Legal Representation Discrepancy

Summary

In Missouri, defendants have the right to an attorney, and if they cannot afford one, a public defender should be appointed. If theres a discrepancy in legal representation or sentencing, consider filing a motion with the court or contacting the Missouri Public Defenders Office. Different prosecutors may influence sentencing, even with the same judge. Dismissal is complex and may require evidence of legal error or rights violation. Consulting a local attorney can provide specific guidance.

Full Conversation

Yes they were
It sounds like both individuals had similar eligibility for court-appointed attorneys, but there might still be a difference in how their cases were handled.
- Were both individuals informed about their right to a court-appointed attorney?
- Did either of the individuals choose to waive their right to an attorney?
Understanding these aspects could provide more clarity on the situation.
No
It seems like there might be an inconsistency in how the right to legal representation is being applied. In Missouri, defendants are entitled to an attorney, and if they cannot afford one, the court should appoint a public defender. Here are a few things to consider:
- Ensure both individuals have formally requested a court-appointed attorney.
- Check if there are any procedural errors or oversight in their cases.
If you think there's been a violation of rights, you might want to contact the Missouri Public Defender's Office for further assistance or consider speaking with a local attorney for more guidance. Is there anything else you'd like to know or discuss?
How to file on this myself
Case Rating: *
If you're looking to address this issue yourself, you can consider filing a complaint or motion with the court. Here are some general steps:
- Gather all documentation related to the case.
- Prepare a written statement outlining the issue and any discrepancies.
- File a motion with the court requesting a review of the legal representation issue.
- Contact the Missouri Public Defender's Office for guidance on filing procedures.
Do you have any specific questions about these steps or need further assistance?
The state on. My case said *$ fine the state on the other case said jail time charges are the same
Case Rating: *
It seems there might be a disparity in sentencing. Here are some factors to consider:
- Were both cases handled by the same prosecutor or judge?
- Are there any differences in prior criminal records or mitigating/aggravating factors?
These could influence sentencing decisions. Would you like more guidance on this issue?
Same judge different prosecutor
Case Rating: *
It seems the situation involves potential inconsistencies in legal representation and sentencing. Here are a few additional points to consider:
- Different prosecutors may have varying approaches to similar cases, influencing recommendations for sentencing.
- Check if any plea deals or negotiations were offered in either case.
Would you like to explore any specific legal options or have further questions about this issue?
Does it qualify for dismissal
Case Rating: *
Inconsistencies in legal representation and sentencing can be challenging to address. Dismissal might not be straightforward unless there's a clear legal error or rights violation. Here's what you can consider:
- File a motion to review the case details.
- Consult with a local attorney for specific legal advice.
Would you like more guidance on any specific part of this process?