Understanding Contempt Of Court

Summary

The user is going through an uncontested divorce in New York and is concerned about potentially being held in contempt of court for removing their spouse from their health insurance policy before the divorce is finalized. The users spouse is obtaining individual insurance and both parties agree that it would be best for the spouse to be removed from the users policy. However, their divorce agreement explicitly states that neither party can remove the other from any existing medical, hospital, and dental insurance coverage until the divorce is finalized. The user is advised to consult with a legal professional before making any changes that could potentially violate court orders, even if both parties agree to the changes. The user is also informed that contempt of court is not automatic and typically requires someone to file a charge. Penalties for contempt of court in New York can include fines and/or imprisonment, and a contempt of court conviction can appear on a criminal record.

Full Conversation

I don’t have a reason I just want to make sure I can avoid it.
What actions are you concerned might lead to a contempt of court charge?
General Information:
- Avoid disrespecting the court or violating court orders to prevent contempt charges.
- Always consult with a legal professional for advice.
I may not know everything that counts as breaking the rules and could do something on acccident
What specific court order or rule are you worried about potentially violating?
General Information:
- Ignorance of the law is not typically a valid defense.
- It's important to fully understand all court orders and rules.
Some minor things during uncontested divorce
What minor things are you referring to in your uncontested divorce?
General Information:
- Always follow court orders and agreements made during divorce proceedings.
- Non-compliance can lead to contempt of court charges.
If insurance changes occur during the divorce process
Are you referring to health insurance or another type of insurance?
General Information:
- Changes to insurance policies during divorce should be discussed and agreed upon by both parties.
- Unauthorized changes may lead to legal consequences.
Health insurance
What changes are you considering making to your health insurance policy?
General Information:
- Any changes to health insurance during divorce should be communicated to the other party.
- Unilateral changes can lead to legal issues.
Spouse may obtain his own individual insurance and ask to be removed from my policy
What is the current agreement regarding health insurance in your divorce proceedings?
General Information:
- It's crucial to follow the agreed terms about health insurance during divorce.
- Any changes should be mutually agreed upon and documented.
That after the divorce we will have our own. However open enrollment is occurring now and the divorce is not finalized yet
Are you considering removing your spouse from your insurance policy during the open enrollment period before the divorce is finalized?
General Information:
- It's advisable to maintain the status quo of insurance coverage until the divorce is finalized.
- Any changes should be communicated and agreed upon by both parties.
Yes but only because he is obtaining new insurance from his employer and it is best for both of us
Is your spouse aware and in agreement with this change?
General Information:
- Communication and agreement are key in such changes.
- Document any mutual decisions for future reference.
Yes. But the divorce papers explicitly state I cannot remove him from my policy before the divorce is finalized, so even though he agrees it’s best I don’t want to get in trouble
What does your lawyer advise about this situation?
General Information:
- Always consult your lawyer before making changes that could potentially violate court orders.
- Document any mutual decisions for future reference.
I don’t have a lawyer. And if I do violate the court order does that automatically mean I will be in contempt?
What state are you in? This will help me provide more accurate information. Generally, violating a court order can lead to contempt charges, but it's not automatic. It's best to consult with a legal professional.
New York
What is the exact wording of the court order regarding health insurance in your divorce proceedings?
General Information:
- In New York, violating a court order can lead to contempt charges.
- It's crucial to follow the exact wording of court orders.
the spouses] can't take each other off any existing medical, hospital and dental insurance coverage and must keep the coverage you have current." This also applies for life insurance polices.
What is the exact date of your divorce finalization?
General Information:
- In New York, it's crucial to maintain existing insurance coverage until the divorce is finalized.
- Violating this order can lead to contempt charges.
It is not finalized yet
Do you have an estimated date for the finalization of your divorce?
General Information:
- It's crucial to maintain existing insurance coverage until the divorce is finalized.
- Violating this order can lead to contempt charges.
Who would likely to file the contempt charge, if it came to that?
The contempt charge would typically be filed by the party who believes the court order has been violated. In this case, it would likely be your spouse or their attorney.
If my spouse is agreeing to this change, then they likely would not try to file for contempt?
If your spouse agrees to the change and doesn't file for contempt, it's less likely you'll face contempt charges. However, it's best to get legal advice. Is there anything else I can help with?
Would such a simple act of contempt lead to just a fine?
What is the nature of the contempt act you are referring to?
General Information:
- Penalties for contempt of court can vary, including fines, imprisonment, or community service.
- The severity of the penalty often depends on the nature of the contempt act.
Taking spouse off of health insurance policy too soon
In New York, violating a court order can lead to contempt charges. The penalties can vary and it's best to consult with a legal professional. Is there anything else I can help with?
But again. If my spouse agrees to the change. Even if it would possibly be considered contempt, it should not result in them filing for contempt?
If your spouse agrees to the change and doesn't file for contempt, it's less likely you'll face contempt charges. However, it's best to get this agreement in writing. Is there anything else I can help with?
Would a judge have access to my health insurance files without us presenting it to the court?
Are you asking if a judge can independently access your health insurance records without your consent or presentation in court?
General Information:
- Typically, a judge cannot access your personal health insurance files without your consent or a court order.
- Confidentiality laws protect such information.
Would a judge know if I defied a court order without a defendant filing for contempt?
A judge typically wouldn't know if a court order was violated unless it was brought to their attention, usually through a contempt filing. Is there anything else I can help with?
If my spouse is getting individual insurance can I take him off my policy even if the divorce is not final
What does your divorce agreement say about making changes to health insurance policies before the divorce is finalized?
General Information:
- It's crucial to follow the agreed terms about health insurance during divorce.
- Any changes should be mutually agreed upon and documented.
Do Lot of people get away with contempt
It's hard to quantify as it depends on the circumstances and the judge's discretion. However, violating a court order is generally taken seriously. Is there anything else I can help with?
If my spouse agrees that I can take him off my insurance before divorce is final, can he still file for contempt?
Even if your spouse agrees, it's crucial to follow the court order. If you violate it, your spouse could potentially file for contempt. Always consult a legal professional before making such decisions.
In order to be accused of contempt, would one have to have proof
What kind of proof are you referring to?
General Information:
- Proof of contempt usually involves evidence that a court order was knowingly violated.
- The burden of proof typically lies with the person filing for contempt.
If I take him off my insurance because he has his own coverage…
Are you asking if removing your spouse from your insurance, due to him having his own coverage, could be considered contempt?
General Information:
- Violating a court order, even with mutual agreement, can potentially lead to contempt charges.
- Always consult a legal professional before making such decisions.
Yes
If the court order explicitly states not to remove your spouse from your insurance before the divorce is finalized, doing so could potentially be considered contempt. Is there anything else I can help with?
You keep saying could be contempt, what would definitely make it contempt
Definitely violating a court order, such as removing your spouse from your insurance when the order explicitly forbids it, can lead to a contempt charge.
But someone would have to protest the and file that charge?
Yes, typically a party involved in the case would need to bring the violation to the court's attention by filing a contempt charge.
- Always consult a legal professional before making decisions that could potentially violate court orders.
If no one files a contempt charge then I should be ok and not be held in contempt
Are you asking if you can avoid contempt charges if no one files a charge against you?
General Information:
- Even if no one files a charge, violating a court order can still have legal consequences.
- Always follow court orders and consult a legal professional.
Yes
Are you considering making this change without consulting a legal professional?
General Information:
- It's always advisable to consult a legal professional before making decisions that could potentially violate court orders.
- Violating a court order can lead to legal consequences, even if no one files a contempt charge.
No, I am just gathering info
Is there anything else you would like to know about contempt of court or any other legal issue?
I just think that I would rather me and my spouse agree on when is right to change our health insurance plans, regardless of the divorce timeline
Are you considering discussing this with a legal professional to ensure you're not violating any court orders?
General Information:
- It's crucial to follow court orders during divorce proceedings.
- Any changes to health insurance should be mutually agreed upon and documented.
I would like to, but it is such a simple matter, I wanted to avoid a lawyer if I can assure that contempt will not be an issue, since neither of us would be filing for contempt against the other and we are doing what’s best for both of us
Are you considering getting this agreement in writing and signed by both parties?
General Information:
- Written agreements can provide a record of mutual decisions.
- Always consult a legal professional before making decisions that could potentially violate court orders.
That could work. Would it have to be motorized to be legal in NY
Are you asking if the written agreement needs to be notarized to be legally binding in New York?
General Information:
- Notarization can add an extra layer of legal protection.
- It's always advisable to consult a legal professional.
Yes
In New York, notarization is not required for an agreement to be legally binding. However, it can provide additional legal protection. Is there anything else I can help with?
So you are saying anything written and signed by both parties is legally binding?
Yes, a written agreement signed by both parties can be legally binding. However, it's always advisable to consult a legal professional for advice.
What is a usual fine for minor contempt of court? NY
In New York, the penalty for contempt of court can vary. For minor contempt, a fine up to $* and/or imprisonment up to 15 days may be imposed.
Would that be on my criminal record?
Are you asking if a contempt of court charge would appear on your criminal record in New York?
General Information:
- In New York, contempt of court is considered a criminal offense and may appear on your criminal record.
- Always consult with a legal professional for advice.
Yes
In New York, a contempt of court conviction can appear on your criminal record. It's always advisable to consult a legal professional for advice. Is there anything else I can help with?