Severance In Criminal Cases

Summary

In Kentucky, to seek severance from a co-defendant, you must demonstrate that a joint trial would prejudice your defense. This includes showing that defenses are antagonistic or that evidence against the co-defendant is prejudicial to you. To obtain body camera footage, submit a request under the Kentucky Open Records Act. Access evidence through a discovery motion. Jail phone calls can be used as evidence. Consult a lawyer for guidance on these legal processes.

Full Conversation

What do I need to prove to the court in order to get severance from a codefendant in a criminal case?
In Kentucky, to seek severance from a co-defendant in a criminal case, you generally need to prove:
- A joint trial would be prejudicial to your defense.
- The defenses are antagonistic or mutually exclusive.
- Evidence against the co-defendant would be prejudicial to you.
Is there a specific reason you believe severance is necessary in your case?
The co defendant stated to the officer arresting us that the drugs weren’t mine and it is on body camera footage, and the arresting officer said in the court of law that he stated they were his drugs in front of the judge during pre-trial. But they are still trying me for the equal charges for drugs that were not mine. I was just driving the car.
In your situation, proving severance might hinge on demonstrating that the evidence against your co-defendant is prejudicial to you. The body camera footage and the officer's statement could be crucial. Have you consulted with a lawyer about using this evidence to support your case?
How can I get the body camera footage from the arresting officer?
In Kentucky, to obtain body camera footage, you can:
- Submit a written request to the police department under the Kentucky Open Records Act.
- Specify the date, time, and location of the incident.
- Consider consulting a lawyer to help ensure the request is properly filed.
Have you already reached out to the police department for this footage?
How can I access any of the evidence being used to build a case against me for which the prosecutor and arresting officers have?
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, to access evidence against you, you can:
- File a discovery motion through your lawyer.
- Request evidence disclosure from the prosecutor.
- Review the evidence list and request specific items.
Have you consulted with a lawyer about filing a discovery motion?
Is there a timeframe for which evidence can still be presented or not be presented in a criminal case in the state of Kentucky?
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, evidence must be disclosed by both parties before trial through the discovery process. The timeline can vary, but generally, evidence should be presented before the trial begins. Deadlines for evidence presentation are often set by the court, and failure to present evidence by those deadlines can result in exclusion.
Have you been given any deadlines or discovery timeline by the court or your lawyer?
The case is in the district court, as we wait arraignment and date what part of the process is it in now then?
Case Rating: *
At this stage, since you're awaiting arraignment, your case is still in the pre-trial phase. Here, the court will formally read the charges, and you can enter a plea. Following this, pre-trial motions, including discovery and potential plea bargaining, may occur before the trial date is set.
If you need more detailed advice, consider consulting a local attorney to guide you through the process.
What can I be preparing at this stage of the criminal case to have all of my ducks in a row?
Case Rating: *
At this stage, you should focus on the following:
- Gather all evidence that supports your defense, such as the body camera footage.
- Discuss potential defense strategies with your lawyer.
- Ensure all necessary motions, like for discovery or severance, are timely filed.
- Prepare character references or any other supportive documentation.
Would you like any further information on any of these steps?
How can I get the officer to state what was said in the body camera footage which would capture my code defendant claiming the drugs were his and that I had nothing to do with it
Case Rating: *
To get the officer to state what's on the body camera footage, consider these steps:
- Request the officer's testimony during the pre-trial motion.
- Subpoena the officer to testify about the footage.
- Consult with your lawyer to file necessary motions for the officer's statement.
Have you already discussed this plan with your lawyer?
I also know that my codefendant has been approached by the arresting officer to inform the prosecution of other people other outlets to try to put more evidence on me. How do I handle this?
Case Rating: *
In this situation, it's crucial to:
- Discuss with your lawyer any potential implications of your co-defendant's cooperation with the prosecution.
- Gather as much evidence as possible to support your defense.
- Consider negotiating a plea deal if advised by your attorney.
Have you had a chance to discuss these concerns with your lawyer?
If the code defendant is trying to put more blame on me, then is due how can I defend myself or get insights as to what evidence they would use against me so I can create a strong defense and prove otherwise
Case Rating: *
To effectively defend yourself, consider these steps:
- Discovery Process: Ensure your lawyer requests full disclosure of all evidence the prosecution intends to use.
- Witness Testimony: Subpoena any officers or individuals who can provide testimony supporting your defense.
- Evidence Collection: Gather any documentation or footage that supports your claim.
Have you already started working with a lawyer?
If my code defendant is blaming the majority of the charges on me well none of the drugs were mine. What do I do?
Case Rating: *
In your situation, consider these steps:
- Consult a Lawyer: It's crucial to have legal representation to navigate the complexities of your case.
- Gather Evidence: Ensure you have all evidence, including body camera footage, to support your defense.
- Witness Testimony: Consider having the officer testify about the footage.
- Discovery: Make sure your lawyer requests all evidence from the prosecution.
Have you already begun working with a lawyer on this case?
If I have my code defendant on recorded jail line stating that he takes responsibility for all the drugs and the charges. Can I use that recording in my defense to drop the case?
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, using a recorded jail call as evidence may depend on its admissibility. Consider these steps:
- Ensure the recording is legally obtained.
- Discuss its admissibility with your lawyer.
- Present it as evidence in pre-trial motions.
Have you consulted with a lawyer regarding this recording?
How likely is it that jail phone conversations could be used against myself and my codefendant in the pre-trial phase to prove anything
Case Rating: *
Jail phone conversations can often be used in court as evidence. In Kentucky, these calls are generally recorded and can be used to prove your or your co-defendant's statements. Always discuss potential evidence with your lawyer to prepare a robust defense. Have you talked to your lawyer about this specific concern yet?
Is there a way to search an officers record?
Case Rating: *
To search an officer's record in Kentucky, you can:
- Submit a request under the Kentucky Open Records Act.
- Contact the police department's internal affairs or professional standards division.
- Consult a lawyer for guidance on obtaining records for legal proceedings.
Have you considered reaching out to a lawyer regarding this inquiry?
If the Scott County Police Department continues to use informants or people from previous criminal cases to turn on other people so they can get lesser sentencing is that illegal?
Case Rating: *
Using informants or individuals from previous cases to testify for a reduced sentence is generally legal in the U.S., including Kentucky. It's part of the plea bargaining process. However, any misconduct or coercion by law enforcement during this process could be challenged. Have you discussed this concern with a lawyer?
How can an informant story hold up or be proven truthful in a criminal case?
Case Rating: *
An informant's story can hold up in a criminal case if supported by:
- Corroborating evidence or witnesses.
- Consistent statements over time.
- Verification of the informant's reliability and history.
- Cross-examination during trial to test credibility.
Would you like more information on any of these points?
If my codefendant has a big criminal record in other states as well as a pending case which will get a verdict before our case, sees a judge, may I use or reference any of that to source their character?
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, a co-defendant's criminal record and pending cases might be relevant if they impact your defense. However, introducing their character evidence can be complex. Courts generally limit such evidence unless it directly relates to your defense. Consulting with your attorney on how to effectively introduce this information is crucial.
Have you already discussed this strategy with your lawyer?
If my codefendant has Late and back child support due, can I use that to also prove his character to get severance from the case?
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, late or back child support issues are typically not considered relevant to proving a co-defendant's character in a criminal case, especially for the purpose of severance. Courts usually focus on whether the co-defendant's actions or evidence would prejudice your defense. Have you consulted your lawyer about other potential strategies for severance?
I was in a relationship with my codefendant and was manipulated and gaslit into following a lot of storytelling. I am now seeing clearly, but I still want to communicate with him. What should I do?
Case Rating: *
Since you're in a sensitive legal situation, it might be best to consult your lawyer before communicating with your co-defendant. They can advise on how such communication could impact your case. Is there a specific reason you want to maintain communication with your co-defendant?
I’m pregnant
Case Rating: *
Given the complexity and potential impact of your situation, it might be considered a high-value case. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you please share more details about your situation?
Is there a way to tell where calls are coming from inside the detention center based on the recording when the phone picks up on my end?
Case Rating: *
Unfortunately, it is typically not possible to determine the exact location within a detention center from a recorded phone call. Calls from detention centers are often routed through a centralized system, which doesn't provide specific location details. Would you like more information on how these systems work?
My codefendant calls from the detention center. Some of the calls are from a collect source and the other calls are from a free source. Would he be using one of these sources over the other if he was making calls to get information on behalf of the police department?
Case Rating: *
It's not necessarily indicative of cooperation with the police if your codefendant uses different calling sources. However, using free calls might be more convenient if those are provided for specific purposes. Monitoring the situation and consulting your lawyer for guidance on any legal implications is advisable.
How would he get free calls if he doesn’t have any money and no one’s putting money in his commissary or on his call log
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, inmates may receive free calls for various reasons, such as legal calls arranged by their attorney or calls to certain approved numbers. Some detention centers also provide limited free calls as part of their communication services. Do you think your codefendant's communication might be linked to legal matters?
He calls me * times a day and I think he’s calling to get me to say things over recorded line to try to put things at fault against me
Case Rating: *
It seems like a potentially high-value case given the complexity and the situation with your co-defendant. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you tell me more about your concerns regarding the calls?
What are good tactics to prove that my Choat defendant is not reliable and is a liar and has a bad drug history well, I have a clean record and no connection to any of the sources that he’s used or any recognition by the arresting officers in our town for which he has
Case Rating: *
Your case seems quite complicated and potentially high-value, especially with the claims against your co-defendant and the ongoing communications. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you tell me more about your concerns regarding the calls?
I stopped answering the phone because I could tell that he was trying to mix my vocabulary in words, asking very specific questions and play Katie me for information that I did not have
Case Rating: *
Your situation is indeed complex, involving legal intricacies with your co-defendant and potential manipulation through recorded calls. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you tell me more about your concerns regarding the calls?
Can you talk to my codefendant at all?
Case Rating: *
It sounds like you are dealing with a complex legal issue involving significant potential consequences. If you'd like, I can help connect you with local lawyers who can assist with your case. Could you tell me more about your specific concerns regarding your co-defendant's actions?
My Choat event is trying to get me to prove knowledge of addresses where he picked up drugs, and that I was driving around while he would sell and communicate or whatever. In reality, I would go and park at a business stay in the car get worked on and had no idea what he was doing or where he went.
Case Rating: *
Your case appears to involve serious allegations and complexities, especially with the involvement of your co-defendant and the nature of the charges. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you provide a bit more information about the issue?
What would I likely be charged with? If I was driving for my Choat defendant even though I didn’t know what drugs he had where he was going or what he was doing or saw anything at all just curious what the highest charge could still be for being a naïve driver
Case Rating: *
In Kentucky, if you're driving someone involved in drug activities without knowledge, you might still face charges like:
- Complicity in drug trafficking or possession, depending on evidence.
- Being an accessory if the prosecution argues you should have known.
Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you provide a bit more information about the issue?
What’s the probable charge I could get for driving my codefendant around well I did not know that he was selling purchasing and trading illegal drugs. I was just a driver and I’ve never had a conviction for drug drugs before.
Case Rating: *
Given the complexity of your situation and the serious nature of the charges, it might be beneficial to connect with local lawyers. Would you like me to help with that? If so, could you provide a bit more information about your case for better assistance?
How do I get my attorney to call me back quickly when he’s been ignoring me and doesn’t take me seriously
Case Rating: *
Your case seems complex and potentially high-value, especially with the legal intricacies and the involvement of your co-defendant. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you tell me a bit more about your concerns regarding your current attorney's lack of communication?
He has not gotten back to me for four or five days and each day more information comes to surface about my codefendant. I learned more about what he’s going to try to use against me and the calls that I get which I do not answer from him continue to stack up I get roughly somebody calls a day from him from the jailhouse.
Case Rating: *
Your situation involves complex legal issues, including potential charges related to your co-defendant's activities. Would you like to be connected to local lawyers who can better assist you with your case? If so, could you provide a bit more information about your concerns regarding your co-defendant's actions and the situation with your current attorney?