Negligence Claim Legal Considerations
Summary
To file a negligence claim in Lagos State, Nigeria, consider the following: establish a reasonable cause of action, identify parties, and ensure locus standi. Verify the statute of limitations, which is generally five years under Section 8(1) of the Limitation Law of Lagos State. Seek relief for damages, gather evidence, and exhaust available remedies. Understand jurisdiction, applicable laws, and procedural requirements. File a statement of claim, serve the defendant, and follow court procedures. The elements of negligence include duty of care, breach, causation, and damages. A statement of claim outlines the facts, legal basis, and relief sought.Full Conversation
Look at this scenario and consider the following preliminary considerations.
PRELIMINARY CONSIDERATIONS BEFORE COMMENCING CIVIL ACTION
*.) Existence of a reasonable cause of action – Area of Law, Elements:
*.)Parties - Legal personality, capacity, etc.:
*.)Locus standi:
*.)Statutory limitation:
*.)Reliefs to be sought:
*.)Available evidence:
*.)Exhaustion of all available remedies, the availability of alternative dispute resolution
mechanisms, and need to preserve previous relationship:
*.)Cost of litigation, length of time it may take to conclude litigation, and cost of enforcing judgement:
*.) Jurisdiction and Venue – Subject matter, Parties, Territorial, Monetary, etc.:
*.) Applicable and relevant laws – Substantive laws and Procedural laws:
*.) Mode and procedure for commencing the action:
*.) Satisfaction of all conditions precedent, such as pre-action notice, pre-action counseling protocol
form, proper signing, NBA seal, etc.:
SCENARIO
Mr. John Ibe walks into your law office and narrates to you that he was in the business of supplying aluminum roofing sheets and other building materials to building contractors, so on the 20th of
September, *, he was on his way to attend a business meeting with Almaco Industrial Services Limited for the conclusion of a business deal involving roofing sheets and building materials worthmillions of Naira.
On that fateful day while driving his vehicle, a Black Toyota Hillux Pick-up Truck * Model with Engine
Registration No: ABC *, and he was to pass through the Ikeja Express Road. Upon getting to the Ikeja Express Road he was unaware that Julius Berger Construction Company Limited, a construction company which was contracted by the Government of Lagos State to make repairs on the Ikeja Express Road, had poured a slippery black substance on the road later identified as bitumen as part of the
repairs being carried out on the road.
As a result of the said bitumen on the road, the road was slippery and as a result, Mr. John Ibe lost
control of his car and the vehicle veered off the road resulting in a ghastly auto crash in which his vehicle was totally wrecked and damaged and numerous injuries were sustained by him and he was rushed to the hospital.
Mr. John Ibe insists that there were no road signs along the road to warn any oncoming and ongoing vehicles of the slippery substance on the said road. He also said that upon inquiries after the said accident, it was observed that the natives and some road users, resident within the said environs of the auto crash scene had raised alarms on account of the manner in which the company poured the said bitumen, pointing out the obvious dangers that may result from it, but the company bluntly failed to listen to them and take any necessary action.
He also found out that one of the witnesses to the car crash, Mr. Peter Okoro reported the crash to the
Police, who accompanied him to the Construction Company’s Office at Ikeja, very close to the scene of the accident, and complained to the Project Manager and other Senior Staff about the incident, but regrettably, the said staff of the Company accompanied them to the scene but did nothing regarding the damage done to Mr. John Ibe and other affected persons except to pour sharp sand on the affected areas which was an afterthought.
The Police then went ahead to write a report of the incident on the 23rd of August, * which was signed by one DSP Tunde Oche, the Divisional Police Officer attached to the Police Station in Ikeja.
As a result of the accident, Mr. John Ibe lost out in the scheduled business meeting with Almaco Industrial
Services Limited as he could not continue the journey to the business meeting as already scheduled:
The damage of his vehicle made it such that he could no longer meet up with other business engagements and this seriously occasioned hardship on him and his family, coupled with the serious health damage as a result of the physical and mental injuries sustained in the auto crash and the hefty sums that were paid for treatment of the said injuries.
Mr. John Ibe wrote to the Company on the 24th of January, *, demanding compensation for the
damages suffered by him, but the company blatantly refused.
He has now come to you to sue the Company no matter what it takes.
Given the scenario, Mr. John Ibe appears to have a strong case to sue Julius Berger Construction Company Limited for negligence. Here are some preliminary considerations for the civil action:
- Reasonable Cause of Action: Negligence.
- Parties: Mr. John Ibe (Plaintiff) vs. Julius Berger Construction Company Limited (Defendant).
- Locus Standi: Mr. John Ibe is directly affected.
- Statutory Limitation: Verify the statute of limitations for negligence claims in Lagos State, Nigeria.
- Reliefs to be Sought: Compensation for vehicle damage, medical expenses, lost business opportunities, and mental anguish.
- Available Evidence: Police report, witness statements, medical records, photographs of the accident scene.
- Exhaustion of Remedies: Demand letter already sent and ignored.
- Cost and Time: Assess the potential cost and time for litigation.
- Jurisdiction and Venue: Lagos State courts should have jurisdiction.
- Applicable Laws: Nigerian tort laws.
- Mode and Procedure: File a negligence claim.
- Conditions Precedent: Ensure all pre-action notices and procedural requirements are met.
Would you like more detailed information on any specific point?
- Reasonable Cause of Action: Negligence.
- Parties: Mr. John Ibe (Plaintiff) vs. Julius Berger Construction Company Limited (Defendant).
- Locus Standi: Mr. John Ibe is directly affected.
- Statutory Limitation: Verify the statute of limitations for negligence claims in Lagos State, Nigeria.
- Reliefs to be Sought: Compensation for vehicle damage, medical expenses, lost business opportunities, and mental anguish.
- Available Evidence: Police report, witness statements, medical records, photographs of the accident scene.
- Exhaustion of Remedies: Demand letter already sent and ignored.
- Cost and Time: Assess the potential cost and time for litigation.
- Jurisdiction and Venue: Lagos State courts should have jurisdiction.
- Applicable Laws: Nigerian tort laws.
- Mode and Procedure: File a negligence claim.
- Conditions Precedent: Ensure all pre-action notices and procedural requirements are met.
Would you like more detailed information on any specific point?
Elements of Negligence under Nigerian law and the section that backs it off.
Elements of Negligence under Nigerian Law:
*. Duty of Care - The defendant owed a legal duty to the plaintiff.
*. Breach of Duty - The defendant breached that duty.
*. Causation - The breach caused harm or damage to the plaintiff.
*. Damages - The plaintiff suffered actual harm or damage.
*. Duty of Care - The defendant owed a legal duty to the plaintiff.
*. Breach of Duty - The defendant breached that duty.
*. Causation - The breach caused harm or damage to the plaintiff.
*. Damages - The plaintiff suffered actual harm or damage.
Relevant Sections:
- Common Law: Nigerian negligence law is largely based on common law principles found in English law.
- Nigerian Civil Code: Specific sections may not exist, but general tort principles apply.
Would you like information on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
- Common Law: Nigerian negligence law is largely based on common law principles found in English law.
- Nigerian Civil Code: Specific sections may not exist, but general tort principles apply.
Would you like information on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
Statutes of limitations for negligence under Lagos state?
The statute of limitations for negligence claims in Lagos State, Nigeria, is generally five years from the date the cause of action arose. This means Mr. John Ibe should file a lawsuit within five years from the date of the accident.
Do you need more details on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
Do you need more details on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
Which section under Lagos state law states that.
Lagos State does not have a specific statute codifying the limitation period for negligence claims. Instead, the Limitation Law of Lagos State, often referenced, generally applies. Relevant sections include:
- Section *(*): Actions founded on simple contract or tort shall not be brought after the expiration of five years from the date the cause of action accrued.
Would you like more information on how to file the lawsuit?
- Section *(*): Actions founded on simple contract or tort shall not be brought after the expiration of five years from the date the cause of action accrued.
Would you like more information on how to file the lawsuit?
Section * (*) of which act?
Section *(*) is part of the Limitation Law of Lagos State. This section states that actions founded on simple contract or tort shall not be brought after the expiration of five years from the date the cause of action accrued.
Would you like more details on how to file the lawsuit or any other aspect?
Would you like more details on how to file the lawsuit or any other aspect?
What do they mean as exhaustion of remedies under the preliminary considerations for a civil suit?
Exhaustion of remedies means that before filing a lawsuit, a plaintiff must attempt to resolve the issue through all other available avenues. This could include:
- Sending a demand letter
- Attempting mediation or arbitration
- Using any internal grievance procedures
In Mr. John Ibe's case, he has already sent a demand letter, which was ignored. This fulfills the requirement of attempting to exhaust remedies before proceeding with a civil suit.
Would you like more details on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
- Sending a demand letter
- Attempting mediation or arbitration
- Using any internal grievance procedures
In Mr. John Ibe's case, he has already sent a demand letter, which was ignored. This fulfills the requirement of attempting to exhaust remedies before proceeding with a civil suit.
Would you like more details on how to proceed with the lawsuit?
What do they mean by mode and procedures as one of the preliminary considerations for the civil suit.
"Mode and procedures" refer to the specific steps and formalities required to initiate a civil lawsuit. This includes:
- Filing the appropriate legal documents (pleadings).
- Serving the defendant with the lawsuit.
- Following court rules for submitting evidence and motions.
- Adhering to procedural timelines set by the court.
Do you need more details on any of these aspects?
- Filing the appropriate legal documents (pleadings).
- Serving the defendant with the lawsuit.
- Following court rules for submitting evidence and motions.
- Adhering to procedural timelines set by the court.
Do you need more details on any of these aspects?
What are the modes and procedures of the suit above?
Case Rating: *.
Here are the modes and procedures for Mr. John Ibe's civil suit:
- File a Claim: Draft a statement of claim detailing the negligence and damages.
- Court Filing: Submit the claim to the appropriate court in Lagos State.
- Service of Process: Serve the defendant (Julius Berger Construction Company Limited) with the lawsuit.
- Court Appearance: Attend preliminary hearings and follow court directions.
- Evidence Submission: Present all relevant evidence (e.g., police report, witness statements, medical records).
- Trial: Attend the trial, where both parties present their cases.
- Judgment: Await the court's decision and any possible appeals.
Would you like more detailed guidance on any particular step?
Here are the modes and procedures for Mr. John Ibe's civil suit:
- File a Claim: Draft a statement of claim detailing the negligence and damages.
- Court Filing: Submit the claim to the appropriate court in Lagos State.
- Service of Process: Serve the defendant (Julius Berger Construction Company Limited) with the lawsuit.
- Court Appearance: Attend preliminary hearings and follow court directions.
- Evidence Submission: Present all relevant evidence (e.g., police report, witness statements, medical records).
- Trial: Attend the trial, where both parties present their cases.
- Judgment: Await the court's decision and any possible appeals.
Would you like more detailed guidance on any particular step?
What is a statement of claim?
A statement of claim is a legal document filed by the plaintiff in a civil lawsuit. It outlines the details of the plaintiff's case, including:
- The facts of the case
- The legal basis for the claim
- The specific relief or damages sought
Would you like more details on how to draft a statement of claim?
- The facts of the case
- The legal basis for the claim
- The specific relief or damages sought
Would you like more details on how to draft a statement of claim?
Sample of a statement of claim?
Here's a simplified sample of a statement of claim for Mr. John Ibe's case:
---
IN THE HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE
HOLDEN AT IKEJA
SUIT NO: [insert suit number]
BETWEEN
MR. JOHN IBE
(Plaintiff)
AND
JULIUS BERGER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED
(Defendant)
---
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
*. Parties:
- The Plaintiff is Mr. John Ibe, a businessman residing in Lagos State.
- The Defendant is Julius Berger Construction Company Limited, with its principal office located at [insert address].
*. Facts:
- On September *, *, the Plaintiff was driving his vehicle, a Black Toyota Hilux Pick-up Truck * Model with Engine Registration No: ABC *, on Ikeja Express Road.
- The Plaintiff lost control of his vehicle due to a slippery substance (bitumen) poured on the road by the Defendant, resulting in a ghastly auto crash.
- There were no road signs warning of the slippery condition.
- The Plaintiff sustainedserious injuries and his vehicle was completely wrecked.
*. Negligence:
- The Defendant owed a duty of care to road users, including the Plaintiff.
- The Defendant breached this duty by failing to provide adequate warnings and safety measures.
- The breach directly caused the Plaintiff's accident and injuries.
*. Damages:
- The Plaintiff incurred significant medical expenses, lost business opportunities, and suffered physical and mental anguish.
- The Plaintiff's vehicle was totally damaged.
*. Relief Sought:
- Compensation for medical expenses.
- Compensation for the damaged vehicle.
- Compensation for lost business opportunities.
- Damages for physical and mental suffering.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff claims against the Defendant as follows:
- The sum of [insert amount] as compensation for medical expenses and vehicle damage.
- The sum of [insert amount] for lost business opportunities.
- General damages for physical and mental suffering.
- Costs of this suit.
- Any other relief the court deems fit.
DATED THIS [insert date] DAY OF [insert month], *.
__________________________
Plaintiff's Counsel
**[Law Firm Name]
---
IN THE HIGH COURT OF LAGOS STATE
HOLDEN AT IKEJA
SUIT NO: [insert suit number]
BETWEEN
MR. JOHN IBE
(Plaintiff)
AND
JULIUS BERGER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED
(Defendant)
---
STATEMENT OF CLAIM
*. Parties:
- The Plaintiff is Mr. John Ibe, a businessman residing in Lagos State.
- The Defendant is Julius Berger Construction Company Limited, with its principal office located at [insert address].
*. Facts:
- On September *, *, the Plaintiff was driving his vehicle, a Black Toyota Hilux Pick-up Truck * Model with Engine Registration No: ABC *, on Ikeja Express Road.
- The Plaintiff lost control of his vehicle due to a slippery substance (bitumen) poured on the road by the Defendant, resulting in a ghastly auto crash.
- There were no road signs warning of the slippery condition.
- The Plaintiff sustainedserious injuries and his vehicle was completely wrecked.
*. Negligence:
- The Defendant owed a duty of care to road users, including the Plaintiff.
- The Defendant breached this duty by failing to provide adequate warnings and safety measures.
- The breach directly caused the Plaintiff's accident and injuries.
*. Damages:
- The Plaintiff incurred significant medical expenses, lost business opportunities, and suffered physical and mental anguish.
- The Plaintiff's vehicle was totally damaged.
*. Relief Sought:
- Compensation for medical expenses.
- Compensation for the damaged vehicle.
- Compensation for lost business opportunities.
- Damages for physical and mental suffering.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff claims against the Defendant as follows:
- The sum of [insert amount] as compensation for medical expenses and vehicle damage.
- The sum of [insert amount] for lost business opportunities.
- General damages for physical and mental suffering.
- Costs of this suit.
- Any other relief the court deems fit.
DATED THIS [insert date] DAY OF [insert month], *.
__________________________
Plaintiff's Counsel
**[Law Firm Name]