TRY ME!
Balcony Plant Dispute Resolution
Summary
Landlords in Maine must act in good faith and provide proper notice for lease changes. If you have documented prior agreements allowing plants on your balcony, you may have a strong case. Consider temporarily removing the plants to avoid conflict and document all communications. If management involves their attorney, be prepared to discuss the matter further. Understanding your rights and maintaining clear communication can help resolve the issue amicably.Full Conversation
The management is saying I can't have plants on the balcony. I argue that I can have patio furniture and could keep plants on top of the furniture. They state that I am not allowed to even have furniture as the lease states.
It sounds like there's some confusion regarding the lease terms. Here are a few steps you can take:
- Review Lease: Revisit the exact wording in your lease about balcony usage.
- Communication: Request a written clarification from management regarding the discrepancy.
- Maine Tenant Rights: Familiarize yourself with Maine tenant rights which might offer additional support.
Would you like more detailed information on your tenant rights in Maine?
- Review Lease: Revisit the exact wording in your lease about balcony usage.
- Communication: Request a written clarification from management regarding the discrepancy.
- Maine Tenant Rights: Familiarize yourself with Maine tenant rights which might offer additional support.
Would you like more detailed information on your tenant rights in Maine?
I previously discussed this with them and last year they allowed the plants. They had the opportunity to change their website and the lease before I renewed. Now they are saying I cannot. So, what legal recourse do I have? If I continue to keep the plants out there and they confiscate them, are they liable for damages?
Got it. Here are some steps you might consider:
- Review Lease and Documentation: Check if there's any written communication from last year permitting the plants.
- Maine Tenant Rights: Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith. Changes to lease terms should be communicated before renewal.
- Legal Recourse: If they confiscate your plants, you might claim for damages if you can prove prior allowance and lack of proper notice.
Would you like more detailed information on Maine tenant rights?
- Review Lease and Documentation: Check if there's any written communication from last year permitting the plants.
- Maine Tenant Rights: Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith. Changes to lease terms should be communicated before renewal.
- Legal Recourse: If they confiscate your plants, you might claim for damages if you can prove prior allowance and lack of proper notice.
Would you like more detailed information on Maine tenant rights?
Yes please
Case Rating: *
Certainly, here are some key points about your rights as a tenant in Maine:
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
- Lease Terms: Any changes in lease agreements should be communicated clearly before renewal.
- Recourse for Damages: If your plants are confiscated, you may be able to claim for damages if you can prove prior allowance and lack of notice.
Would you like to discuss this matter further or any other specifics related to your tenant rights in Maine?
Certainly, here are some key points about your rights as a tenant in Maine:
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
- Lease Terms: Any changes in lease agreements should be communicated clearly before renewal.
- Recourse for Damages: If your plants are confiscated, you may be able to claim for damages if you can prove prior allowance and lack of notice.
Would you like to discuss this matter further or any other specifics related to your tenant rights in Maine?
Yes please
Case Rating: *
Could you clarify if you have any written communication or proof from last year allowing the plants on the balcony? This will help determine the strength of your case.
Could you clarify if you have any written communication or proof from last year allowing the plants on the balcony? This will help determine the strength of your case.
Yes. I have an email exchange where I argued that my lease allowed patio furniture. The management agreed to allow the plants as long as I removed them during inspections, which I agreed to do.
Case Rating: *
Given that you have written communication allowing the plants, you have a fairly strong case. Here are some steps you can take:
- Document Everything: Ensure you have all email exchanges and any other communication saved.
- Good Faith Requirement: Maine law mandates landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for changes.
Would you like to discuss anything specific about your tenant rights in Maine or next steps?
Given that you have written communication allowing the plants, you have a fairly strong case. Here are some steps you can take:
- Document Everything: Ensure you have all email exchanges and any other communication saved.
- Good Faith Requirement: Maine law mandates landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for changes.
Would you like to discuss anything specific about your tenant rights in Maine or next steps?
Yes to both
Case Rating: *
It seems you have a strong argument with your documented email exchange. Here are some additional steps you can take:
- Review Lease and Emails: Keep all your documentation handy.
- Good Faith Requirement: Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith.
- Written Clarification: Request a written statement from management.
Would you like to discuss the next steps specifically regarding legal recourse if they confiscate your plants?
It seems you have a strong argument with your documented email exchange. Here are some additional steps you can take:
- Review Lease and Emails: Keep all your documentation handy.
- Good Faith Requirement: Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith.
- Written Clarification: Request a written statement from management.
Would you like to discuss the next steps specifically regarding legal recourse if they confiscate your plants?
yes please
Case Rating: *
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Not yet. I would like wording that I can reply to their latest email. Maybe suggesting that the property manager refer the dispute to her legal department. I am hoping they will see it and see that they don't have a case.
Case Rating: *
Here's a suggestion for replying to their latest email:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
Here's a suggestion for replying to their latest email:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
Explain to me the "act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes" point? Can they just say, hey, in 7 days we are changing the terms of the lease and no longer allowing you to have plants on the balcony? Or can they simply argue that is not what they intended in the wording of the lease?
Case Rating: *
"Act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes" means landlords must:
- Good Faith: Act honestly and fairly without deception.
- Proper Notice: Inform tenants of any lease changes with sufficient advance notice, typically before lease renewal.
They cannot abruptly change terms without proper notice. If they argue the lease wording is unclear, your documented agreement can support your case.
Would you like more specific information about Maine tenant laws?
"Act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes" means landlords must:
- Good Faith: Act honestly and fairly without deception.
- Proper Notice: Inform tenants of any lease changes with sufficient advance notice, typically before lease renewal.
They cannot abruptly change terms without proper notice. If they argue the lease wording is unclear, your documented agreement can support your case.
Would you like more specific information about Maine tenant laws?
Yes please
Case Rating: *
Certainly! Here are some key points about Maine tenant laws that might be relevant to your situation:
- Lease Modifications: Any changes to the lease terms must be communicated and agreed upon by both parties.
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must act in good faith, meaning they should be honest and fair without deception.
- Proper Notice: Typically, any changes should be communicated with sufficient notice, often before the lease renewal.
Would you like any further clarification on these points?
Certainly! Here are some key points about Maine tenant laws that might be relevant to your situation:
- Lease Modifications: Any changes to the lease terms must be communicated and agreed upon by both parties.
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must act in good faith, meaning they should be honest and fair without deception.
- Proper Notice: Typically, any changes should be communicated with sufficient notice, often before the lease renewal.
Would you like any further clarification on these points?
Yes please
Case Rating: *
Certainly! Here are some detailed points about Maine tenant laws:
- Lease Modifications: Any changes to lease terms need mutual agreement.
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must be honest and fair.
- Proper Notice: Changes should be communicated with adequate notice, typically before lease renewal.
Would you like to clarify any specific point further?
Certainly! Here are some detailed points about Maine tenant laws:
- Lease Modifications: Any changes to lease terms need mutual agreement.
- Good Faith Requirement: Landlords must be honest and fair.
- Proper Notice: Changes should be communicated with adequate notice, typically before lease renewal.
Would you like to clarify any specific point further?
Can you modify your suggested email response to include that the current lease states what I pointed out to you previously?
Case Rating: *
Sure! Here's an updated email response that includes the lease terms you mentioned:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, the current lease states, "Storage of any items in common areas or balconies (other than patio furniture) is strictly prohibited," which supports my argument that plants on patio furniture should be allowed. Furthermore, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
Sure! Here's an updated email response that includes the lease terms you mentioned:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, the current lease states, "Storage of any items in common areas or balconies (other than patio furniture) is strictly prohibited," which supports my argument that plants on patio furniture should be allowed. Furthermore, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
Can you also add that I pointed the discrepancy in the lease out last year and that they had the chance to modify it before I renewed?
Case Rating: *
Sure! Here's the updated email response:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, the current lease states, "Storage of any items in common areas or balconies (other than patio furniture) is strictly prohibited," which supports my argument that plants on patio furniture should be allowed. Last year, I pointed out this discrepancy in the lease, and there was an opportunity to modify it before I renewed. Furthermore, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
Sure! Here's the updated email response:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I would like to request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Given the documented agreement from last year allowing the plants, I believe there is a valid basis for my position. Additionally, the current lease states, "Storage of any items in common areas or balconies (other than patio furniture) is strictly prohibited," which supports my argument that plants on patio furniture should be allowed. Last year, I pointed out this discrepancy in the lease, and there was an opportunity to modify it before I renewed. Furthermore, Maine law requires landlords to act in good faith and provide proper notice for any changes.
I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Feel free to adjust the wording to better fit your tone and style.
She relied: The balconies at this community are a common area due to the structure of the building. You are more than welcome to contact a legal team if you'd like. We have been very clear since your move-in. No rules have changed. The plants are a size at which they completely block the emergency egress.
I will let Lyndsay continue communicating regarding this issue from here.
Can you confirm the plants have been removed? If not, I will need to come remove them.
Case Rating: *
It appears the management is now emphasizing safety concerns regarding emergency egress, which might complicate the situation. Here's a suggestion for how you can respond:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I understand the importance of keeping emergency egress clear for safety reasons. However, as previously discussed and documented, the plants were allowed last year under the condition that they would be removed during inspections. I believe this agreement should still be honored.
I request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Additionally, I would appreciate written clarification regarding this issue, considering the lease terms and prior agreement.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like to proceed with this response, or do you need further assistance with any other aspect of your tenant rights in Maine?
It appears the management is now emphasizing safety concerns regarding emergency egress, which might complicate the situation. Here's a suggestion for how you can respond:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. I understand the importance of keeping emergency egress clear for safety reasons. However, as previously discussed and documented, the plants were allowed last year under the condition that they would be removed during inspections. I believe this agreement should still be honored.
I request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review. Additionally, I would appreciate written clarification regarding this issue, considering the lease terms and prior agreement.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like to proceed with this response, or do you need further assistance with any other aspect of your tenant rights in Maine?
to which I replied:
Case Rating: *
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Sorry, I had already replied: Julia,
I do not yet need to contact any legal team as my rights have not yet been violated.
But let me assure you, that if you touch my plants, that will be a violation.
The balconies at this community are a common area due to the structure of the building. (Then you should state this clearly on both your website and your lease agreement.
We have been very clear since your move-in. No rules have changed. (The precedent you set last year indicates that this is in fact a change)
The plants are a size at which they completely block the emergency egress. (This is an overstatement)
I will let Lyndsay continue communicating regarding this issue from here. (I understand, thank you, this is not personally directed at you. I paid for a balcony and intend to use it.)
Can you confirm the plants have been removed? (They have not been removed)
If not, I will need to come remove them. (That will be a choice you will need to consider carefully)
Thank you,
Case Rating: *
Given the ongoing communication, potential lease discrepancies, and safety claims, this situation seems quite contentious. Here is a refined response to address their latest email:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. While I understand the importance of keeping emergency egress clear, I believe the claim that the plants completely block it is overstated. As discussed and documented last year, the plants were allowed under the condition that they would be removed during inspections.
I request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review, considering the lease terms, prior agreement, and the need for clear communication on common area policies. Additionally, I would appreciate written clarification regarding this issue.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like further assistance or any additional information on Maine tenant rights?
Given the ongoing communication, potential lease discrepancies, and safety claims, this situation seems quite contentious. Here is a refined response to address their latest email:
---
Dear [Property Manager's Name],
Thank you for your response. While I understand the importance of keeping emergency egress clear, I believe the claim that the plants completely block it is overstated. As discussed and documented last year, the plants were allowed under the condition that they would be removed during inspections.
I request that this matter be referred to your legal department for further review, considering the lease terms, prior agreement, and the need for clear communication on common area policies. Additionally, I would appreciate written clarification regarding this issue.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like further assistance or any additional information on Maine tenant rights?
Sorry, after my response, her manager said this: Robert, your email is not only inappropriate but threatening. Please remove the plants today for an inspection that is happening tomorrow. I will follow up with our attorney and reach out to you this week to further discuss.
Please note, should the plants not be removed today by 2PM, Princeton Properties Management will be forced to remove the plants.
Best,
Case Rating: *
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case?
Not yet, please comment on my last comment
Case Rating: *
It appears the situation has escalated, and the management is now involving their attorney. Here’s a possible course of action:
*. Document Everything: Keep all correspondence and take photos of the plants and balcony.
*. Compliance: Consider temporarily removing the plants to avoid immediate conflict and potential removal by management.
*. Reply: A polite but firm response may help.
Here’s a suggested response:
---
Dear [Manager’s Name],
Thank you for your message. I apologize if my previous email seemed inappropriate. My intention is to resolve this matter amicably. I will remove the plants temporarily for the inspection scheduled tomorrow.
However, I would like to reiterate the documented agreement from last year that allowed the plants under the condition they be removed during inspections. I look forward to further discussing this matter with you and your attorney to reach a fair resolution.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like further assistance or any additional information on Maine tenant rights?
It appears the situation has escalated, and the management is now involving their attorney. Here’s a possible course of action:
*. Document Everything: Keep all correspondence and take photos of the plants and balcony.
*. Compliance: Consider temporarily removing the plants to avoid immediate conflict and potential removal by management.
*. Reply: A polite but firm response may help.
Here’s a suggested response:
---
Dear [Manager’s Name],
Thank you for your message. I apologize if my previous email seemed inappropriate. My intention is to resolve this matter amicably. I will remove the plants temporarily for the inspection scheduled tomorrow.
However, I would like to reiterate the documented agreement from last year that allowed the plants under the condition they be removed during inspections. I look forward to further discussing this matter with you and your attorney to reach a fair resolution.
Best regards,
[Your Name]
---
Would you like further assistance or any additional information on Maine tenant rights?
Start a new chat