Motion To Suppress Viability

Summary

In Florida, officers can request ID from passengers if theres reasonable suspicion. Drugs on a driver may contribute to this, but without more suspicious behavior, probable cause might be weak. Resisting arrest charges can arise if lawful commands are refused. Consider consulting a local attorney for advice on challenging this in court.

Full Conversation

So without probable cause in Florida and officer can request ID from a passenger and if the passenger refuses they can be arrested for resisting
In Florida, an officer can request ID from a passenger during a traffic stop. However, the legality of arresting a passenger for refusing to provide ID depends on whether the officer had reasonable suspicion or probable cause.
Would you like more information on how to challenge this in court?
If the driver had a small bag of drugs in his wallet is that probable cause to request ID from the passenger and if they refuse arrest them
In Florida, the discovery of drugs on a driver can give officers reasonable suspicion to investigate further. However, whether this justifies requesting ID from the passenger and arresting them for refusal depends on the specific circumstances and the officer's reasonable suspicion of the passenger's involvement.
Would you like information on Florida's resisting arrest laws or how to challenge this in court?
The fact that drugs were found in the wallet of the driver was the only reason why they demanded ID from the passenger and when the passenger refused they were arrested for no other reason than the drugs were found on the driver
The situation you described involves complex legal issues regarding probable cause and reasonable suspicion. Here are some key points to consider:
- Probable Cause: The presence of drugs in the driver's wallet may give the officer reason to suspect involvement of others in the vehicle.
- Reasonable Suspicion: Officers need reasonable suspicion to detain you and ask for ID.
- Resisting Arrest: In Florida, resisting without violence can be charged if you refuse lawful commands.
Would you like more details on how to challenge this in court?
So a small bag of drugs found on the driver is enough to arrest the passenger for refusal to ID resist
In Florida, the arrest of a passenger for refusing to provide ID, based solely on drugs found on the driver, can be legally contested. Here are some points:
- Officers need reasonable suspicion of the passenger's involvement.
- Resisting without violence can be charged if lawful commands are refused.
Would you like information on challenging this in court?
Are drugs found on the driver reasonable suspicious to request ID from a passenger
In Florida, drugs found on the driver can give officers reasonable suspicion to request ID from a passenger. However, whether this justifies arresting a passenger for refusal depends on the specific circumstances and the officer's reasonable suspicion of the passenger's involvement.
Would you like information on how to challenge this in court?
There was no other reasonable suspicious of the passenger the passenger had a seatbelt on was not acting funny was quiet was polite the only reason why ID was requested was because drugs were found on the driver and when the passenger refused they were arrested for resisting it can I win a motion to suppress
In Florida, the legality of the request for ID and subsequent arrest depends on whether the officers had reasonable suspicion or probable cause to believe the passenger was involved in criminal activity. Here are some key points:
- Reasonable Suspicion: The presence of drugs on the driver may contribute to reasonable suspicion.
- Probable Cause: Without additional suspicious behavior, this might be weak.
- Resisting Arrest: If the command was lawful, refusal could lead to charges.
Would you like information on how to challenge this in court?