Family Financial Dispute Resolution

Summary

Verbal agreements can be binding but are often difficult to prove without evidence. In family financial disputes, its crucial to understand any agreements made, even if verbal. Discussing the situation with involved parties, like your father, can help clarify responsibilities. If needed, consider seeking mediation or legal aid for further assistance.

Full Conversation

And David said that me and Dale owe him a lot of money because he pays for our phone bill but he doesn't do it as a favor for us he does it as part of a rental agreement between him and my father my father gave him the responsibility to pay for all of our phone bills me Dale and my father. But he only wants me and Dale because he doesn't like us he claims we owe him over $*,* He wants $* a week from us and he claims he wants his money but we have no income.But I also shouldn't have to because I never said something okay and I borrow money he started paying me Dale mom dad and his phone bill as part of my dad's agreement with him contributing to the house it was their agreement now brother David the oldest one wants money from me and
It sounds like a tricky family situation. A few things to consider:
- Written Agreement: Check if there's a written agreement between your father and David regarding the phone bill payments.
- Rental Agreement: If the phone payments are part of a rental agreement, ensure it’s clearly documented.
- Communication: Discuss the issue with your father to clarify the agreement terms with David.
Do you have any documents or messages that outline this agreement?
Dale from handicapped people with speech impediments who have no income. My brother, David, is demanding that my handicapped sibling, Dale, and I repay him for payments he made. However, those payments were not a loan to us; they were part of his financial contribution agreement with our father. We have no income to pay him back.
It seems like you and Dale are in a tough situation with your brother David. Here are a few steps you might consider:
- Written Agreement: If there's a written agreement between your father and David, it could clarify responsibilities.
- Discuss with Father: Have a conversation with your father to confirm what was agreed regarding payments.
- Legal Advice: Consider seeking advice from a local legal aid organization that can provide free assistance, especially given your financial situation.
Do you have access to any documents or messages that outline the agreement between your father and David?
So David wants money from me and Dale he says we owe him a lot of money
Case Rating: *
It sounds like a complicated family and financial situation. Understanding any written agreements between your father and David is crucial. If these payments were part of a rental agreement, you might not be liable. Discussing this with your father and potentially seeking legal advice could be beneficial. Do you have access to any documents or messages that outline this agreement?
I think they made a verbal agreement that David was to pay the phone bills but there was no written one
Case Rating: *
It seems like a complex situation involving verbal agreements and family dynamics. Here are some steps to consider:
- Verbal Agreements: While verbal agreements can be binding, they're often harder to prove without evidence.
- Communication: Have a conversation with your father to confirm the terms of the arrangement, if possible.
Do you think discussing this matter with a mediator or legal aid might help clarify the situation?
So me and Dale don't owe David anything right
Case Rating: *
It sounds like a complicated situation. Without a written agreement, it's difficult to determine liability. Verbal agreements can be binding but are harder to prove. Discussing with your father and potentially involving a mediator or legal aid could clarify responsibilities. Would you like to consider discussing this with a legal professional?
No
Case Rating: *
It seems like a challenging family situation involving verbal agreements. Without a written agreement, it might be hard to determine liability. If your situation changes or you reconsider, seeking advice from a legal professional could be helpful. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask!
Give me an example police report
Case Rating: *
Here's a basic example of a police report layout for a scenario involving a financial dispute:
---
Police Report
Date: October *, *
Time: *:* PM
Location: Suffolk County, New York
Reporting Officer: Officer John Doe
Case Number: *
Individuals Involved:
- Name: Patrick [Last Name]
- Age: *
- Address: [Patrick's Address]
- Contact Information: [Phone Number]
- Name: Dale [Last Name]
- Age: [Dale's Age]
- Address: [Dale's Address]
- Contact Information: [Phone Number]
- Name: David [Last Name]
- Age: [David's Age]
- Address: [David's Address]
- Contact Information: [Phone Number]
Incident Description:
Patrick and Dale have reported a financial dispute with their brother, David. According to Patrick, David claims that Patrick and Dale owe him money for phone bill payments. These payments were part of an agreement between David and their father. Patrick and Dale assert that they have no income to repay the amount demanded. There is no written agreement outlining the responsibilities, and the situation is further complicated by verbal agreements made between David and their father.
Action Taken:
- Discussed the situation with Patrick.
- Advised Patrick to seek clarification from his father regarding the verbal agreement.
- Recommended considering mediation or legal aid for further resolution.
Conclusion:
The case involves complex family dynamics and verbal agreements. Further investigation may be required to understand the agreement terms and responsibilities.
---
Please note that actual police reports may vary in format and details depending on the jurisdiction and specific case circumstances.