the district school superintendent to inspect the portfolio.
What was the judgement made against you based on the school district's claim?
That we were not providing an education and the children has to enroll in a specific brick and mortar 7 days after the judgement
What steps have you taken since the judgement was made?
Seeking legal aid, bought school clothes and supplies
What is the current status of your appeal or legal action against the judgement?
None
What is the name of the school district that made the judgement against you?
Santa Rosa county Florida
What is the current educational status of your children? Are they enrolled in the brick and mortar school as per the judgement?
2 days from enrolling into the specific brick and mortar
What is the name of the brick and mortar school your children are enrolling in?
Kings middle school
What is the specific reason you chose homeschooling over traditional schooling for your children?
The choice was made based off mental health and providing a more thorough and one on one education for a better chance to succeed
What steps are you planning to take to appeal the judgement?

In Florida, you have the right to appeal a judgement. You may need to consult with a lawyer to understand the process and requirements.
Whatever is needed
What is the timeline given by the court for you to appeal the judgement?
None, state limits it to 30 days I believe
What is the current date and when was the judgement made? This will help us determine if you are still within the *-day appeal period.
Today is Oct *, the judgement happened on Sept *
What is the exact wording of the judgement? This will help us understand the specific requirements and conditions imposed by the court.
Children are not receiving an education at home, and the states recommendation of enrollment into Kings middle
What is the exact location of Kings Middle School?
Milton Fl
What is the exact reason given by the court for the judgement against your homeschooling?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require:
- A log of educational activities
- Reading list
- Samples of writings, worksheets, etc.

The nearest court to you is Santa Rosa County Clerk of Court, located at * Caroline St, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
The exact reason stated was because we did not provide evidence of the children receiving an education that included the four core courses
What steps have you taken to provide evidence of education in the four core courses since the judgement?
It is not required by law
What is your plan to address the court's concern about the lack of evidence for education in the four core courses?
That it is inconsequential due to there being no requirements in the law for four core courses
What is your plan to appeal the judgement?
I am seeking legal aid
What is the name of the judge who made the judgement against you?
Warwick
What is the full name of the judge who made the judgement against you?
Unknown
What is the full name of the school district superintendent who requested to inspect your portfolio?
Karen Barber
What is the contact information for Superintendent Karen Barber?
She is the superintendent of Santa Rosa county Florida school board
What specific actions has Superintendent Karen Barber taken in relation to your case?
Over the course of 6 months, in court she has required written work instead of typed work, claimed not enough samples were given, and refused to accept an evaluation done by a certified teacher, which led to a continuation, 4 months later and the judge declared it useless as it was a new school year for the district, but not my homeschool
What steps have you taken to address the concerns raised by Superintendent Karen Barber regarding your homeschooling portfolio?
I addressed them in court, but it fell on deaf ears, everything I said was a lie from the courts perspective
What steps are you planning to take next in order to address the court's judgement?
Seek legal aid
What is the name of the certified teacher who evaluated your homeschooling portfolio?
Cheryl Trzasko
What was the outcome of Cheryl Trzasko's evaluation of your homeschooling portfolio?
That the children were learning commiserate with their ability, she passed them
What steps are you planning to take to include Cheryl Trzasko's evaluation in your appeal process?
I don't know, I need legal aid
What is the specific legal aid you are seeking? Are you looking for a lawyer to represent you in court or for advice on how to proceed with your appeal?
I need a lawyer, I am being run over from lack of speaking or understanding legalese
What is your financial situation? Depending on your income, you may qualify for free or low-cost legal aid in Florida.
We are on foodstamps and low income housing, we have taken in a nephew from a family member who passed away
What is the age and grade level of your nephew? This information can help determine the educational requirements for him.
He is *, in 5th grade
What is the current educational arrangement for your nephew?
Public school
What is the name of the public school your nephew is attending?
Rhodes
What is the specific reason your nephew is attending public school instead of being homeschooled like your other children?
He wants to
Why does your nephew prefer public school over homeschooling?
He came from a different lifestyle and enjoys the chaos of public schools
What is the name and location of the public school your nephew is attending?
Rhodes Milton Fl
Rhodes, Milton Fl
What is the current educational status of your nephew at Rhodes, Milton Fl?
Passing
Passing
He is passing
He goes to public school
I'm not sure what your asking for
What is the current academic performance of your nephew at Rhodes, Milton Fl?
He is passing
He has grades above c
Good
I don't know what answer you want
What is your nephew's academic performance in the four core subjects at Rhodes, Milton Fl?
He has C's
He is in the 70s for each one
How do I answer this question, I said he is passing
What are his grades in Math, Language Arts, History, and Science?
Math * la * history * science *
I am trying
What specific challenges are you facing in appealing the judgement?
I don't know how to do it
I would like a lawyer
Your not helping
No
What
The amount of duress this situation has put on my family has the seams splitting, I cannot deal with faulty chat bots please get a real person
I'm sorry to hear about your situation, ****. Have you consulted with a lawyer regarding your homeschooling case and the judgement against you?
I cannot afford one
What steps have you taken to seek free or low-cost legal aid in Florida? In Florida, organizations like Florida Rural Legal Services and Legal Aid Society of Palm Beach County offer free legal services to eligible individuals.
I will call aclu today
What is the specific legal help you are seeking from ACLU?

ACLU of Florida can be reached at (*) *-*. They are located at * West Flagler Street, Suite *, Miami, Florida *.
Representation
What is the nature of the representation you are seeking from ACLU? Are you looking for them to represent you in court or provide legal advice for your appeal?
To get the ruling fixed, it was based off information that was wrong, and I cannot get the judge to even look at what the law states
What specific information was wrong that the ruling was based on?
That Florida homeschools had to include the four core subjects in the portfolio
What evidence do you have to support your claim that Florida homeschools are not required to include the four core subjects in the portfolio?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require:
- A log of educational activities
- Reading list
- Samples of writings, worksheets, etc.

The nearest court to you is Santa Rosa County Clerk of Court, located at * Caroline St, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
Florida statute *.* 1d1,1d2
What is your interpretation of Florida statute *.* 1d1,1d2 in relation to your homeschooling portfolio?
It leaves the parent with the right to include in the portfolio the instruction chosen by the parent alone.
What steps have you taken to present your interpretation of Florida statute *.* 1d1,1d2 to the court?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require:
- A log of educational activities
- Reading list
- Samples of writings, worksheets, etc.

The nearest court to you is Santa Rosa County Clerk of Court, located at * Caroline St, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
I said all of this in court, the reply was yes, it is required by law to have the four core subjects
What is the name of the court where the judgement was made?
Santa Rosa Florida circuit court
What is the exact date of the judgement made by the Santa Rosa Florida Circuit Court?

For general information, the Santa Rosa County Clerk of Court is located at * Caroline St, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
September 27th, *
What is the name of the lawyer who represented you in the Santa Rosa Florida Circuit Court?
I was not represented, the judge never offered one, and I can not afford one
There was no lawyer
What steps have you taken to seek free or low-cost legal representation since the judgement was made?
Contacted hslda, stated because it was a pending case they could not do anything
What was the reason given by HSLDA for not being able to assist with your case?

In Florida, you have the right to appeal a judgement. You may need to consult with a lawyer to understand the process and requirements. The nearest court to you is Santa Rosa County Clerk of Court, located at * Caroline St, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
Said it was a pending case
What is the current status of your case? Is it still pending or has a final decision been made?
Judgement was made, and we have to return Nov * *
What is the purpose of your return to court on November *, *?
The case was originally a petition to find habitual truancy over failed county provided online education.
What was the outcome of the petition for habitual truancy?
They found us guilty the first day, without us ever being able to defend the dates of absences
What evidence do you have to dispute the dates of absences?

In Florida, habitual truancy can lead to legal consequences. It's important to have accurate records of your children's educational activities and attendance.
Emails from conversations expressing concern due to delays from lack of login info and class enrollment online
What was the response from the school district regarding your concerns about the delays in login information and online class enrollment?
The children would have to make up the work, and nothing about absences
What steps have you taken to address the issue of your children making up the work due to the delays in login information and online class enrollment?
This is over a year ago, they were trying to make up the work, but it was not working and was not beneficial
What steps are you planning to take to address the issue of habitual truancy in your upcoming court appearance?
They have to be enrolled in a specific school
What is the name and location of the specific school they have to be enrolled in as per the court's judgement?
Kings middle school in Milton Fl
What is the reason given by the court for requiring your children to be enrolled in Kings Middle School in Milton, FL?

General Information:
- Kings Middle School is located at * Ward Basin Rd, Milton, FL *. Phone: (*) *-*.
- Florida homeschooling laws require a log of educational activities, a reading list, and samples of writings, worksheets, etc.
Because our portfolio did not include the four core subjects
What steps are you planning to take to include the four core subjects in your homeschooling portfolio moving forward?
They are not required by law
*.* 1d1, and 1d2e do not require any specific subject be taught
What is your plan to address the court's concern about the lack of evidence for education in the four core subjects?
None, it is inconsequential
What is your plan to appeal the court's judgement?
New question
Can I enroll my children into a private school instead of brick and mortar
Yes, you can enroll your children in a private school in Florida. However, you should check the specific requirements and regulations of the private school.
What if the judge named a specific school for the children to enroll in
What was the reason given by the judge for specifying a particular school for enrollment?
Truancy
The court ruled us habitual truant
The court ruled we are habitually truant
What steps have you taken since the court's ruling on habitual truancy?
I have to enroll them into a specific school, but I am asking if I can enroll them into a private school instead
What is the name of the private school you are considering and its location?
Florida unschoolers it is in Florida
What is the reason you are considering Florida Unschoolers for your children's education?
To keep them out of public school
Because I do not want them in public school
What are your main concerns about enrolling your children in public school?
Failing rates, lack of quality teachers, criminal prosecution for failing to meet attendance, unsafe learning environment, and I would like more time with them
What is the specific reason you believe Florida Unschoolers would be a better fit for your children's education needs?
They are not tied directly to the state, like public education members are
What are the specific benefits you see in Florida Unschoolers that make it a better choice for your children's education?
Broader subject choices, broader education sources,less students per teacher, safety, and no ex parte communication with the state
What is the process for enrolling your children in Florida Unschoolers and have you started this process?
They need shot records, physicals and forms filed
What is the deadline for submitting these documents to Florida Unschoolers?
Before enrollment
Before enrollment can be filed to have them start schooling
What is the current status of these requirements (shot records, physicals, forms)? Have you obtained them yet?
Everything but physical, appointment is on the 9th
What is the name and contact information of the doctor who will be conducting the physicals?
It is the health department in Milton Fl
What is the address and phone number of the health department in Milton, FL where the physicals will be conducted?
* Stewart Street Milton, FL *
The Florida Department of Health in Santa Rosa County is located at * Stewart Street, Milton, FL *. You can contact them at (*) *-*.
Ok
What is the deadline for enrolling your children in Florida Unschoolers?
There is none
There is no deadline to enroll the children into Florida unschoolers
What is the process for transferring your children from a public school to Florida Unschoolers?
I will have to unenroll them first then enroll them into Florida unschoolers
They will be unenrolled from the public school before there can be any transfer
What is the process for unenrolling your children from the public school?
Go to the school and unenroll them at the front desk with paperwork
Simply tell the school you want to unenroll them
What is the name and location of the public school from which you plan to unenroll your children?
Please refer to the rest of our conversation
Yes I need to appeal it, but cannot find a lawyer who will represent me through the process due to the truancy case still pending
What is the status of your truancy case?

In Florida, homeschooling laws require a portfolio with samples from each subject taught. For legal assistance, consider contacting Florida's Legal Aid.
There was samples of each subject taught. They required me to have the four common core subjects
What is the current status of your truancy case? Are you seeking representation for this case as well?
Yes, and we now have be reviewed every month in attendance in court
What is the reason for the monthly court reviews? In Florida, truancy cases often involve regular court reviews to ensure compliance with education laws.
For the attendance during the previous month
What evidence do you have to prove the attendance during the previous month? In Florida, attendance records are crucial in truancy cases.
One tardy so far
What are the consequences of being tardy according to the court's guidelines in your case?
Continue court reviews
What are the specific guidelines or rules set by the court for your monthly reviews?
To appear and answer questions regarding attendance issues for the previous month
What are the penalties if you fail to appear for these monthly reviews?

In Florida, failure to appear in court can result in a bench warrant for your arrest.
Fine or jail
In Florida, if you fail to appear for court reviews:

- You may be fined.
- A bench warrant can be issued for your arrest, potentially leading to jail time.

For more details, contact your local court.
I already know all this, I need help finding the exact court order for the appeal process
What is the specific court order you are trying to appeal?
I don't know what it is, that's why I am looking for help
What is the name of the court that issued the order you are trying to appeal?
Santa Rosa circuit court *
What is the case number or docket number for the order you are trying to appeal? For Santa Rosa Circuit Court *, you can contact them at (*) *-* for more information.
23ty12
What is the nature of the order you are trying to appeal?
Habitual truancy verdict
What is the basis for your appeal against the habitual truancy verdict?
It was founded on incorrect information
What is the incorrect information that the verdict was based on?
That a portfolio requires all four common subjects
What evidence do you have to support your claim that a portfolio doesn't require all four common subjects in Florida?
Florida statute *.*
What part of Florida Statute *.* do you believe supports your claim that a portfolio doesn't require all four common subjects?
The requirements for the portfolio
What specific requirements in Florida Statute *.* do you believe the school district has misinterpreted or overlooked?
1f1 and 1f2
What does Florida Statute *.*, sections 1f1 and 1f2, state about the requirements for a homeschooling portfolio?
It list what is required by the state to satisfy the educational requirements for homeschooling
What specific elements from sections 1f1 and 1f2 of Florida Statute *.* do you believe were overlooked in your case?

In Florida, homeschooling requirements include a portfolio of records and materials. The portfolio shall be preserved by the parent for 2 years and made available for inspection by the district school superintendent, or the district school superintendent’s agent, upon 15 days’ written notice. The inspection shall be confined to the portfolio. The portfolio shall consist of the following:

- A log of educational activities that is made contemporaneously with the instruction and that designates by title any reading materials used.
- Samples of any writings, worksheets, workbooks, or creative materials used or developed by the student.
That it does not require any specific subject
What evidence do you have to support your claim that Florida Statute *.* does not require any specific subject in the homeschooling portfolio?
The very statutes themselves. No where in them does it specifically state what a homeschool curriculum should have
What steps have you taken so far to appeal the court's decision? In Florida, appeals are typically filed with the District Court of Appeal. The Santa Rosa Clerk's office can provide more information at (*) *-*.
The order is in juvenile, I cannot get them, nor was I ever given anything about the order except the summons to appear at the next court date
What is the case number for the juvenile order you are trying to appeal?
* ty *
What specific issues are you facing in obtaining the juvenile order for your appeal?
Ok, your help has been beyond imagination
What is the next step you plan to take in your appeal process?
Compliance
What specific actions are you planning to take to comply with the court's order?
Whatever the judge decrees
What is the next court date and do you have any specific concerns about complying with the judge's decree?
The judgement will be solely based on his thoughts and views without any regard to the laws
What makes you believe that the judgement will be solely based on the judge's thoughts and views without any regard to the laws?
When you have been cut with a knife, you have evidence, when you have been denied due process, in the court, with a transcriber, and video/audio recording, I have to prove it. There is no accountability, and massive hurdles to fight for accountability and justice.
What specific instances led you to believe that you were denied due process in court?
It's not only I believe but based on facts, facts that found in the recordings of each court date
What specific facts from the recordings of each court date lead you to believe that you were denied due process?
I refuse to tell you anymore, dismissal of the truth as feelings is what the court is doing
I understand your frustration. Can you specify which part of the court proceedings you believe was dismissed or not properly considered?
Florida statutes regarding truancy and homeschooling
Florida state statutes pertaining to homeschooling and truancy