Vehicle Trade Dispute Resolution

Summary

Trading vehicles without a title transfer can lead to legal complications. Even if the vehicle is registered in your name, taking it back without consent may be seen as unlawful. Police involvement suggests potential criminal elements, even if no charges are currently filed. Consult a local attorney to understand your legal position and protect your interests.

Full Conversation

I wanted to trade my truck for a motorcycle however after getting the motorcycle I didnt like it. I wanted to trade back but, the guy I traded my truck to said no. So, I went to his house, hooked up the truck and towed it back to my house. No title transfers were done and the registration is still in my name. The police showed up today and towed it off and are contacting the SOS office to investigate it. Can they legally tow my vehicle off?
Hey Londrelle! In Illinois, even if a vehicle is registered in your name, the action of taking it back without consent could be seen as taking property unlawfully, depending on the circumstances. The police can tow the vehicle if they believe a law has been violated. Have you had any prior agreement or written contract regarding the trade?
no just text exchanges saying we would trade
In Illinois, even text exchanges can sometimes be considered as a form of agreement, but without a title transfer, you still legally own the truck. However, the action of taking it back without consent can complicate matters, potentially leading to legal issues. It might be beneficial to consult with a local attorney to explore your options. Would you like assistance in connecting with a local lawyer who can help with your case?
but isnt this more civil then criminal? I didnt even get arrested or any charges brought onto me. Police just said they were towing it as evidence and going to contact the SOS office Police to see if they want to invetigate it
Case Rating: *
In Illinois, while your situation may seem civil, the police involvement and investigation suggest potential criminal elements. The absence of charges doesn't rule out future legal actions. You may want to consult a lawyer to understand potential implications and protect your interests.