Mutual Joint Wills Validity

Summary

Mutual joint wills, especially those unchanged over time, can hold significant evidentiary value in establishing intent. In New York, these wills are often seen as binding contracts once one party dies, preventing the survivor from altering the distribution plan. Courts respect long-standing wills if they clearly express the testators intentions. For specific case law, consulting a legal expert is advisable.

Full Conversation

DOES THE FACT THAT A WILL WAS CREATED AND FILED IN * AND WAS MAINTAINED UNTIL PARENTS' DEATH WITHOUT ANY CHANGES HAVE AN EVIDENTIARY VALUE IN * IN ESTABLISHING INTENT
Hi ****! Yes, a will created and maintained without changes can have evidentiary value in establishing intent, as it may reflect the testator's consistent wishes over time. Courts often consider the lack of changes as evidence of the testator's stable intent. Is there any specific aspect you're concerned about regarding this will?
IT IS A MUTUAL JOINT WILL THAT STATED We give, devise and bequeath to the survivor of us absolutely all the rest, residue and remainder of the property which we may individually or collectively own or which we may individually or collectively be entitled to, at the death of the first of us to die, or which either of our estates may be entitled to receive after death. After the death of the survivor of us, all the property, both real and personal, of whatsoever nature remaining, shall go to our children share and share alike, to be theirs absolutely and forever, per stirpes
Thank you for sharing the details, ****. Here's some general information regarding mutual wills and their evidentiary value:
- Mutual wills are agreements between two individuals, often spouses, to distribute their estates in a specified manner.
- Courts generally regard such wills as binding contracts once one party has passed away, preventing the survivor from altering the distribution plan.
- The fact that the will was maintained unchanged since * can support the intent and agreement between the parties.
Do you have concerns about how this mutual will might be contested or enforced?
CAN YOU PROVIDE CURRENT OR CONSISTENT CASELAW ABOUT HOW NEW YORK COURTS TREAT OLD MUTUAL JOINT WILLS THAT WERE NEVER CHANGED THOUGH THE YEARS
Case Rating: *
While I can't provide specific case law, here are some general principles related to mutual joint wills in New York:
- Mutual wills are considered binding contracts once one party dies, often preventing changes by the survivor.
- Courts may enforce the will's terms if there's evidence of intent and agreement.
- Long-standing wills are typically respected if they clearly express the testators' intentions.
For specific case law, consulting a legal expert or lawyer is advisable. If you have further concerns, feel free to ask!