Trey Vs Larlar Rule

Summary

The user seeks to understand the application of the Trey vs. Larlar (2020) rule in estate law by using a hypothetical scenario. They reference the Heirs of Magdaleno Ypon case to illustrate how the rule might apply to a new set of heirs. Under strict interpretations, heirs like Ana, Ben, and Carla would need to file a special proceeding for estate settlement, be judicially declared as heirs, and then pursue civil action to address fraudulent titles.

Full Conversation

Under the strict interpretation of cases like Heirs of Magdaleno Ypon, Ana, Ben, and Carla would have faced a significant hurdle. A lawyer might have told them: • "You need to file a special proceeding for the settlement of Juan's estate first." • "In that probate case, you need to be judicially declared as Juan's heirs." • "Only after you have that judicial declaration can you then file an ordinary civil action against Daniel to cancel his fraudulent title and recover the property." CONVERT THIS TO THIRD PERSON
Under the strict interpretation of cases like Heirs of Magdaleno Ypon, Ana, Ben, and Carla would have faced a significant hurdle. A lawyer might have advised them that they needed to file a special proceeding for the settlement of Juan's estate first. In that probate case, they would need to be judicially declared as Juan's heirs. Only after obtaining that judicial declaration could they then file an ordinary civil action against Daniel to cancel his fraudulent title and recover the property.
The user wants to break down the scenario that the new rule from Trey vs. Larlar (*) addresses, imagining "Step One" of how such a case would likely start, leading to the application of this rule. They intend to use a hypothetical example, referencing the original Heirs of Magdaleno Ypon case's facts, while applying the Trey v. Larlar rule to a new set of heirs.
he probate court may make a provisional or prima facie determination of ownership for the sole purpose of determining whether a property should be included in or excluded from the inventory of the estate. This determination is not final or conclusive and does not bind the parties in a separate action concerning ownership. It's merely for the efficient administration of the estate. If there's genuine dispute, the property is usually excluded from the inventory, and the parties are advised to litigate the ownership in a proper ordinary action. SIMPLIFY
The probate court can temporarily decide on property ownership to determine if it should be in the estate's inventory. This decision isn't final and doesn't affect separate ownership disputes. If disagreement arises, the property is excluded from the inventory, and parties are encouraged to resolve ownership issues through regular legal action.
NOW the said property was acquired originally by MELVIN CONTAPAY and is being resold to another buyer all the necessary documents, including owner's copy of the title, is with the above-named person. PLEASE RECTIFY THIS STATEMENT IN A DEED OF SALE. THE CONTENT SOMETHING THERE WAS AGREEMENT VERBALLY TO BUY THE PROPERTY WITHOUT YET CONSIDERATION PENDING RESOLUTION OF THE RECONSTITUION OF TITLE BUT THE HEIRS EXPRESSLY ALLOW MELVIN CONTAPAY TO POSSESS THE PROPERTY COUPLED WITH THE DELIVERY OF THE MOTHER TITLE
Case Rating: *
Here's a simplified statement for the deed of sale:
The property was initially acquired by Melvin Contapay and is being resold. A verbal agreement exists for the sale, pending title reconstitution. The heirs have allowed Melvin Contapay possession, along with the delivery of the mother title.
The property was initially acquired by Melvin Contapay and is being resold. A verbal agreement exists for the sale, pending title reconstitution. The heirs have allowed Melvin Contapay possession, along with the delivery of the mother title. CAN YOU CONVERT THIS TO LEGAL ENGLISH FOR LEGAL FORM
Case Rating: *
Certainly! Here's a more formal legal language version for a deed of sale:
---
Deed of Sale
Parties:
Seller: Melvin Contapay
Buyer: [Buyer's Name]
Property Description:
[Detailed description of the property]
Terms and Conditions:
*. Acquisition and Resale:
The property was originally acquired by Melvin Contapay and is now being offered for resale under the terms outlined herein.
*. Agreement for Sale:
A verbal agreement has been established between the parties for the sale of the aforementioned property. The completion of this sale is contingent upon the successful reconstitution of the title.
*. Possession and Title:
The heirs of the property have expressly permitted Melvin Contapay to retain possession of the property. Additionally, Melvin Contapay has received the mother title for said property.
Consideration:
Pending resolution of the title reconstitution, no consideration has been exchanged or agreed upon.
Execution:
This deed shall be executed in accordance with applicable laws governing property transactions in the jurisdiction where the property is located.
---
Please ensure to fill in the placeholders with the specific details pertaining to the transaction.
NO NOT FORM BUT ONE OF THE TERMS OF THE DEED
Case Rating: *
Sure, here is a refined legal language for one of the terms in the deed:
---
Term of the Deed:
Possession and Title:
The heirs of the property have expressly permitted Melvin Contapay to possess the property. Melvin Contapay is entrusted with the mother title. This possession and title delivery are conditioned upon the verbal agreement pending title reconstitution.
---
Feel free to ask if you need more assistance!
CAN YOU ADD SOMETHING THAT MELVIN ASK THE EXECUTION OF THE DEED FORMALLY IN WRITING WHEREBY ALL THE HEIRS EXPRESSLY APPROVED
Case Rating: *
Certainly! Here's an updated term for the deed:
---
Term of the Deed:
Possession and Title:
The heirs of the property have expressly permitted Melvin Contapay to possess the property, coupled with the delivery of the mother title. Melvin requests formal execution of this deed in writing, where all heirs expressly approve the terms set forth, pending title reconstitution.
---
Let me know if you need further assistance!
IS THERE OTHER LEGAL TERM FOR MOTHER TITLE?
Case Rating: *
In legal terms, "mother title" can be referred to as the "original title" or "root title." It represents the primary document from which all subsequent ownership or rights are derived. Let me know if you have any other questions!
NOW Melvin CONTAPAY is occupying and possessing said property by virtue of the agreement of sale coupled with the delivery of the original title and is being resold. The possessor requests formal execution of this deed in writing, whereby all heirs aforementioned expressly approve the terms setforth, pending title reconstitution. CHECK GRAMMAR
Case Rating: *
Here's a refined version of the sentence:
"Melvin Contapay currently occupies and possesses the property by virtue of a sale agreement coupled with the delivery of the original title. The possessor requests formal execution of this deed in writing, with all aforementioned heirs expressly approving the terms set forth, pending title reconstitution."
Feel free to ask if you need more help!