Property Damage Defense Strategies

Summary

In South Africa, property damage is a criminal offense. If accused, gather witness statements and evidence to support your innocence. Hearsay can be admitted under certain conditions, but its crucial to have credible evidence. Consult a lawyer to guide you through the legal process and ensure your defense is strong. Witness statements from family members and any evidence showing your location during the incident can be beneficial. Consider obtaining a copy of the police report and documenting all interactions with authorities.

Full Conversation

If I have witnesses saying all I did was shouting get off my internet, and I was not see throwing anything, I did not do this, so what even? The damages are minor in my opinion unless they did something themselves to the front door. The size of the stones in this area are small, I dont see how this can have caused damages even if if it was me. My mom did this but the policeman anyways wrote malicious damage to property against my name.
It sounds like you have witnesses who can corroborate your story, which is beneficial. Here are some key points for you:
- Gather witness statements supporting your claim.
- Collect any evidence showing you did not cause the damage.
- Inform the police again that your mother was responsible.
Have you consulted a lawyer to discuss the details of your case?
Hello, is my neighbor reading my messages maybe huh? Cause a suprise is awaiting him next year.
Thanks for sharing more details. Based on the information provided, it seems you might have a strong case to defend yourself, especially since you have witnesses who can attest to your actions. Here are a few points to consider:
- Gather Witness Statements: Collect statements from anyone who saw you at the time of the incident and can confirm your actions.
- Document Everything: Keep a record of all communications, evidence, and any potential proof of your innocence.
- Legal Representation: It might be a good idea to consult a lawyer who can guide you through the legal process and help present your case effectively.
Do you need help finding a lawyer or legal aid in Bavaria?
But what can I document? Even if I had my own cctv in front of my house, the court would not see it the way I see it. According to people I spoken to this neighbor also never had any outside cameras before, so how did he know it was me?
You should document the following:
- Witness Statements: Written and signed statements from those who were present and can confirm your actions.
- Photos/Videos: Any visual evidence that could show the condition of the property before and after the alleged incident.
- Communication Records: Any messages or communication with your landlord, neighbor, or police.
- Police Report: Ensure you have a copy of the report and any updates or corrections.
Would you like guidance on how to obtain and prepare witness statements?
How can he make this a criminal case against me this charge since I was not there at his house to begin with and also he is basing this on hearing me, and also hearsay/speculative.
In Bavaria, a charge can still be made if there's probable cause, even if it's based on hearsay. Here are some key steps you can take:
- Witness Statements: Get signed statements from witnesses who can confirm you were not at the neighbor's house.
- Evidence: Gather any evidence that shows your location at the time.
- Police Report: Ensure the police report includes your mother's admission.
Have you considered filing a counter-complaint to correct the record?
I am in South Africa. How can a charge be made on hearsay? This is a first time I have heard of this.
In South Africa, hearsay evidence can be admitted under certain conditions. Here are some points:
- Hearsay is generally not admissible unless the court grants permission.
- The court considers the credibility of the source and the necessity of the evidence.
- It must be in the interest of justice to admit the hearsay.
Have you gathered all possible evidence and witness statements to support your case?
I have no other evidence but by saying I was inside went outside onto my own drive way shouting his way, and was frustrated since I suffered rf anomalies for a long time here now and somehow they pin this on me, I believe a creditor of my father is behind this that has put these people up to it. He used to say he needs to have us watched. For me this was always more than just a threat and intent behind it. He even came to my landlord to discuss my fathers debt with him, now my landlord does not admit this all of the sudden. So I only have my direct family members here who can say that I was only in and out not throwing anything their way. It was my mom who I found outside I thought was picking up things of the driveway, cleaning up things, who actually did it.
In Bavaria, proving your innocence with the help of witness statements and any other evidence is crucial. Here are the steps you should consider:
- Gather written and signed statements from your family members who can confirm your actions.
- Document all interactions with the landlord and police.
- Ensure the police report includes your mother’s admission if possible.
Have you tried speaking directly with the police to correct the record?
The police never included my mom`s admission, and also that I am not sure even if I go now that they will want to include this. I dont trust the police on this in South Africa to be honest. I believe he deliberately kept this info out, his words were dont know what they will do to her/what will happen to her.
It sounds like a challenging situation. Here are some steps to consider:
- Gather Evidence: Collect any witness statements and any evidence that shows your innocence.
- Police Report: Request a copy of the police report.
- Legal Representation: Consult a lawyer to guide you through the legal process.
Would you like help finding a lawyer in South Africa?
so I still get locked up for doing something like this?
If you can prove your innocence with witness statements and evidence, you have a strong defense. Here are some key points:
- Gather witness statements from your family members.
- Collect any evidence that supports your claim.
- Consult a lawyer to guide you through the defense process.
Would you like help finding a lawyer in South Africa?