Insurance Policy Cancellation Dispute

Summary

If your auto insurance was canceled due to communication issues, you may have grounds to dispute the cancellation and seek coverage for an accident. Consider filing a complaint with the Arizona Department of Insurance and consult with an attorney specializing in insurance disputes. Include details of the incident, communication records, and evidence of damages in your complaint. If you lack funds for legal representation, evaluate settlement offers carefully and consider the strength of your case.

Full Conversation

Julie
Hi Julie! How can I assist you with your legal issue today?
I was renewing my *-month auto insurance policy. The office informed me that a new policy required the clients to sign an authorization document. The insurance agent's employee sent the document through the Postal service to an old address. Then, the insurance employee emailed the document to me on May *. I asked her to send me a DocuSign on April * because I had no printer. I didn't get an email response, so on June *, I called her, and she said that if I didn't get them a signed authorization document, my car insurance would be canceled on May 24th for nonpayment. Then, on May *, I got into an accident, and ultimately, my insurance was canceled for nonpayment.
It sounds like there might have been a communication issue and possible negligence by your insurance company. You may have grounds to dispute the cancellation and seek coverage for your accident.
Have you considered filing a complaint with the Arizona Department of Insurance or consulting with an attorney specializing in insurance disputes?
I lack the funds to hire an attorney. I filed a civil lawsuit, and the defendant's attorney tried to settle for $*,*.
Julie, it looks like you might have a strong case based on the communication issues and potential negligence. Before deciding to settle, consider the following:
- Review the details of the settlement offer.
- Evaluate your actual damages and the strength of your evidence.
- Consider filing a complaint with the Arizona Department of Insurance.
Would you like more information on how to file a complaint or details on steps to take next?
yes
You can file a complaint with the Arizona Department of Insurance to report the issue and seek assistance.

Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI)


Phone: (*) *-*
Website: https://difi.az.gov/

Would you like guidance on what to include in your complaint or how to proceed further?
The cost to repair both cars is approximately $*,*
Julie, to proceed with your complaint to the Arizona Department of Insurance, include the following details:
- A clear, concise description of the events.
- Dates and communication records with the insurance company.
- Copies of the documents and emails exchanged.
- The total cost of damages ($*,*) and how the cancellation affected your coverage.
Would you like help drafting this complaint or further steps to take?
yes thank you
Case Rating: *
Certainly, Julie! Here's a brief outline to help draft your complaint:
Complaint Draft Outline:
*. Introduction:
- Your name and contact information.
- Policy details (policy number, insurance company details).
*. Incident Description:
- Timeline of events (dates of communication, document requests, and response times).
- Details of the accident on May *, including the circumstances and damages.
*. Communication Issues:
- Specific communication lapses (e.g., delay in document delivery, lack of response to DocuSign request).
*. Impact of Cancellation:
- Direct impact on you (e.g., lack of coverage during the accident, financial burden).
*. Supporting Evidence:
- Attach copies of emails, documents, and any other relevant communication records.
*. Conclusion:
- State the resolution you seek (e.g., reinstatement of coverage, compensation for damages).
Would you like further assistance on any specific section or additional information?
are thinking about how to respond
Julie, here's a draft outline for your complaint to the Arizona Department of Insurance:
*. Introduction: Briefly explain who you are and your policy details.
*. Issue Description:
- Renewal process and new policy requirements.
- Miscommunication and delays from the insurance company.
- Details of the accident and subsequent claim denial.
*. Evidence Summary:
- Dates and communication records.
- Relevant documents and emails.
*. Impact:
- Cost of damages ($*,*).
- Effects of the insurance cancellation.
Would you like any specific wording or further assistance with this outline?
Please help with drafting this complaint and further steps to take
Sure, Julie! Here's a draft for your complaint to the Arizona Department of Insurance:
---
To: Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI)
Phone: (*) *-*
Website: [https://difi.az.gov/](https://difi.az.gov/)
Subject: Complaint Against [Insurance Company Name] for Policy Cancellation and Denial of Claim
Dear Sir/Madam,
I, Julie [Last Name], am writing to file a formal complaint against [Insurance Company Name] regarding the wrongful cancellation of my auto insurance policy, and the subsequent denial of my claim following an accident on May *, *.
Details of the Complaint:
- Policy Renewal Miscommunication: On April *, *, I requested the insurance agent's employee to send me the authorization document via DocuSign, as I did not have a printer. Instead, the document was sent through the Postal Service to an old address and later emailed to me on May *.
- Lack of Response: Despite my follow-up, I received no email response and was informed over the phone on June * that my car insurancewould be canceled on May * for nonpayment if the signed document was not received.
- Accident and Claim Denial: On May *, *, I was involved in an accident. When I reported the incident and opened a claim, I was informed by the claims adjuster that my coverage had been canceled due to nonpayment.
- Miscommunication and Negligence: Despite having signed the authorization document on May *, the payment was not processed as confirmed by the employees and Dan Hakes, leading to the wrongful cancellation of my policy.
Impact:
- Damages: The cost to repair both involved cars is approximately $*,*.
- Stress and Inconvenience: The mishandling of my policy renewal and the lack of proper communication have caused significant stress and financial burden.
Attachments:
- Copies of all relevant documents and email communications.
- Evidence of the signed authorization document.
- Details and cost estimates for the damages incurred.
I request your urgent intervention to investigate this matter, ensure the insurance company honors my claim, and take appropriate action against the company for their negligence.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Julie [Last Name]
[Contact
This is from the insurance companies lawyer:
Julie, it seems like you have a strong case with clear evidence of mishandling and potential negligence by the insurance company. Make sure to include all relevant documents and communication records when you submit your complaint.
Would you like any additional assistance regarding the steps to take after filing the complaint?