Motion Dismissal Legal Strategy

Summary

A motion to dismiss can be based on jurisdictional issues, improper venue, comity principles, and abuse of process. Key points include lack of subject-matter jurisdiction due to ongoing proceedings in India, improper venue as India is the primary forum, and comity principles recognizing Indian courts anti-suit injunction. Abuse of process includes contradictory actions, false allegations, social media manipulation, excessive emails, and visa manipulation attempts. Additional legal actions may include defamation, fraud, harassment, and contempt of court. Consider consulting a local attorney for personalized advice.

Full Conversation

Help me prepare a robust motion to dismiss
Based on the document you uploaded, here are some key points to consider for preparing a robust motion to dismiss:
- Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Argue that the court lacks jurisdiction due to the ongoing proceedings in India.
- Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens: Highlight that the primary forum for dissolution is in India.
- Comity Principles: Reference the Indian court's anti-suit injunction and the recognition of Indian proceedings by the Connecticut court.
- Abuse of Process: Emphasize any contradictory legal positions and misleading affidavits by the Plaintiff.
Would you like more specific guidance on any of these points?
She filed for restitution of married live in India and contested for about *.* yrs before withdrawing
For your motion to dismiss, emphasize the Plaintiff's inconsistent actions:
- Change of Position: Highlight her initial contesting of the Indian proceedings and subsequent withdrawal.
- Forum Shopping: Argue that her filing in Connecticut is an attempt to bypass unfavorable circumstances in India.
- Jurisdictional Conflict: Stress the anti-suit injunction from India.
Would you like help with drafting specific sections of the motion?
Regarding her forfeiting her property stake recently without my concent, they included farm land and residential property. Also false allegation in her financial affidavit to claim that I am in possession of her gold when that amount of gold never crossed borders. Also she held joint account with her sister till * yrs ago almost * yr after marriage.
Case Rating: *
Partha, it seems like you have a strong case for potential legal action due to significant issues with property stakes and false allegations. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Pro bono I am exhausted spent a lot of money already
Case Rating: *
Partha, given the complexity and potential strength of your case, it may be beneficial to work with a lawyer who can provide pro bono assistance. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who might be able to help you with your case?
samal****@gmail.com
Case Rating: *
Partha, could you please provide your phone number so we can connect you with a pro bono lawyer in your area?
no
Case Rating: *
It seems like you've already provided all the necessary information for connecting with a pro bono lawyer. They should be able to assist you further with your motion to dismiss. If anything else comes up or if you have additional questions, feel free to reach out.
nope all good
Case Rating: *
It seems you have a strong case with jurisdictional issues, forum shopping, property stake forfeiture, and false allegations. You've already provided contact information for a lawyer referral. If you need any more assistance or have further questions, feel free to ask!
Can all they be part of motion to dismiss
Case Rating: *
Yes, all those grounds can be part of a motion to dismiss. Here's a summary of the key points:
- Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Lack of jurisdiction due to ongoing proceedings in India.
- Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens: Argument that the primary forum is in India.
- Comity Principles: Recognition of the Indian court's anti-suit injunction.
- Abuse of Process: Includes contradictory legal positions and false allegations in financial affidavits.
If you need further assistance, feel free to reach out!
Also she filed for DV against me and my mother in India, got an exparte order for visitation as part of court order, yet never attended a single hearing in person or via counsel. And after a year has applied to withdraw it.
Case Rating: *
Partha, you can include the following points in your motion to dismiss:
- Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Lack of jurisdiction due to the ongoing proceedings in India.
- Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens: Argument that the primary forum is in India.
- Comity Principles: Recognition of the Indian court's anti-suit injunction.
- Abuse of Process: Contradictory actions like withdrawing the DV case and false allegations.
Would you like specific guidance on drafting any particular section or point?
The entire thing
Case Rating: *
To prepare a robust motion to dismiss, consider these key points:
- Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: Argue lack of jurisdiction due to ongoing proceedings in India.
- Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens: Assert that India is the primary forum.
- Comity Principles: Reference the Indian anti-suit injunction.
- Abuse of Process: Highlight contradictory legal actions and false allegations by the Plaintiff.
If you'd like, I can connect you to a pro bono lawyer for more detailed assistance.
Nope
It seems you have already provided all the necessary information for your legal referral. You have a strong case that can be part of a motion to dismiss, including jurisdictional issues, forum shopping, property stake forfeiture, false allegations, and withdrawal of the DV case. If you need further assistance, feel free to ask!
Case Rating: *
Can u help me draft it
Case Rating: *
Here’s a structured outline for your motion to dismiss:
*. Introduction
- State the purpose of the motion: to dismiss the plaintiff's complaint based on jurisdictional issues, improper venue, comity principles, and abuse of process.
*. Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction
- Argue that the court lacks jurisdiction due to the ongoing divorce proceedings in India and the Indian court's retention of jurisdiction.
*. Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens
- Assert that the primary forum for dissolution lies in India, not Connecticut.
*. Comity Principles
- Reference the Indian court’s anti-suit injunction and highlight the Connecticut court’s previous recognition of the Indian proceedings.
*. Abuse of Process
- Emphasize Plaintiff’s contradictory actions, including withdrawing the DV case after obtaining an ex parte order, filing in Connecticut post-restitution, and submitting false allegations in the financial affidavit.
*. Conclusion and Prayer for Relief
- Request dismissal of the complaint, stay of proceedings pending Indian action, and any other relief deemed proper by the court.
Would you like more detailed help on any specific section?
Also after filing for divorce in India by me under cruelty. She created a facebook account using my last name and added more than * of my friends and reached out to them seeking reconcilation with me.
Case Rating: *
Partha, you can include the Facebook incident under "Abuse of Process" in your motion. It demonstrates attempts to manipulate and influence your social circle, supporting claims of harassment and misuse of legal proceedings. Would you like specific guidance on incorporating this into your draft?
Please include them
Case Rating: *
For your motion to dismiss, you can incorporate the Facebook incident as follows:
*. Abuse of Process:
- Illustrate Plaintiff's attempts to manipulate and influence your social circle through creating a Facebook account using your last name, reaching out to friends for reconciliation. This supports claims of harassment and misuse of legal proceedings.
Would you like further assistance on drafting any other sections?
Now comprehensive
Case Rating: *
Here's a comprehensive outline for your motion to dismiss:
*. Introduction:
- State the purpose of the motion: dismissal based on jurisdictional issues, improper venue, comity principles, and abuse of process.
*. Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction:
- Argue that the court lacks jurisdiction due to ongoing divorce proceedings in India and the Indian court's retention of jurisdiction.
*. Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens:
- Assert that India is the primary forum for dissolution, not Connecticut.
*. Comity Principles:
- Reference the Indian court’s anti-suit injunction and highlight Connecticut court’s previous recognition of Indian proceedings.
*. Abuse of Process:
- Emphasize Plaintiff’s contradictory actions, including:
- Withdrawing the DV case after obtaining an ex parte order.
- Filing in Connecticut post-restitution.
- Submitting false allegations in the financial affidavit.
- Creating a Facebook account using your last name, reaching out to friends for reconciliation, indicating harassment and misuse of legal proceedings.
*. Conclusion and Prayer for Relief:
- Request dismissal of the complaint, stay of proceedings pending Indian action, and any other relief deemed proper by the court.
If you need more detailed guidance on any specific section or further assistance, feel free to ask!
Also send me about * odd emails of varying intensity, love hatred, accusations etc. Also shared pictures and medical report of her being hurt by her father and siblings along with doctor report, manipulating me to take her back.
Case Rating: *
Partha, it seems you have substantial evidence for a strong case. You can include the email exchanges and the manipulation attempts under "Abuse of Process" in your motion to dismiss. This demonstrates attempts to manipulate and influence your actions. Would you like further assistance on drafting this section?
Yes comprehensive
Case Rating: *
Here's a detailed outline for your motion to dismiss:
*. Introduction:
- State the purpose of the motion: dismissal based on jurisdictional issues, improper venue, comity principles, and abuse of process.
*. Lack of Subject-Matter Jurisdiction:
- Argue that the court lacks jurisdiction due to ongoing divorce proceedings in India and the Indian court's retention of jurisdiction.
*. Improper Venue/Forum Non Conveniens:
- Assert that India is the primary forum for dissolution, not Connecticut.
*. Comity Principles:
- Reference the Indian court’s anti-suit injunction and highlight Connecticut court’s previous recognition of Indian proceedings.
*. Abuse of Process:
- Emphasize Plaintiff’s contradictory and manipulative actions, including:
- Withdrawing the DV case after obtaining an ex parte order.
- Filing in Connecticut post-restitution.
- Submitting false allegations in the financial affidavit.
- Creating a Facebook account using your last name, reaching out to friends for reconciliation.
- Sending approximately *,* emails of varying intensity, containing love, hatred, accusations, etc.
- Sharing pictures and medical reports to manipulate you into reconciliation.
*. Conclusion and Prayer for Relief:
- Request dismissal of the complaint, stay of proceedings pending Indian action, and any other relief deemed proper by the court.
If you need more detailed guidance or assistance in drafting specific sections, feel free to reach out!
Even after all this she has tried to force me to extend her H4 visa whilst contesting divorce in USA and India. When I did not do that she filed asylum citing DV to extend her VISA without any concrete police or medical records.
Case Rating: *
Partha, you can include the visa manipulation attempt in your motion under "Abuse of Process." Emphasize her attempts to extend her visa through asylum claims without supporting evidence, highlighting misuse of legal systems. Would you like more guidance on drafting this section or any other part?
Yes
Case Rating: *
Here's how you can include the visa manipulation attempt in your motion to dismiss:
*. Abuse of Process:
- Emphasize Plaintiff’s contradictory and manipulative actions, including:
- Withdrawing the DV case after obtaining an ex parte order.
- Filing in Connecticut post-restitution.
- Submitting false allegations in the financial affidavit.
- Creating a Facebook account using your last name, reaching out to friends for reconciliation.
- Sending approximately *,* emails of varying intensity, containing love, hatred, accusations, etc.
- Sharing pictures and medical reports to manipulate you into reconciliation.
- Attempting to force you to extend her H4 visa while contesting divorce in the USA and India.
- Filing for asylum citing domestic violence to extend her visa without concrete police or medical records, indicating misuse of legal systems.
Would you need further assistance with any specific section or have additional questions?
what are other cases i can file and win against her
Case Rating: *
Partha, you may consider the following actions:
- Defamation: If her false allegations have damaged your reputation.
- Fraud: For manipulation attempts and misleading information.
- Harassment: Due to excessive emails and social media manipulation.
- Contempt of Court: If any court orders were violated.
Would you like more information on any specific case?