Refusing Id To Strangers

Summary

In New York, you are not required to provide your ID or personal information to a random stranger who is not a law enforcement officer. Its generally advisable to remain cautious and prioritize your safety by not sharing personal details with unknown individuals.

Full Conversation

If an average citizen in a car is asking us where are you going and then he said can I see your IDs he is asking for our names and personal information and he's not a law enforcement officer and never was a law enforcement officer and the person is a random stranger should I remain silent?
In New York, you are not required to provide your ID or personal information to a random stranger who is not a law enforcement officer. It's generally advisable to remain cautious and prioritize your safety by not sharing personal details with unknown individuals. Is there any other concern you have about this situation?