Equal Pay Dispute Clarified

Summary

Patricia, a logistics clerk, believes she should earn the same as Martin, the warehouse manager, despite his higher qualifications and senior position. Martins BComm degree and management diploma justify the pay difference. Unathis unresolved dismissal dispute will proceed to arbitration. FPSs lock-out of employees without due process is unprotected. Steve must prove discrimination as an unmarried single parent. Affirmative action promotes substantive equality. Workplace forums require over 100 employees. Essential service employees, like those in blood transfusion services, cannot strike. Hlabi’s Best Fruit is not a designated employer due to its turnover. Employers must disclose information to unions during collective bargaining. Fronting practices can lead to severe penalties. Independent contractors cannot form unions or strike. A physically able white male is not a designated group member. Affirmative action benefits groups based on listed discrimination grounds. Changing language policies to promote employment access is affirmative action. Black ownership requires 75% ownership by Black persons. Employees below the earnings threshold can refer discrimination claims to the CCMA

Full Conversation

Unathi has referred an unfair dismissal dispute to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration. The dispute is not settled at conciliation. The next step is: --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Unathi het ‘n onbillike ontslag dispuut na die Kommissie vir Versoening, Bemiddeling en Arbitrasie verwys. Die dispuut word nie tydens die versoeningsproses geskik nie. Die volgende stap is: Question 2Answer a. Unathi’s dispute will go on appeal to the Labour Court after the unsuccessful conciliation. / Unathi se dispuut sal op appèl gaan na die Arbeidshof na die onsuksesvolle versoeningsproses. b. Unathi’s dispute will be referred to arbitration by the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration. / Unathi se dispuut moet na die Kommissie vir Versoening, Bemiddeling en Arbitrasie verwys word vir arbitrasie. c. Unathi’s dispute will be closed following unsuccessful conciliation. / Unathi se dispuut sal gesluit wees na die onsuksesvolle versoeningsproses. d. Unathi’s dispute will be referred to adjudication by the Labour Court after the unsuccessful conciliation. / Unathi se dispuut moet na die Arbeidshof verwys word vir beoordeling na die onsuksesvolle versoeningsproses.
The correct option for Unathi's scenario is:
b.
Unathi’s dispute will be referred to arbitration by the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration. / Unathi se dispuut moet na die Kommissie vir Versoening, Bemiddeling en Arbitrasie verwys word vir arbitrasie.
Do you need more information on the arbitration process or have another question?
FPS (Pty) Ltd is negotiating with its employees regarding the value of the night shift allowance payable to employees working in the factory. FPS only offers an increase of R50 to the night shift allowance of R150. The employees demand an increase of R100 to the night shift allowance. The employees embark on a go-slow without having referred a dispute to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). In response to the go-slow, FPS locks the employees out of the workplace without following a process. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: FPS (Edms) Bpk onderhandel met sy werknemers aangaande die waarde van die aandskof-toelaag wat betaalbaar is aan werknemers wat in die fabriek werk. FPS bied slegs ‘n toename van R50 tot die aandskof-toelaag van R150 aan. Die werknemers dring aan op ‘n toename van R100 tot die aandskof-toelaag. Die werknemers begin met vertragingstaktieke sonder om ‘n dispuut na die Kommissie vir Versoening, Bemiddeling en Arbitrasie (KVBA) te verwys. In reaksie op die vertragingstaktieke sluit FPS die werknemers uit die werkplek uit sonder om ‘n proses te volg. Question 3Answer a. The lock-out is a legal lock-out. / Die uitsluiting is ‘n wettige uitsluiting. b. The lock-out is a protected lock-out. / Die uitsluiting is ‘n beskermde uitsluiting. c. The lock-out is an illegal lock-out. / Die uitsluiting is ‘n onwettige uitsluiting. d. The lock-out is an unprotected lock-out. / Die uitsluiting is ‘n onbeskermde uitsluiting.
The correct option for FPS (Pty) Ltd’s scenario is:
d.
The lock-out is an unprotected lock-out. / Die uitsluiting is ‘n onbeskermde uitsluiting.
Since FPS locked out the employees without following due process, the lock-out lacks protection under the Labour Relations Act.
Do you need more information on the legal implications of unprotected lock-outs?
Steve’s employer has recently introduced a car allowance for all employees. Employees who are married with children are entitled to a car allowance of *% of their monthly salary, whereas unmarried employees are entitled to a car allowance of *% of their monthly salary. Steve is an unmarried single parent and believes that the employer’s actions are discriminatory. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Steve se werkgewer het onlangs ‘n motor-toelaag ingestel vir alle werknemers. Werknemers wat getroud is met kinders is geregtig op ‘n motor-toelaag van *% van hulle maandelikse salaris, terwyl ongetroude werknemers geregtig is op ‘n motor-toelaag van *% van hulle maandelikse salaris. Steve is ‘n ongetroude enkelouer en glo dat die werkgewer se optrede diskriminerend is. Question 4Answer a. Because the employer differentiates between employees on the basis of an unlisted ground the onus will be on the employer to prove that the discrimination did not take place, or that their actions were otherwise rational and justified and therefore not unfair. / Omdat die werkgewer differensieer tussen werknemers gebaseer op ‘n ongelyste grond, sal die onus op die werkgewer wees om te bewys dat die diskriminasie nie plaasgevind het nie, of dat hulle optrede andersins rasioneel en regverdigbaar is en daarom nie onregverdig is nie. b. Because the employer differentiates between employees on the basis of a listed ground, the onus will be on the employer to prove that the discrimination did not take place, or that their actions were otherwise rational and justified and therefore not unfair. / Omdat die werkgewer differensieer tussen werknemers op grond van ‘n gelyste grond sal die onus op die werkgewer wees om te bewys dat die diskriminasie nie plaasgevind het nie, of dat hulle optrede andersins rasioneel en regverdigbaar was en daarom nie onregverdig was nie. c. Because the employer differentiates between employees on the basis of an unlisted ground, the onus will be on Steve to prove that discrimination took place and that the discrimination was unfair. / Omdat die werkgewer differensieer tussen werknemers gebaseer op ‘n ongelyste grond, sal die onus op Steve wees om te bewys dat diskriminasie plaasgevind het en dat die diskriminasie onregverdig was. d. Because the employer differentiates between employees on the basis of a listed ground the onus will be on Steve to prove that discrimination took place and that the discrimination was unfair. / Omdat die werkgewer differensieer tussen werknemers op grond van ‘n gelyste grond sal die onus op Steve wees om te bewys dat diskriminasie plaasgevind het en dat die diskriminasie onregverdig was.
Given the information, the most accurate option for Steve's scenario is:
**c.**
- Because the employer differentiates between employees on the basis of an unlisted ground, the onus will be on Steve to prove that discrimination took place and that the discrimination was unfair.
Moet jy meer inligting hê oor hoe om diskriminasie te bewys, of het jy ander vrae?
Affirmative action entails a duty on designated employers to promote formal equality. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Regstellende aksie behels ‘n plig op aangewese werkgewers om formele gelykheid te bevorder. Question 5Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. False / Onwaar**
Affirmative action entails a duty on designated employers to promote substantive equality, not just formal equality.
Do you need more information on affirmative action or any other legal issue?
A workplace forum may not be established in a firm of panel beaters which employs * employees. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Werkplekforum mag nie ingestel word nie in ‘n paneelkloppers-besigheid wat * werknemers het. Question 6Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
In hierdie geval is die korrekte opsie:
**b. Waar**
Volgens die Wet op Arbeidsverhoudinge (No. * van *) kan 'n werkplekforum slegs ingestel word in 'n werkplek waar die werkgewer meer as * werknemers in diens het. Aangesien die paneelkloppers-besigheid slegs * werknemers het, kan ‘n werkplekforum nie daar ingestel word nie.
Het jy enige ander vrae oor arbeidswetgewing of enige ander regsprobleme wat ek kan help verduidelik?
The employees of blood transfusion services are not allowed to strike. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Die werknemers van bloedoortappingsdienste word nie toegelaat om te staak nie. Question 7Answer a. True / Waar b. False / Onwaar
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. True / Waar**
According to South African labour laws, employees of essential services, such as blood transfusion services, are generally not allowed to strike.
Do you have any other legal questions or need more information on essential services and labour laws?
Choose the correct option: Hlabi’s Best Fruit (Pty) Ltd, a fruit farm in the Western Cape employs * employees and has an annual turnover of R2.* million. Hlabi’s Best Fruit is a designated employer in terms of the Employment Equity Act. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Hlabi’s Best Fruit (Edms) Bpk, ‘n vrugteplaas in die Wes-Kaap, het * werknemers in diens en het ‘n jaarlikse omset van R2.* miljoen. Hlabi’s Best Fruit is ‘n aangewese werkgewer in terme van die Wet op Diensbillikheid. Question 8Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. False / Onwaar**
- According to the Employment Equity Act, a "designated employer" is one that employs * or more employees or has an annual turnover exceeding the thresholds specified in Schedule * of the Act. For the agriculture sector, the threshold is R6 million. Since Hlabi’s Best Fruit has an annual turnover of R2.* million, it does not meet the threshold to be considered a designated employer solely based on turnover.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on the Employment Equity Act?
Choose the correct option: A trade union which represents domestic workers is engaged in collective bargaining against one of their members’ employers. The employer is not obliged to disclose information to the union. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Vakbond wat huishulpe verteenwoordig is betrokke in kollektiewe bedinging met die werkgewer van een van hul lede. Die werkgewer is nie verplig om inligting aan die vakbond te onthul nie. Question 9Answer a. True / Waar b. False / Onwaar
The correct option for Question * is:
**b. False / Onwaar**
- Under South African labour law, specifically the Labour Relations Act, employers are generally required to disclose relevant information to trade unions during collective bargaining, provided it is necessary for the union to effectively perform its duties.
Do you need more information on collective bargaining or any other legal matter?
Businesses which are found guilty of engaging in fronting practices can be fined up to *% of their annual turnover and be prohibited from doing business with state entities for up to 20 years. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Besighede wat skuldig bevind word daaraan dat hulle deelneem aan frontvoorbehouding kan beboet word tot en met *% van hulle jaarlikse omset en kan verbied word daarvan om besigheid te doen met staatsentiteite vir tot * jaar. Question 10Answer a. False | Onwaar b. True | Waar
Die korrekte opsie vir Vraag * is:
**b. True | Waar**
- Besighede wat skuldig bevind word aan frontvoorbehouding kan inderdaad beboet word tot en met *% van hulle jaarlikse omset en kan verbied word om besigheid met staatsentiteite te doen vir tot * jaar.
Het jy enige ander vrae of het jy meer inligting nodig oor frontvoorbehouding en die gepaardgaande wetgewing?
Choose the correct option: A group of independent contractors who provide a range of different services to a big mining company may form a trade union and engage in a protected strike against the employer. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Groep onafhanklike kontrakteurs wat ‘n verskeidenheid dienste aan ‘n groot mynmaatskappy lewer kan ‘n vakbond stig en deelneem aan ‘n beskermde staking teen die werkgewer. Question 11Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
Die korrekte opsie is:
**a. False / Onwaar**
- Onafhanklike kontrakteurs beskou nie as werknemers onder die Wet op Arbeidsverhoudinge nie en het dus nie dieselfde regte as werknemers om 'n vakbond te stig en aan 'n beskermde staking deel te neem nie.
Het jy enige ander vrae of benodig jy meer inligting oor arbeidsreg en regte vir kontrakteurs?
Choose the correct option: Which of the following persons is not a member of a designated group in terms of the Employment Equity Act? --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Welke van die volgende persone is nie ‘n lid van ‘n aangewese groep in terme van die Wet op Billike Diensgeleenthede nie? Question 12Answer a. A disabled coloured male / ‘n Gestremde bruin man b. A physically able Indian woman / ‘n Ongestremde Indiese vrou c. A physically able white male / ‘n Ongestremde wit man d. A physically able white female / ‘n Ongestremde wit vrou
The correct option for Question * is:
**c. A physically able white male / ‘n Ongestremde wit man**
- According to the Employment Equity Act, designated groups include black people (Africans, Coloureds, and Indians), women, and people with disabilities. Therefore, a physically able white male is not included.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on the Employment Equity Act?
The Employent Equity Act identifies the three ‘designated groups’ who may benefit from affirmative action. These three groups are all classified based on listed grounds of unfair discrimination. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Die Wet op Billike Diensgeleenthede identifiseer die drie ‘aangewese groepe’ wat mag baat by die toepassing van regstellende aksie. Hierdie drie groepe word almal geklassifiseer op grond van gelyste gronde van onbillike diskriminasie. Question 13Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
Die korrekte opsie vir Vraag * is:
**b. True / Waar**
- Die Wet op Billike Diensgeleenthede identifiseer swart mense (Afrikaans, Bruin, en Indiërs), vroue, en gestremde persone as aangewese groepe wat kan baat by regstellende aksie. Hierdie groepe word op grond van gelyste gronde van onbillike diskriminasie geklassifiseer.
Het jy enige ander vrae of benodig jy meer inligting oor die Wet op Billike Diensgeleenthede?
An employer who replaces an ‘Afrikaans only’ language policy in the workplace with an ‘English only’ language policy in order to assist in providing access to employment for black African persons is implementing affirmative action in terms of the Employment Equity Act. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Werkgewer wat ‘n ‘slegs Afrikaans’ taalbeleid in die werkplek vervang met ‘n ‘slegs Engels’ taalbeleid ten einde toegang tot die werkplek vir swart werknemers te bevorder implementeer regstellende aksie in terme van die Wet op Billike Diensgeleenthede. Question 14Answer a. True / Waar b. False / Onwaar
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. True / Waar**
- Replacing an 'Afrikaans only' language policy with an 'English only' policy to promote employment access for black African persons is considered affirmative action under the Employment Equity Act.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on affirmative action or employment law in the Western Cape?
Choose the correct option: A business will be considered to be black owned if at least *% of the business is owned by Black persons. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Besigheid sal beskou word om in swart-besit te wees indien minstens *% van die besigheid deur Swart persone besit word. Question 15Answer a. False | Onwaar b. True | Waar
The correct option for Question * is:
**b. True | Waar**
A business is considered black-owned if at least *% of the business is owned by Black persons.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on business ownership criteria in the Western Cape?
Choose the correct option: Employees who earn less than the earnings threshold amount (as determined in terms of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act) per year may refer unfair discrimination claims to the CCMA for arbitration. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Werknemers wat minder verdien as die vergoedingsdrempel bedrag (soos vasgestel in terme van die Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes) per jaar kan ‘n onbillike diskriminasie eis na die KVBA (CCMA) verwys vir arbitrasie. Question 16Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
**b. True / Waar**
- Werknemers wat minder verdien as die vergoedingsdrempel bedrag soos vasgestel in terme van die Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes mag inderdaad ‘n onbillike diskriminasie eis na die KVBA (CCMA) verwys vir arbitrasie.
Het jy enige ander vrae of benodig jy meer inligting oor arbeidswetgewing in die Wes-Kaap?
Choose the correct option: An employer establishes a staff pension fund for monthly-paid employees, and a separate staff provident fund for weekly-paid employees. Contributions per employee by the employer to the pension fund is double the contribution made to the provident fund. Only *% of the monthly-paid employees are women, whereas *% of the weekly-paid employees are women. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Werkgewer skep ‘n personeelpensioenfonds vir maandeliks-betaalde werknemers en ‘n afsonderlike personeelvoorsorgfonds vir weekliks-betaalde werknemers. Bydraes per werknemer deur die werkgewer aan die pensioenfonds is dubbeld soveel as die bydrae deur die werkgewer aan die voorsorgfonds. Slegs *% van die maandeliks-betaalde werknemers is vroue, terwyl *% van die weekliks-betaalde werknemers vroue is. Question 17Answer a. The employer indirectly unfairly discriminates against women on the basis of gender. / Daar word indirek op die basis van geslag, onbillik deur die werkgewer teen die vroue gediskrimineer. b. The employer indirectly discriminates fairly against women on the basis of gender. / Daar word indirek op die basis van geslag, billik deur die werkgewer teen die vroue gediskrimineer. c. The employer directly unfairly discriminates against women on the basis of gender. / Daar word direk op die basis van geslag, onbillik deur die werkgewer teen die vroue gediskrimineer. d. The employer’s actions do not amount to discrimination. / Die werkgewer se optrede is nie diskriminerend nie.
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. The employer indirectly unfairly discriminates against women on the basis of gender. / Daar word indirek op die basis van geslag, onbillik deur die werkgewer teen die vroue gediskrimineer.**
- The contributions disparity between the pension and provident funds indirectly discriminates against women, as a higher percentage of women are in the lower-contributing provident fund.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on employment equity or discrimination?
Choose the correct option: The following is an example of an interest dispute that should be the subject of collective bargaining: --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: Die volgende is ‘n voorbeeld van ‘n belangegeskil wat besleg moet word by wyse van kollektiewe bedinging: Question 18Answer a. A trade union claims that the employer acted unfairly in not promoting two of its members / ‘n Vakbond voer aan dat die werkgewer onbillik opgetree het deur nie twee van hul lede te bevorder nie. b. A trade union is unhappy because one of its members was unfairly dismissed / ‘n Vakbond is ongelukkig omdat een van hul lede onbillik ontslaan is. c. A trade union claims that the employer has breached provisions of legislation dealing with safety in the workplace / ‘n Vakbond voer aan dat die werkgewer statutêre bepalings met bettrekking tot veiligheid in die werksplek verbreek het. d. A trade union demands that a travel allowance that only senior managers are entitled to must be extended to all employees in the workplace / ‘n Vakbond dring aan daarop dat ‘n vervoertoelaag wat slegs beskikbaar is vir senior bestuurders uitgebrei moet word na alle werknemers in die werksplek.
The correct option for Question * is:
**d. A trade union demands that a travel allowance that only senior managers are entitled to must be extended to all employees in the workplace / ‘n Vakbond dring aan daarop dat ‘n vervoertoelaag wat slegs beskikbaar is vir senior bestuurders uitgebrei moet word na alle werknemers in die werksplek.**
- This is an example of an interest dispute, as it pertains to the terms and conditions of employment and is typically addressed through collective bargaining.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on collective bargaining or employment law in the Western Cape?
Choose the correct option: John was dismissed for assault in the workplace, and he brings an unfair dismissal claim to the CCMA. John wants his legal representative to represent him at the arbitration, but the employer does not agree to it. John will not be entitled to be represented by the legal representative. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: John is ontslaan vir aanranding in die werkplek, en hy neem ‘n saak van onbillike ontslag na die KVBA. John wil hê dat sy regsverteenwoordiger hom moet verteenwoordig by die arbitrasie, maar die werkgewer weier om daartoe in te stem. John sal nie geregtig wees om verteenwoordig te word deur die regsverteenwoordiger nie. Question 19Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
Choose the correct option:
John was dismissed for assault in the workplace, and he brings an unfair dismissal claim to the CCMA. John wants his legal representative to represent him at the arbitration, but the employer does not agree to it. John will not be entitled to be represented by the legal representative.
---------------------------------------
Kies die korrekte opsie:
John is ontslaan vir aanranding in die werkplek, en hy neem ‘n saak van onbillike ontslag na die KVBA. John wil hê dat sy regsverteenwoordiger hom moet verteenwoordig by die arbitrasie, maar die werkgewer weier om daartoe in te stem. John sal nie geregtig wees om verteenwoordig te word deur die regsverteenwoordiger nie.
Question 19Answer
a.
False / Onwaar
b.
True / Waar
---
The correct option is:
**a. False / Onwaar**
- At the CCMA arbitration, a party is generally entitled to legal representation, especially in cases of dismissal for misconduct or incapacity. The employer's objection alone does not determine John's right to representation.
Do you have any other questions or need more information on CCMA procedures or legal representation rules?
Choose the correct option: A party to proceedings in the Labour Court may not be represented by a fellow member of a trade union, and must be represented by a legal practitioner. --------------------------------------- Kies die korrekte opsie: ‘n Party tot verrigtinge in die Arbeidshof mag nie verteenwoordig word deur ‘n mede-lid van ‘n vakbond nie, en moet verteenwoordig word deur ‘n regspraktisyn. Question 20Answer a. False / Onwaar b. True / Waar
The correct option for Question * is:
**a. False / Onwaar**
- In the Labour Court, a party may be represented by a fellow member of a trade union or an employer's organization, and not exclusively by a legal practitioner.
Do you need more information on representation rights in the Labour Court or any other legal matters?