Passenger Id Requirements

Summary

Passengers in most states, including Florida, are not required to provide ID during a traffic stop unless theres reasonable suspicion of a crime. Some states like Nevada and Colorado have stop and identify laws that may apply under certain conditions. Recording police is generally legal in public spaces, including traffic stops, as long as it does not interfere with their duties. Contesting a window tint ticket may be possible if the devices accuracy is questionable.

Full Conversation

Is there any law in any state that says being in a car that is stopped by the police requires someone other than the driver to give their ID to the police?
In Arizona, passengers in a car stopped by police are generally not required to provide identification unless there is reasonable suspicion of a crime. However, refusal may escalate the situation.
Are you dealing with a specific incident where this happened?
No. Are there any other states that DO require this?
Hey there! In general, most states do not require passengers to provide identification during a traffic stop unless there is reasonable suspicion of a crime. However, some states like Colorado and Nevada have "stop and identify" statutes that might apply in some situations.
Is there anything else you would like to know about this topic?
Does stop and identify apply to someone other than the driver of a car?
Yes, "stop and identify" laws can apply to passengers in some states under certain conditions. For example:
- Nevada: Passengers must provide identification if police have reasonable suspicion of criminal activity.
- Colorado: Similar laws apply, where passengers may need to identify themselves if suspected of involvement in a crime.
Is there a specific state or scenario you are inquiring about?
Watching this video:
Case Rating: *
It looks like you are seeking general information regarding "stop and identify" laws in different states. If you have any specific questions or situations in mind, feel free to ask!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgyCwyGWI9k
Case Rating: *
It looks like you are seeking general information about "stop and identify" laws as they apply to passengers in a vehicle during a police stop. The information provided should help clarify your question.
If you have any other questions or need further clarification, feel free to ask!
Can you watch youtube videos?
Case Rating: *
I can't watch YouTube videos directly. However, I can help answer any questions you have about the content. Can you describe what the video is about or any specific questions you have after watching it?
Cops in florida pulled a driver over for revving their engine too much (he was actually downshifting) and then they are citing him for having slightly too dark tint. The cop then tries to force the passenger of the car to give their ID out. They cited a case Johnson v Nocco which seems completely irrelevant. They also advised he was not allowed to record them which I believe is legal across the country.
Case Rating: *
The situation you described involves several legal issues:
- Tinted Windows: Florida law prohibits excessively dark window tints. However, the specific measurements and limits can be contested in court.
- Passenger ID: Generally, passengers are not required to provide ID unless there is reasonable suspicion of a crime.
- Recording Police: It is generally legal to record police in public spaces, including traffic stops, as long as it does not interfere with their duties.
Would you like more detailed information on any of these points?
He used some kind of device to measure tint and said it's *% and the legal limit is *%. That sounds like something that would easily be thrown out in court, yes?
Case Rating: *
It's possible to contest the accuracy of the device used to measure window tint in court. However, the success of the argument depends on several factors, including evidence of the device's calibration and the officer's training.
Would you like more information on how to contest a window tint ticket in Arizona?