Verbal Agreement Property Dispute

Summary

Verbal agreements in New York can be legally binding but are difficult to enforce, especially in property matters. Since her name is on the deed, she may have rights to the property. Witnesses like the realtor and sister can strengthen the case. For emotional distress or financial damages, substantial evidence is needed. Consulting a local attorney specializing in property disputes is advisable.

Full Conversation

Can your mother sue for her money back on a verbal agreement of a house she gave her son an early inheritance on. She was supposed to live with him but decided he didn’t pay enough attention to her and now she wants him to pay her pay. Her name is on the deed. It’s been over. 1 year and she has not contributed to any household expense or toward toward the mortgage that she is listed on since she said it was his house.
In New York, verbal agreements can be legally binding but are often difficult to enforce, especially concerning property matters. Since her name is on the deed, she may have a stronger case. Here are a few points to consider:
- Ownership: As her name is on the deed, she is a co-owner and may have rights to the property.
- Verbal Agreements: These can be challenging to prove in court without witnesses or evidence.
- Legal Action: She may consider legal action to clarify ownership or financial contributions.
Would you like to connect with a local lawyer who can better assist with this situation?
No but if there were witnesses to the verbal agreement including the realtor and his sister.
Having witnesses like the realtor and his sister can strengthen the case, as it provides evidence of the verbal agreement. It would still be valuable for your mother to consult with a local attorney who specializes in property disputes in New York. Is there anything else you'd like to know or discuss about this situation?
She also caused family issues by causing my wife to live in fear as we found a large butcher knife in her room when she lived here.
That sounds like a concerning situation. If you feel threatened or unsafe, consider contacting local law enforcement for advice on handling the situation. For property disputes and family issues, a local attorney can provide guidance on both legal rights and safety measures. Would you like more information on how to proceed legally?
No but I will a countersuit be possible for emotional and financial reasons due to her actions
Case Rating: *
In New York, you might be able to file a countersuit for emotional distress or financial damages, but it can be challenging. Here are some general points to consider:
- Emotional Distress: Proving emotional distress requires substantial evidence, like medical records or testimony.
- Financial Damages: If you have incurred financial losses due to her actions, document them thoroughly.
It may be beneficial to consult with a lawyer to explore your options. Let me know if there's anything else you'd like to discuss!