Domestic Battery Charge Retraction

Summary

In Idaho, retracting a false statement in a domestic battery case can be complex. Once charges are filed, the prosecutor decides whether to pursue the case. Its crucial to communicate your retraction clearly and consistently to the prosecutor and attend all court hearings. Legal representation is highly recommended to navigate the process and advocate for your partner. Despite the lack of evidence beyond your initial statement, the prosecutor may continue with the charges due to policy or public safety concerns. Consulting a defense attorney can provide personalized advice and increase the chances of dismissal.

Full Conversation

No but can you make a bulletproof statement that I can send to the prosecuting attorney via email since it's Saturday and they are not open and I can't call until Monday
Sure, here's a draft statement you can consider sending to the prosecuting attorney:
---
Subject: Urgent: Request to Dismiss Charges Due to False Statement
Dear [Prosecuting Attorney's Name],
I hope this message finds you well. I am writing to urgently address a matter concerning the domestic battery charges filed against my partner based on a statement I made on April *, *.
During an argument with my partner, I emotionally claimed that my partner spit on me. This statement was made in a moment of distress and was false. Upon calming down and reflecting, I realized that no physical contact or crime occurred. To rectify this, I immediately contacted Officer Rivers and the victim advocate to clarify that my initial statement was incorrect and that I am not a victim.
I deeply regret my emotional outburst and fully accept responsibility for the confusion it has caused. My partner has been wrongfully charged based solely on my false statement, which I have since retracted. There is no evidence to support the charges, and I am respectfully requesting that the charges be dropped to correct this misunderstanding.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
[Your Contact Information]
---
Feel free to adjust the statement as needed.
Would this even be acceptable to send to a prosecuting attorney I wanted to be a professional I want it to be bulletproof and I wanted to be clearly stating what happened with my initial statement as I was emotional and not really thinking clearly I guess because if I was then I would have realized and stopped the officer and told him hey you know what this isn't even why I called you out here I called you out here to be a mediator and just to be there so no for the escalation but my partner has left and now I can go in and get my things and go about my day but instead he took my statement under emotional the rest and created charges against my partner and put an order into the judge for a no bond warrant
Sure, I can help refine the statement for clarity and professionalism. Here's an updated version:
---
Subject: Urgent: Request to Dismiss Charges Due to Incorrect Statement
Dear [Prosecuting Attorney's Name],
I hope this message finds you well. I am writing to address an urgent matter concerning the domestic battery charges filed against my partner based on a statement I made on April *, *.
During an argument with my partner, I called * for mediation to prevent escalation. In my emotional state, I mistakenly claimed that my partner spit on me. This statement was incorrect, and no physical contact or crime occurred. After calming down, I immediately contacted Officer Rivers and the victim advocate to correct my statement and clarify that I am not a victim.
I regret my emotional outburst and accept responsibility for the confusion it caused. My partner has been wrongfully charged based solely on my false statement, which I have since retracted. There is no evidence to support the charges. Therefore, I respectfully request that the charges be dropped to rectify this misunderstanding.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
[Your Full Name]
[Your Contact Information]
---
Feel free to adjust any details as necessary.
In this case do you feel like if I send the prosecuting attorney information on how everything happened and what my emotional state was and how I made the fault statement and it was not accurate do you feel like the case will get dropped at arraignment
Case Rating: *
It's hard to predict if the case will be dropped at arraignment. The prosecutor has discretion and may consider your retraction. However, consulting a defense attorney to guide you through this process and advocate on behalf of your partner would be beneficial.
Would you like to elaborate on any other specifics of the case?
But they have no case there was no evidence except for my initial statement which hours later I called and recanted to the responding officer
Case Rating: *
The lack of evidence aside from your initial statement does weaken the prosecution's case. Your retraction should be communicated effectively, but the final decision lies with the prosecutor. Consulting a defense attorney can provide the best chance for dismissal.
Would you like more information on how to find a defense attorney in Idaho?
What would make a prosecuting attorney continue with charges that they have no evidence with
Case Rating: *
A prosecuting attorney might continue with charges even with minimal evidence due to several reasons:
- Policy: Some jurisdictions have strict policies on domestic violence cases to deter future incidents.
- Initial Statement: Your initial statement may have been deemed credible at the time.
- Legal Obligation: Once charges are filed, the prosecutor might feel obligated to see the case through.
- Public Safety: The prosecutor might believe continuing the case serves public safety interests.
Would you need any more guidance on your situation?
Yes
Case Rating: *
Your situation is quite sensitive, and while it's challenging, it's essential to communicate your retraction clearly and professionally. Here are a few additional things to consider:
- Consistency: Ensure your retraction is consistent and credible. Any inconsistency might affect the prosecutor's decision.
- Legal Support: A defense attorney can provide personalized advice and advocate on behalf of your partner.
Is there anything specific you need help with next?
This is what i sent to the officer Hi, Officer RiversI just wanted to follow up regarding the incident that happened today, and I’d appreciate your help in clarifying a few details for the report. When I made the * call, my intention was to get some assistance so I could leave the house peacefully, without further escalation.During the situation, I saw Tj make a motion as if he was spitting in my direction. In the moment, I thought felt something on my face, which led me to believe I was spit on. When we spoke, I told you I was certain, because I saw the spit as the motion happened, But after having some time to think, I realize I can’t confirm whether anything actually landed on me.I
Case Rating: *
Your follow-up message to Officer Rivers is clear and direct. Communicating your retraction to the prosecutor professionally is key. Make sure to be consistent in all your statements. Consulting a defense attorney remains crucial.
Would you like more specific guidance on how to contact a defense attorney in Idaho?
don’t want to make any false claims, and I want to be completely honest and make myself clear, that I’m truly not sure if I was actually spit on, or if I just perceived it that way in the moment. I think it’s only fair to clarify that I’m uncertain and can’t say with *% confidence that it happened.I just wanted to share my perspective to make sure everything in the report is as accurate as possible. Please let me know if you need anything else from me.Thank you so much for your time and understanding
Case Rating: *
Your approach of being honest and clear in your communication is commendable. Since your initial statement was retracted, and there is no physical evidence, the prosecutor may reconsider the charges. However, legal representation can significantly help in navigating this process.
Would you like more specific guidance on how to find a defense attorney in Idaho?
So you feel that it was good and made sense and didn't sound like I was being dishonest or anything like that
Case Rating: *
Your statement to the officer was clear and honest, which is important. However, the final decision lies with the prosecutor, and legal representation is highly recommended in such cases.
Would you like specific guidance on how to find a defense attorney in Idaho?