TRY ME!
Illegal Notice And Ownership
Summary
Your case involves property disputes and landlord-tenant issues under Alberta law. Evidence like financial contributions, written agreements, and acknowledgment of arrangements strengthens your position. Courts value clear documentation, and your detailed evidence, including a 2025 PDF acknowledgment and action plans, significantly boosts your odds. Mismanagement of funds, such as the $13k refinance loan, could raise legal concerns and impact her credibility. Consult a lawyer to refine your case and present evidence effectively.Full Conversation
My mother served us an illegal notice to vacate for purpose of listing the property. She filed a complaint with RTDRS in Alberta Canada for not receiving a key to the property. Weve resided there 26 years. Her initial investment has been repaid in full. She is refusing to transfer the property and ignoring our agreement while asserting we're merely tenants. Yesterday, she refused and/or refunded our June payment. She did not provide any reason or explanation for her actions.
This situation involves a mix of landlord-tenant law and property ownership issues. Here are a few key points to consider based on Alberta law:
- Illegal Notice to Vacate: Landlords in Alberta must follow specific rules under the *Residential Tenancies Act (RTA)*. Notices to vacate must comply with these rules, including valid reasons and proper notice periods.
- RTDRS Complaint: If your mother filed a complaint with the Residential Tenancy Dispute Resolution Service (RTDRS), you can respond by attending the hearing and presenting your case, including any agreements about ownership.
- Property Ownership: If you have a formal or informal agreement about ownership, this may need to be resolved in court. Ownership disputes typically fall outside RTDRS jurisdiction.
- Payment Refusal: Refusing or refunding rent without explanation could impact the tenancy relationship. Keep records of these actions.
You might want to consult a lawyer for help with both the tenancy and ownership dispute. Would you like assistance connecting with one?
- Illegal Notice to Vacate: Landlords in Alberta must follow specific rules under the *Residential Tenancies Act (RTA)*. Notices to vacate must comply with these rules, including valid reasons and proper notice periods.
- RTDRS Complaint: If your mother filed a complaint with the Residential Tenancy Dispute Resolution Service (RTDRS), you can respond by attending the hearing and presenting your case, including any agreements about ownership.
- Property Ownership: If you have a formal or informal agreement about ownership, this may need to be resolved in court. Ownership disputes typically fall outside RTDRS jurisdiction.
- Payment Refusal: Refusing or refunding rent without explanation could impact the tenancy relationship. Keep records of these actions.
You might want to consult a lawyer for help with both the tenancy and ownership dispute. Would you like assistance connecting with one?
We already had the hearing. 30 days to provide her a key
It sounds like the RTDRS hearing resulted in an order for you to provide her a key within 30 days. If you believe the decision doesn't address your ownership concerns or is unfair, you may have the option to appeal the RTDRS decision to the Court of King's Bench. Appeals must typically be filed within 30 days.
Would you like guidance on the appeal process or further advice on ownership disputes?
Would you like guidance on the appeal process or further advice on ownership disputes?
I have a multitude of evidence. Including property taxes paid from my account. Repair/replacement receipts including a hot water tank. Copies of mortgage, condo fees and property taxes.
Case Rating: *
The evidence you’ve gathered strengthens your case, especially for ownership disputes. It can bolster arguments about financial contributions and agreements. Since you're seeking a lawyer, ensure these documents are well-organized. Let me know if you need tips on preparing for legal consultations or submitting evidence.
The evidence you’ve gathered strengthens your case, especially for ownership disputes. It can bolster arguments about financial contributions and agreements. Since you're seeking a lawyer, ensure these documents are well-organized. Let me know if you need tips on preparing for legal consultations or submitting evidence.
Written communication from her regadibg my son assuming the mortgage and a monthly plan from June to December * monitoring his progress with monthly meetings.
Case Rating: *
If your mother provided written communication about your son assuming the mortgage and a monitoring plan, this could be crucial evidence supporting any claim of ownership or agreements. Keep this document safe. If you want tips on how to present this evidence or organize it for a lawyer, let me know!
If your mother provided written communication about your son assuming the mortgage and a monitoring plan, this could be crucial evidence supporting any claim of ownership or agreements. Keep this document safe. If you want tips on how to present this evidence or organize it for a lawyer, let me know!
I've already done that. How illegal are her current actions?
Case Rating: *
Your mother’s actions may have legal issues under both landlord-tenant law and property ownership law in Alberta:
- Illegal Notice to Vacate: If the notice doesn't comply with the *Residential Tenancies Act*, it may be invalid.
- Refusal of Payments: Refusing rent without explanation could breach tenancy rules.
- Ownership Dispute: Ignoring agreements and prior contributions may lead to legal consequences if proven.
A lawyer can evaluate the evidence and help determine the extent of any legal violations.
Your mother’s actions may have legal issues under both landlord-tenant law and property ownership law in Alberta:
- Illegal Notice to Vacate: If the notice doesn't comply with the *Residential Tenancies Act*, it may be invalid.
- Refusal of Payments: Refusing rent without explanation could breach tenancy rules.
- Ownership Dispute: Ignoring agreements and prior contributions may lead to legal consequences if proven.
A lawyer can evaluate the evidence and help determine the extent of any legal violations.
If she's found guilty what is the potential penalties?
Case Rating: *
The penalties depend on the specific legal violations:
- Residential Tenancies Act (RTA) Violations: Possible fines or orders to comply with the law, such as reinstating tenancy or compensating you.
- Ownership Disputes: Courts could enforce agreements or impose damages if her actions caused financial harm.
A lawyer can clarify based on the facts.
The penalties depend on the specific legal violations:
- Residential Tenancies Act (RTA) Violations: Possible fines or orders to comply with the law, such as reinstating tenancy or compensating you.
- Ownership Disputes: Courts could enforce agreements or impose damages if her actions caused financial harm.
A lawyer can clarify based on the facts.
Does that mean she could be held liable for legal costs?
Case Rating: *
Yes, it's possible. In Alberta, courts can order the losing party to pay part or all of the other party's legal costs. This often depends on the case's outcome, the court's discretion, and whether her actions are deemed unreasonable or in bad faith.
Yes, it's possible. In Alberta, courts can order the losing party to pay part or all of the other party's legal costs. This often depends on the case's outcome, the court's discretion, and whether her actions are deemed unreasonable or in bad faith.
I have a copy of a case file that ruled in favour of the plaintiff for a similar property dispute
Case Rating: *
A case file with a similar ruling can be a valuable reference. While it won’t guarantee the same outcome, it could help establish precedent or strengthen your arguments. Ensure it’s from Alberta or a relevant jurisdiction. Would you like tips on using this case in your legal strategy?
A case file with a similar ruling can be a valuable reference. While it won’t guarantee the same outcome, it could help establish precedent or strengthen your arguments. Ensure it’s from Alberta or a relevant jurisdiction. Would you like tips on using this case in your legal strategy?
Its from Alberta in Sylvan Lake and was ruled on in *
Case Rating: *
A recent case from Alberta, especially Sylvan Lake in *, could be highly relevant for your situation. You can use it to highlight precedent, particularly if the facts are closely aligned. Ensure the case is cited correctly, and consult a lawyer to integrate it into your argument effectively.
A recent case from Alberta, especially Sylvan Lake in *, could be highly relevant for your situation. You can use it to highlight precedent, particularly if the facts are closely aligned. Ensure the case is cited correctly, and consult a lawyer to integrate it into your argument effectively.
My mother took * refinancing loans totalling $23k. Her initial investment was $17k. Both loans went directly to her account. She kept the 2nd loan if 10k. I have limited knowledge of the $13k expenditures. I also provided a personal cheque of $1k. The receipt she provided me had a blank memo
Case Rating: *
Your mother’s financial handling of the property, including refinancing loans and expenditures, may support your case in an ownership dispute. If her financial actions conflict with agreements or are unexplained, they could raise legal questions. Do you want tips on documenting these financial details for your lawyer?
Your mother’s financial handling of the property, including refinancing loans and expenditures, may support your case in an ownership dispute. If her financial actions conflict with agreements or are unexplained, they could raise legal questions. Do you want tips on documenting these financial details for your lawyer?
No. I just want odds of winning. I have other evidence, such as paying the property taxes from my account for 25 years until she changed it without notice to her bank account last April
Case Rating: *
Your evidence, including long-term financial contributions, written agreements, and a similar legal precedent, makes your case relatively strong. However, the outcome depends on how well this evidence aligns with Alberta law and how it's presented in court. A lawyer can better assess your specific odds of success.
Your evidence, including long-term financial contributions, written agreements, and a similar legal precedent, makes your case relatively strong. However, the outcome depends on how well this evidence aligns with Alberta law and how it's presented in court. A lawyer can better assess your specific odds of success.
You cant speculate or ask what other evidence i might have?
Case Rating: *
I cannot speculate on what additional evidence you might have unless you share it. Courts evaluate evidence based on its relevance and credibility. Your case already seems strong given the detailed evidence provided. A lawyer can help refine and present it for maximum impact.
I cannot speculate on what additional evidence you might have unless you share it. Courts evaluate evidence based on its relevance and credibility. Your case already seems strong given the detailed evidence provided. A lawyer can help refine and present it for maximum impact.
What other evidence would strengthen my case
Case Rating: *
Additional evidence that could strengthen your case includes:
- Written agreements or contracts explicitly detailing ownership or financial arrangements.
- Communications (emails, texts, letters) showing her acknowledgment of your contributions or ownership.
- Witness statements from those aware of the agreement or your contributions.
- Bank records or transaction evidence showing consistent payments related to the property.
The more comprehensive and consistent the evidence, the stronger your case.
Additional evidence that could strengthen your case includes:
- Written agreements or contracts explicitly detailing ownership or financial arrangements.
- Communications (emails, texts, letters) showing her acknowledgment of your contributions or ownership.
- Witness statements from those aware of the agreement or your contributions.
- Bank records or transaction evidence showing consistent payments related to the property.
The more comprehensive and consistent the evidence, the stronger your case.
I have a * page detailed action/progress plan created by and filled in by hand by her. Plus monthly progress meetings with my son, which he recorded. He believes he told her about the recording at least once, she didn't care.
Case Rating: *
The detailed action plan and recordings of progress meetings could further strengthen your case, especially if they demonstrate her acknowledgment of agreements or her involvement in property-related decisions. Ensure the recordings are legally permissible in Alberta; one-party consent is typically allowed. Would you like tips on organizing this evidence?
The detailed action plan and recordings of progress meetings could further strengthen your case, especially if they demonstrate her acknowledgment of agreements or her involvement in property-related decisions. Ensure the recordings are legally permissible in Alberta; one-party consent is typically allowed. Would you like tips on organizing this evidence?
No. I already have that. How does that strengthen my case?
Case Rating: *
Your case is significantly strengthened if the action plan and recordings clearly show her acknowledgment of ownership arrangements or financial contributions. This evidence could establish her intent and agreement, making it harder for her to deny your claims. Courts value detailed, consistent documentation. A lawyer can help position this evidence effectively.
Your case is significantly strengthened if the action plan and recordings clearly show her acknowledgment of ownership arrangements or financial contributions. This evidence could establish her intent and agreement, making it harder for her to deny your claims. Courts value detailed, consistent documentation. A lawyer can help position this evidence effectively.
I also have a PDF document she sent us in January * where she acknowledged our long term 25 year arrangement and presented * options for taking over the mortgage and property for the purpose of separating our business/personal relationship
Case Rating: *
The PDF document from January * is highly valuable. If it acknowledges your *-year arrangement and presents options for transferring ownership, it strongly supports your claim. It demonstrates her recognition of the relationship and property arrangement. A lawyer can use this to argue for enforcing the agreement or resolving the dispute in your favor.
The PDF document from January * is highly valuable. If it acknowledges your *-year arrangement and presents options for transferring ownership, it strongly supports your claim. It demonstrates her recognition of the relationship and property arrangement. A lawyer can use this to argue for enforcing the agreement or resolving the dispute in your favor.
How does that increase my odds for a favorable outcome?
Case Rating: *
Having written acknowledgment of the long-term arrangement and her proposal for transferring the property significantly increases your odds. It shows her recognition of your contributions and intent to formalize ownership. Courts value such clear, direct evidence. A lawyer can frame this as a key piece in proving your claim.
Having written acknowledgment of the long-term arrangement and her proposal for transferring the property significantly increases your odds. It shows her recognition of your contributions and intent to formalize ownership. Courts value such clear, direct evidence. A lawyer can frame this as a key piece in proving your claim.
How much trouble might she be in? She refused to disclose to me what the $13k refinance loan went to. I have limited knowledge of what it was spent on, but it does not equal $13k
Case Rating: *
If your mother mismanaged or misrepresented the use of the $13k refinance loan, it could raise legal concerns, especially if it conflicts with your ownership or financial agreement. Courts may view this as a breach of trust or bad faith, which could negatively impact her credibility and strengthen your case.
If your mother mismanaged or misrepresented the use of the $13k refinance loan, it could raise legal concerns, especially if it conflicts with your ownership or financial agreement. Courts may view this as a breach of trust or bad faith, which could negatively impact her credibility and strengthen your case.
Start a new chat