TRY ME!
Lack Of Evidence Defense
Summary
In Texas, if charges are pursued without evidence, a motion to dismiss can be filed. The district attorney needs substantial evidence to continue prosecution. If the sole witness recants and the alleged victim denies the incident, the cases foundation is weak. An affidavit of recantation can be submitted to strengthen the defense. If the district attorneys actions seem unethical, a complaint can be filed with the State Bar of Texas. Consulting with an attorney is crucial for navigating these legal challenges and ensuring the defendants rights are protected.Full Conversation
Does it seem like the da had probable cause
It appears that there may be a lack of probable cause given the absence of evidence and recanted statements. Here are some key points to consider:
- The district attorney must have substantial evidence to continue prosecuting.
- Your boyfriend's attorney can file a motion to dismiss and request an expedited hearing.
- Proceeding without evidence or corroborating testimony is questionable.
Would you like further information or assistance on any particular aspect?
- The district attorney must have substantial evidence to continue prosecuting.
- Your boyfriend's attorney can file a motion to dismiss and request an expedited hearing.
- Proceeding without evidence or corroborating testimony is questionable.
Would you like further information or assistance on any particular aspect?
What do you do about the da being questionable
It sounds like you have a strong case for your boyfriend's defense. Here are some steps you can take:
- Consult your attorney: Discuss the possibility of filing a motion to dismiss for lack of probable cause.
- Expedited hearing: Request an expedited hearing due to your boyfriend's safety concerns in jail.
- Ethics violation: Your attorney might consider questioning the ethics of continuing the prosecution without substantial evidence.
Do you need contact information for a local legal aid organization?
- Consult your attorney: Discuss the possibility of filing a motion to dismiss for lack of probable cause.
- Expedited hearing: Request an expedited hearing due to your boyfriend's safety concerns in jail.
- Ethics violation: Your attorney might consider questioning the ethics of continuing the prosecution without substantial evidence.
Do you need contact information for a local legal aid organization?
What to do if the da is being unethical
If you believe the district attorney is acting unethically, here are some steps you can take:
- File a Complaint: You can file a complaint against the district attorney with the State Bar of Texas.
- Speak to Your Attorney: Your boyfriend's attorney can address this issue in court and possibly file a motion questioning the DA's conduct.
- Media Attention: In some cases, bringing media attention to the injustice may prompt quicker action.
Would you like more information on how to file a complaint with the State Bar of Texas?
- File a Complaint: You can file a complaint against the district attorney with the State Bar of Texas.
- Speak to Your Attorney: Your boyfriend's attorney can address this issue in court and possibly file a motion questioning the DA's conduct.
- Media Attention: In some cases, bringing media attention to the injustice may prompt quicker action.
Would you like more information on how to file a complaint with the State Bar of Texas?
Yes
How to File a Complaint with the State Bar of Texas:
- File Online: Visit the State Bar of Texas website and fill out the complaint form.
- Mail: Download the complaint form, complete it, and mail it to the provided address.
- Call: You can also call the State Bar for further guidance.
Would you like the contact details for the State Bar of Texas?
- File Online: Visit the State Bar of Texas website and fill out the complaint form.
- Mail: Download the complaint form, complete it, and mail it to the provided address.
- Call: You can also call the State Bar for further guidance.
Would you like the contact details for the State Bar of Texas?
The only thing I haven't gotten is the statement for my daughter should I get a statement from her to send in with the motion to dismiss
It would be beneficial to include a statement from your daughter with your motion to dismiss. Her recantation is a key part of your defense and could strengthen your case significantly.
Would you need any guidance on how to draft this statement?
Would you need any guidance on how to draft this statement?
Yes
To draft your daughter's statement, ensure it includes:
- A clear recantation of her initial statement.
- Details explaining why she is recanting.
- An assertion that the initial statement was either incorrect or made under duress.
Would you like guidance on the specific language to use in the statement?
- A clear recantation of her initial statement.
- Details explaining why she is recanting.
- An assertion that the initial statement was either incorrect or made under duress.
Would you like guidance on the specific language to use in the statement?
Yes she just agreed with the officers when they asked her questions because one of them she feared because he arrested her before also she has resentment towards my boyfriend and retaliated because he put her in jail but it needs to be framed in a way that she's not going to be found committing a crime
Your daughter's statement should clearly outline her reasons for recanting without implicating her in any criminal activity. Here’s a suggested format:
- Start with her full name, age, and relation to the accused.
- State the date and circumstances of her initial statement.
- Explain the reasons for her initial statement: fear of the officer due to past experiences and personal resentment towards your boyfriend.
- Clarify that her initial statement was made under duress or mistaken belief.
- Assert that her recantation is truthful and voluntary.
Do you need more detailed guidance on this?
- Start with her full name, age, and relation to the accused.
- State the date and circumstances of her initial statement.
- Explain the reasons for her initial statement: fear of the officer due to past experiences and personal resentment towards your boyfriend.
- Clarify that her initial statement was made under duress or mistaken belief.
- Assert that her recantation is truthful and voluntary.
Do you need more detailed guidance on this?
Crime
It sounds like you have a strong defense case. Including your daughter's recantation statement can indeed strengthen the motion to dismiss. Here’s a more detailed guide on drafting her statement:
*. Introduction: Full name, age, and relationship to the accused.
*. Initial Statement Context: Date and context of the initial statement.
*. Reason for Initial Statement: Fear of the officer due to past experiences and personal resentment towards the accused.
*. Recantation: Clarify the initial statement was made under duress or mistaken belief.
*. Truthfulness: Assert that the recantation is truthful and voluntary.
Would you like any further assistance on this?
*. Introduction: Full name, age, and relationship to the accused.
*. Initial Statement Context: Date and context of the initial statement.
*. Reason for Initial Statement: Fear of the officer due to past experiences and personal resentment towards the accused.
*. Recantation: Clarify the initial statement was made under duress or mistaken belief.
*. Truthfulness: Assert that the recantation is truthful and voluntary.
Would you like any further assistance on this?
Can you draft it for me
Sure, here's a draft for your daughter's statement:
---
Affidavit of Recantation
I, [Daughter's Full Name], aged [Daughter's Age], declare the following in relation to the case involving [Boyfriend's Full Name]:
*. Introduction:
- Full Name: [Daughter's Full Name]
- Age: [Daughter's Age]
- Relationship to Accused: [Specify relationship, e.g., daughter of the victim]
*. Initial Statement Context:
- On [Date of Initial Statement], I provided a statement to law enforcement regarding an alleged assault involving [Boyfriend's Full Name].
*. Reason for Initial Statement:
- At the time of my initial statement, I was under significant stress and fear due to a past negative experience with one of the officers.
- Additionally, I harbored personal resentment towards [Boyfriend's Full Name] because he had previously influenced a situation that led to my arrest.
*. Recantation:
- I acknowledge that my initial statement was made under duress and was not a true reflection of the events that occurred.
- I now recant my previous statement and affirmthat no assault took place as initially described.
*. Truthfulness:
- This recantation is made voluntarily and truthfully, without any external pressure or influence.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Signed on [Date] in [Location].
Signature:
[Daughter's Full Name]
---
Would you need any additional assistance?
---
Affidavit of Recantation
I, [Daughter's Full Name], aged [Daughter's Age], declare the following in relation to the case involving [Boyfriend's Full Name]:
*. Introduction:
- Full Name: [Daughter's Full Name]
- Age: [Daughter's Age]
- Relationship to Accused: [Specify relationship, e.g., daughter of the victim]
*. Initial Statement Context:
- On [Date of Initial Statement], I provided a statement to law enforcement regarding an alleged assault involving [Boyfriend's Full Name].
*. Reason for Initial Statement:
- At the time of my initial statement, I was under significant stress and fear due to a past negative experience with one of the officers.
- Additionally, I harbored personal resentment towards [Boyfriend's Full Name] because he had previously influenced a situation that led to my arrest.
*. Recantation:
- I acknowledge that my initial statement was made under duress and was not a true reflection of the events that occurred.
- I now recant my previous statement and affirmthat no assault took place as initially described.
*. Truthfulness:
- This recantation is made voluntarily and truthfully, without any external pressure or influence.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Signed on [Date] in [Location].
Signature:
[Daughter's Full Name]
---
Would you need any additional assistance?
Is there such a thing of an affidavit of recantation or is it titled something else
Yes, an "Affidavit of Recantation" is a legitimate document. It is used when a witness or victim wants to officially retract or change their previous statement given to law enforcement or in court.
Would you like any further assistance with the process of submitting this affidavit?
Would you like any further assistance with the process of submitting this affidavit?
Relationship to Accused: [Specify relationship, e.g., daughter of the victim] daughter of the alleged victim
It seems you have a strong defense case, particularly with your daughter's recantation and the lack of evidence.
Would you like guidance on how to properly submit the Affidavit of Recantation to the court and include it in your motion to dismiss?
Would you like guidance on how to properly submit the Affidavit of Recantation to the court and include it in your motion to dismiss?
No the part of the affidavit of recantation it says Relationship to Accused: [Specify relationship, e.g., daughter of the victim should I put daughter of the alleged victim instead of daughter of the victim
You can use "daughter of the alleged victim" to clarify that the victim status is contested. This phrasing accurately reflects the situation and avoids any implication of an actual crime.
Would you like guidance on how to submit the Affidavit of Recantation to the court?
Would you like guidance on how to submit the Affidavit of Recantation to the court?
Start a new chat