Judicial Advice Limitations

Summary

Judges not involved in a case should not advise petitioners to maintain impartiality and avoid conflicts of interest. Unauthenticated text messages may not be admissible as evidence, but the final decision rests with the judge. Consult a local attorney for specific advice.

Full Conversation

Can a judge not involved in a case advise a petitoner
Hello Mike,
Generally, a judge who is not involved in a case should not provide advice to a petitioner. This is due to the need for impartiality and to avoid conflicts of interest. However, laws may vary based on location. Could you please let me know where you are located?
Florida
Hello Mike,
In Florida:
- Judges not involved in a case generally should not advise a petitioner.
- They must uphold impartiality and avoid conflicts of interest.
- Any advice could potentially breach Judicial Conduct Code Rule *.*.
Please consult a lawyer for specific advice.
Are text messages without a date or time admissable?
Hello Mike,
In Florida, the admissibility of text messages without a date or time can vary. Factors may include:
- The content and context of the messages.
- The ability to authenticate the sender and recipient.
It's best to consult a local attorney for advice.
What if unauthenticated texts were used in complaint?
Hello Mike,
In Florida, unauthenticated texts might not be admissible as evidence. However, the final decision rests with the judge who may consider:
- The reliability of the source.
- The context of the texts.
- Any corroborating evidence.
Please consult with a local attorney for more nuanced advice.