Defending Against False Allegations

Summary

In the UK, the Crown Prosecution Service can pursue charges even if the alleged victim withdraws their complaint. Defenses include self-defense, lack of intent, and character witnesses. Mitigating factors like a lack of prior convictions, evidence of remorse, and character references can influence sentencing. Sentences for ABH, non-fatal strangulation, and coercive control can be severe, but may run concurrently. Demonstrating remorse through counseling, community service, and character references can help. Legal advice is crucial for navigating bail conditions and potential reconciliation with your partner. Consider consulting a criminal defense lawyer for personalized guidance.

Full Conversation

Uk
Understood! Could you please provide a bit more detail on the criminal law issue you're facing? This will help me provide more specific information.
I’m been charged with abh, non fateh strangulation and coehersive controlling behaviour. Although these allegations are false except there was a physical whipping of cable which my partner hit me with a phone charge cable and it triggered me I whipped back in retaliation. Cps has photos of the marks left on her and further made other allegations. She has withdrawn her case but cps is still pursuing the case. What is my best defence
In the UK, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) can pursue a case even if the alleged victim withdraws their complaint. Here are some key points for your defense:
- Self-Defense: Argue that you acted in self-defense after being hit with the phone charger cable.
- Lack of Intent: Emphasize that you did not intend to cause harm, and it was a reflexive action.
- Character Witnesses: Gather character witnesses that can vouch for your behavior and relationship dynamic.
Have you consulted with a criminal defense lawyer yet?
My partner also said if I withdraw the case later it would be because of pressure from me. Although she now has prove that the allegation was false and how can I prove that I never strangled her and there were no marks involved neither intent to strangle her. How can I prove my innocence
To prove your innocence, consider the following steps:
- Evidence of No Marks: Obtain medical or photographic evidence confirming the absence of strangulation marks.
- Witness Testimonies: Collect statements from anyone present during the incident.
- Character Evidence: Present evidence of your good character and past behavior.
- Expert Testimony: Medical or psychological experts can testify about the lack of physical evidence supporting strangulation.
Have you discussed these options with your lawyer?
It was 3 months ago. Will the medical still be able to examine ?
Given the importance of medical evidence in your case, it's crucial to act promptly. While the passage of time may affect the availability of physical evidence, a medical expert can still provide testimony based on available information and records.
Have you already contacted a medical expert or doctor regarding this?
There was no witness but my partner ran off to next door neighbour in distraught and now she is a witness although she was not present at the time of the incident. How does her testimony hold
In the UK, testimony from someone who observed the immediate aftermath of an incident can still be relevant. Your neighbor's testimony could be considered under the "res gestae" principle, which includes statements made spontaneously or immediately after an event. This can sometimes be seen as more reliable.
Have you gathered any other evidence or witness statements that could support your case?
What are the likely chances if I’m found quilty?
If found guilty, the consequences for ABH (Actual Bodily Harm), non-fatal strangulation, and coercive controlling behavior can be severe in the UK. Potential penalties include:
- ABH: Up to 5 years in prison.
- Non-Fatal Strangulation: Up to 5 years in prison.
- Coercive Control: Up to 5 years in prison.
These are general guidelines, and the exact sentence depends on factors like the severity of the incident, your criminal history, and mitigating circumstances.
Have you discussed any plea options with your lawyer?
So will it be a total of 15 years if found quilty?
The sentences for multiple offenses do not necessarily add up linearly. Sentences may run concurrently (at the same time) or consecutively (one after the other). It depends on the judge's discretion and the specifics of your case. Consulting with your lawyer will provide more clarity.
Are you considering any specific legal defenses or plea bargains?
What sort of punishment am I looking if found quiltY
If found guilty, the punishment for your charges could be substantial. In the UK:
- ABH (Actual Bodily Harm): Up to 5 years in prison.
- Non-Fatal Strangulation: Up to 5 years in prison.
- Coercive Control: Up to 5 years in prison.
These penalties could run concurrently or consecutively based on the judge's discretion.
Have you considered discussing potential plea deals with your lawyer?
What is the average percentage in uk for these offences I have never been convicted of any crime before
The sentences for ABH, non-fatal strangulation, and coercive control vary depending on several factors. Here's some general information:
- ABH (Actual Bodily Harm): Average sentences range from community orders to 3 years in prison.
- Non-Fatal Strangulation: This is a relatively new offense; sentences can range from community orders to several years.
- Coercive Control: Sentences range from community orders to 4 years in prison.
Your lack of prior convictions may be a mitigating factor. Have you gathered all possible mitigating evidence to present to the court?
I can provide evidence of bank statement where she has access to money and also messages where can does freely travel. Although been Muslim she does ask me when leaving home but I have never refused. Also she has travelled outside of the country with the kids in *. I have travelled * times out of the country so she clearly had the chance to report to police if she was abuse. What is likely if I produce these documents ?
Providing evidence such as bank statements and messages that show financial freedom and freedom to travel can help support your defense against coercive control allegations.
However, this evidence must be presented alongside other mitigating factors and defenses. It is crucial to discuss these documents with your lawyer to strategically incorporate them into your case.
Have you consulted with your lawyer about how to best present this evidence?
No
Given the severity of the charges and the detailed evidence you can provide, it's crucial to discuss all available options with a lawyer. Presenting bank statements, travel records, and messages can be beneficial, but they must be strategically used.
Have you considered seeking a second opinion from another criminal defense lawyer?
How does a character reference affect this case if found guilty could it affect in sentencing?
A character reference can significantly impact sentencing if found guilty. Here are some key points:
- Mitigating Factor: A strong character reference can serve as a mitigating factor, potentially reducing the severity of the sentence.
- Credibility: It can highlight your positive attributes and contributions to the community.
- Support Network: Demonstrates you have a support system, which may influence the judge's perception.
Have you already gathered any character references?
Who can provide references which holds the most weight in this case ?
For character references that hold the most weight in your case, consider the following:
- Employers or Colleagues: They can vouch for your professional conduct and reliability.
- Community Leaders: Clergy, coaches, or other respected community members can attest to your character and contributions.
- Family Members: Close family members who can speak to your behavior and relationship dynamics.
Have you reached out to any of these individuals for references yet?
How about professional contacts like barristers who are friends and accountants. Also my dentist whom I know personally but can’t involve him in this case so a general reference of character
Professional contacts like barristers, accountants, and your dentist can certainly provide character references. Here are some considerations:
- Barristers and Accountants: Their professional standing and knowledge of your character can be persuasive.
- Dentist: Can offer a general character reference highlighting your demeanor and reliability.
Have you discussed with these individuals about providing references?
Yes
It sounds like you have strong supporting evidence and character references that could potentially help your case. Here’s a summary of actions you can consider:
- Character References: Gather detailed references from professional contacts like barristers, accountants, and a general character reference from your dentist.
- Evidence: Compile all bank statements, travel records, and messages that demonstrate your partner’s freedom.
- Consult Your Lawyer: Discuss all gathered evidence and references with your lawyer to strategically present them.
Would you like more information on how to structure these character references for maximum impact?
Can my partner do anything which doesn’t harm her in this case. Ie providing statements that she lied ?
Your partner should be cautious about admitting to lying, as it could have legal repercussions for her. Instead, she can focus on:
- Providing accurate and truthful statements.
- Clarifying any misunderstandings.
- Highlighting any inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case.
Have you discussed this strategy with your lawyer?
Can she state it was emotional moments and was angry?
Yes, your partner can state that her previous statements were made during emotional moments and anger. However, she should be honest and consistent in her testimony to avoid legal repercussions for herself. It's essential to discuss this strategy carefully with your lawyer.
Have you planned a meeting with your lawyer to discuss this approach?
What harm could it cause her if I prove her to be lying in this case
If you prove that your partner was lying:
- Perjury Charges: She could face charges for perjury, which involves lying under oath.
- Legal Repercussions: Potential penalties including fines or imprisonment.
- Credibility: Her credibility could be severely damaged in future legal matters.
Have you considered the consequences and discussed this with your lawyer?
What is the maximum penalty she could get
Your partner could face serious consequences if proven to be lying, including:
- Perjury: Up to 7 years in prison.
- Obstructing Justice: Potential fines or imprisonment.
Discuss these potential outcomes with your lawyer to understand the full implications.
Would you like more information on any specific aspect of your case?
What is the best approach for proving my innocence and also not harming my partner. We have kids involved too. Any complication it could have on kids ?
To prove your innocence while minimizing harm to your partner and considering the impact on your kids, follow these steps:
- Truthful Testimony: Ensure your partner provides honest and consistent statements about the incident.
- Character References: Gather strong character references.
- Evidence: Present evidence of your partner's freedom and lack of intent to harm.
- Legal Advice: Discuss strategies with your lawyer to avoid legal repercussions for your partner.
What are your primary concerns regarding the impact on your kids?
I don’t want the kids to be taken by the social services if both of us are found guilty
If both parents are found guilty, social services could intervene to ensure the children's safety. Here are some steps to consider:
- Legal Strategy: Work closely with your lawyer to present a strong defense.
- Character Evidence: Highlight your role as a responsible parent.
- Social Services: Engage with social services proactively to demonstrate your commitment to your children's well-being.
Have you discussed potential outcomes and strategies with your lawyer regarding social services?
No
To address your concerns, it’s crucial to act proactively:
- Legal Strategy: Coordinate with your lawyer to build a robust defense that emphasizes your role as a responsible parent.
- Character Evidence: Gather references and evidence that demonstrate your commitment to your children’s welfare.
- Engage Social Services: Contact social services to show your willingness to cooperate and ensure your children’s well-being.
Have you thought about seeking guidance from a family law specialist to help navigate potential social services involvement?
On average in uk what are the likely outcome of these cases domestic violence in Asian background ?
The outcome of domestic violence cases in the UK, including those involving individuals from Asian backgrounds, can vary widely based on the specifics of the case. Factors include:
- Strength of evidence
- Severity of the allegations
- Any prior criminal history
- Mitigating circumstances
Cultural background may also be considered, but the legal principles are applied uniformly.
Have you gathered all relevant evidence and character references to support your defense?
List all the mitigating circumstances
Mitigating circumstances in criminal cases can help reduce the severity of the sentence. Here are common mitigating circumstances that could be relevant to your case:
- Lack of Prior Criminal Record: If you have no previous convictions, it can be a significant mitigating factor.
- Provocation: If you acted in response to provocation or a threat.
- Character References: Positive testimonials from employers, community leaders, or family members.
- Remorse: Genuine expressions of remorse and efforts to make amends.
- Mental State: Evidence of mental health issues that may have influenced your behavior.
- Minor Role: If you played a minor role in the incident compared to others involved.
- Family Responsibilities: Demonstrating your role and responsibilities as a parent.
- Cooperation with Authorities: Willingness to cooperate with law enforcement and legal proceedings.
- Evidence of Rehabilitation: Steps taken to address any underlying issues, such as attending counseling.
Would you like more detailed information on any of these mitigating circumstances?
Yes
Here are some detailed explanations of common mitigating circumstances:
- Lack of Prior Criminal Record: Demonstrates good character and lessens the perceived risk of reoffending.
- Provocation: Show that your actions were a direct response to threats or provocation.
- Character References: Obtain testimonials from credible sources like employers and community leaders to vouch for your integrity.
- Remorse: Express genuine regret and any efforts to rectify the situation.
- Mental State: Provide medical records or expert testimony about any mental health issues.
- Minor Role: Highlight if your involvement was minimal compared to others.
- Family Responsibilities: Emphasize your role in your children's lives and responsibilities at home.
- Cooperation with Authorities: Show your willingness to cooperate with law enforcement and the legal process.
- Evidence of Rehabilitation: Document any counseling or rehabilitation programs you’ve attended.
Would you like to delve into any specific mitigating circumstances further?
How can I prove remorse
To prove remorse, consider these steps:
- Apology Letters: Write a sincere letter of apology to the victim and the court.
- Behavioral Changes: Show evidence of attending anger management or counseling sessions.
- Community Service: Voluntarily engage in community service activities.
- Testimonies: Have character witnesses testify about your regret and efforts to change.
Have you thought about attending any counseling or rehabilitation programs?
Any more
To further demonstrate remorse, you can also consider these additional steps:
- Restitution: Offer to compensate the victim for any damages or losses incurred.
- Public Acknowledgment: Publicly acknowledge your actions and express your willingness to make amends.
- Support Programs: Participate in support groups related to domestic violence.
- Documentation: Keep records of all steps taken to show remorse and present them to the court.
Would you like more detailed advice on any of these steps?
I do have remorse and regret what happened, also I really miss my family and I hold full financial responsibility for running the household. Although we both work but my partner is saving to open a restaurant from her earnings , I am attending general councilling. I applied for volunteering job but because I’m on bail far from home I couldn’t provide any proof of address
To address your situation, consider these steps:
- Document Counseling: Keep records of your attendance at counseling sessions.
- Character References: Gather statements from employers, colleagues, and community members.
- Financial Responsibility: Highlight your role in financially supporting your household.
- Volunteering Efforts: Document your attempts to volunteer, even if unsuccessful.
Have you discussed these steps with your lawyer to incorporate them into your defense strategy?
I did request social services for support programs but they haven’t not replied and also mentioned they don’t know any in the area I’m currently living in.
To better understand your situation and provide more tailored advice, could you please specify which region or city in the UK you are currently living in? This will help me provide you with more relevant information about local support programs and resources.
Stoke on Trent. But originally from London
In Stoke on Trent, you have several ways to strengthen your defense and show remorse while considering your family's well-being. Here are some steps:
- Document Counseling: Keep detailed records of your counseling attendance.
- Character References: Obtain statements from credible sources.
- Financial Responsibility: Highlight your role in supporting your household.
- Volunteering Efforts: Document attempts to volunteer, even if unsuccessful.

Stoke-on-Trent Citizens Advice Bureau


Phone: * * *
Website: [Citizens Advice](https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/local/stoke-trent-north-staffs/)
Would you like more information on local support programs?
Considering all of the above what are the chances of me been convicted and for how long ?
Given the serious nature of the charges and the detailed evidence already involved, your case is complex. Here's a summary:
- Charges: ABH, non-fatal strangulation, coercive control.
- Potential Sentences: Each charge could carry up to 5 years in prison.
- Mitigating Factors: Lack of prior convictions, evidence of remorse, character references, and financial responsibility.
The best approach is to coordinate closely with your lawyer to present a strong defense and mitigating evidence.
Would you like more advice on preparing for your court appearance?
Yes
To prepare effectively for your court appearance:
- Legal Representation: Ensure you have a competent criminal defense lawyer.
- Documentation: Collect all records of counseling, financial support, and any attempts at volunteering.
- Character References: Obtain strong references from credible sources like employers, community leaders, and professional contacts.
- Evidence Presentation: Organize all evidence systematically to demonstrate your remorse, financial responsibility, and mitigating circumstances.
- Courtroom Conduct: Present yourself respectfully and follow your lawyer’s guidance on how to address the court.
Would you like tips on how to organize your documentation and evidence for the court?
If I pleaded guilty what will be outcome ?
If you plead guilty, the outcome could vary based on mitigating factors and the judge's discretion. Generally, considering your charges, you may face:
- ABH (Actual Bodily Harm): Up to 5 years in prison.
- Non-Fatal Strangulation: Up to 5 years in prison.
- Coercive Control: Up to 5 years in prison.
Sentences could run concurrently or consecutively.
Have you discussed the possibility of a plea deal with your lawyer?
What are the likely chances of getting a financial fine or community service?
In the UK, for charges like ABH, non-fatal strangulation, and coercive control, the likelihood of getting a financial fine or community service instead of imprisonment depends on several factors:
- First-time Offender: Lack of prior criminal record.
- Mitigating Circumstances: Evidence of remorse, character references, financial responsibility, and counseling attendance.
- Severity of Offense: The context and severity of the incident.
Have you discussed these factors with your lawyer to explore all possible sentencing options?
How can I do apology to my partner. My bail conditions are to not contact her directly or indirectly. Although I do want to regardless of the outcome of this case and I want to resume my relationship and work to bond a stronger and loving relationship
Given your bail conditions, you cannot contact your partner directly or indirectly. Here are some safe steps to consider:
- Legal Route: Request your lawyer to communicate your feelings and desire to reconcile.
- Counseling: Focus on personal development and counseling to show your commitment to change.
- Court Permission: After the case, seek court permission through your lawyer for contact.
Would you like more tips on how to convey your remorse legally?
What are the likely changes of getting contact with my partner through court?
Re-establishing contact with your partner through the court can be complex given your bail conditions and the charges. Here are some potential steps:
- Legal Petition: Your lawyer can file a petition to modify bail conditions.
- Mutual Agreement: Both parties can agree to request the court for contact, emphasizing the well-being of your children.
- Counseling Programs: Participation in counseling might support your case for contact restoration.
Have you discussed these options with your lawyer?
How can my partner request court for reconciliation
To request court for reconciliation, your partner can take these steps:
- Legal Petition: She can file a formal request through her lawyer to modify the bail conditions.
- Mutual Agreement: Both parties can agree and present a united request to the court, emphasizing the well-being of the children.
- Counseling Programs: Participation in joint counseling sessions may support the request for reconciliation.
Would you like more detailed advice on how to structure the legal petition?